4 ms·
FB (and YT and Twitter) should never have been arbiters of discussion. They became privatized Ministries of Truth. It’s necessary for people to be able to dis
by mc32 5y ago
FB (and YT and Twitter) should never have been arbiters of discussion. They became privatized Ministries of Truth.
It’s necessary for people to be able to discuss topics even if wrong or uncomfortable in pursuit of truth. Yes, there will be bad faith actors, but they are better than a MoT setting truth.
This was totally idiotic and ideologically driven.
I hope a lesson was learned, but I fear it wasn’t and this will repeat itself because people can’t help but want to drive agendas.
- zackees 5y agoIt gets worse from here. Facebook whistleblowers stepped forward a few days ago and warned that “vaccine hesitancy” scores are being assigned to posts via AI and those with high scores don’t go viral. It doesn’t matter if the information is true or false, if the content discourages one from taking a vaccine the AIs will censor it.
- LorenPechtel 5y agoDiscuss, yes, but most of this isn't a discussion but a propaganda effort.
- mc32 5y agoBut they flagged proper researchers; how is that defensible? In addition whats the difference between foreign propaganda, domestic propaganda and corporate propaganda?
- namelessoracle 5y agoConsidering who/what countries actively invest in all forms of communication there is no meaningful line between the 3 anymore. Even domestic propaganda becomes suspect when you find out a government officials child has major business dealings with X or Y country. This happens in both parties.
- weasel_words 5y agoBut that is the whole point of the parent. Who is to say it is a "propaganda effort"? FB/TW/YT? Why? How would they know (unless they were part of that effort, ironically)?
- LorenPechtel 5y agoPart of the answer is looking for patterns and bots. When it's a few voices being amplified by a whole bunch of bots it's propaganda.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoHas this been decided by court/parliament/popular vote or any form of legitimate authority? The only thing worse than government sensorship is privatised mafia sensorship
- swiley 5y agoThey became that long ago when they started automatically curating feeds.
- dexen 5y agoTrue that. More to this, no automatically curated feed should qualify for the Section 230 protection. We understand that manually curated feed doesn't qualify for Section 230 protection. In this case, automatically curated feed should be legally the same, given that the automation is wholy created and maintained by Facebook or other relevant platform, for the express purpose of scaling out their manual processes.
- cvyT 5y agoTruth, Inc.
- _-david-_ 5y ago>FB (and YT and Twitter) should never have been arbiters of discussion. They became privatized Ministries of Truth. I think they knew there would be issues like this and they would sometimes get it wrong. This is why they tried to avoid being the Ministers of Truth by having so called "fact checkers" determine what is true. The credibility of these fact checkers and social media should both be tarnished.