4 ms·
Wait, you have to pay to have a baby in the US? The wealthiest country in the world cannot even pay for the birth of its own citizens? I can understand argume
by gambiting 5y ago
Wait, you have to pay to have a baby in the US?
The wealthiest country in the world cannot even pay for the birth of its own citizens?
I can understand arguments for private healthcare etc....but making people pay to give birth is insane.
- rootusrootus 5y agoTell me where it is completely free. And I don't mean paid for via taxes.
- gambiting 5y agoNo offense, but that's such a weird way of looking at it. Even in the US every reasonable adult would say that driving on public roads is free, right? But roads are maintained from taxes so how dare you call them free!!! It's the same thing here - other countries just pay for their citizens giving birth from taxes. The cost to you as a citizen is zero. No it's not free, someone pays for it. But I never used the word free anywhere, so I feel like you want to have an argument for the argument sake.
- rootusrootus 5y ago> every reasonable adult would say that driving on public roads is free, right? No? I certainly don't. I'm constantly aware of how much we don't spend on roads. Any conversation trashing the US for not having healthcare that is free-at-point-of-sale is meaningless without discussing the larger system. What can I say, I get tired of Europeans trashing the US using singular metrics as if they're a meaningful reflection of policy. You want to get into a more interesting conversation, let's talk about how the US citizenry is essentially subsidizing the universal healthcare that many other countries enjoy. That's not some political talking point, either, it's legitimate.
- gambiting 5y ago>>No? I certainly don't. I'm constantly aware of how much we don't spend on roads. Let me ask this then - is there anything in the world you would call free, or do you avoid the word out of principle? >>Any conversation trashing the US for not having healthcare that is free-at-point-of-sale is meaningless without discussing the larger system. I think you are purposefully trying to drag me into a discussion about a point I didn't make, I merely expressed surprise at the fact that United States of America, the wealthiest nation in the world, cannot even pay for the births of its own citizens. No statement anywhere about healthcare as such. If you want to read into it in my comment, then that's on you. >>You want to get into a more interesting conversation, let's talk about how the US citizenry is essentially subsidizing the universal healthcare that many other countries enjoy. Let's have that discussion then, please, I'm curious to hear your thoughts.
- linuxftw 5y agoThe US spends all of it's money that should be going to infrastructure and services on killing people overseas. We use migrant labor to produce crops below minimum wage, so large corporations can send Europe cheap produce.
- pedroma 5y agoWhy should I pay for other people's kids if I'm never going to have kids? The only people that should have to pay for those services are the people who actually use those services. For things that are unplanned like injuries (or even unplanned pregnancies), payment can be deferred if necessary and wages deducted straight from the paycheck to pay back for those services. Ideally, roads are that way too. People licensed should be charged a tax for road maintenance based on their odometer readings, or something to that effect. Or just use a Fastrak-type system where it automatically scans a device in your car when you get onto certain roads and charges you for that usage -- but do it in more places. Everyone else can get a very minimal tax for the upkeep of the administration in case few very people use these services.
- acuozzo 5y ago> Why should I pay for other people's kids if I'm never going to have kids? Medical Debt Up => Poverty Up => Crime Up => Incarceration Up => Paying for their imprisonment instead. You're protected by prisons, so you are a user of the service provided by them and must therefore pay under your model. > Ideally, roads are that way too. How would this work for e.g. Montana with seemingly-endless lengths of highway and a very low population density? … Let's take things a little further. Do you believe only private schools should exist?
- pedroma 5y ago>How would this work for e.g. Montana with seemingly-endless lengths of highway and a very low population density? Why would they need nice roads then? Seems like a waste of money to build a bunch of expensive roads for the 5,000 people who use them. They can manage with cheap roads and dirt roads that don't need much maintenance. The Chinese rural areas manage just fine with dirt roads, and those areas have way higher population densities. >You're protected by prisons, so you are a user of the service provided by them and must therefore pay under your model. Why should I pay for someone's crimes? It's such a stupid system. If they are murderers they should just receive the capital punishment. And if the crime is not murder, they can be put into factories where they are able produce something of value -- farming or whatever. If their business is not profitable it should at least reduce the taxpayer burden. I know this is dreamland ideal world logic, but working closer to this certainly doesn't hurt, with the alternative being they don't do anything at all and are pure leeches. Yes, I know they make license plates but surely they can do a little more than that with such a huge prison population. This also incentivizes training them and providing them skills when they leave prison -- if training them with skills will help the prison make money, why not? The inmate also leaves the prison with job prospects with many years of experience in a trade. >Do you believe only private schools should exist? Private schools have higher success rate for their graduates. There are other factors that play into this, obviously. Let me ask you this first - do you think public schools are doing poor kids any good? Especially in the inner cities where many poor black families live? I think any alternative is worth looking into to bring them out of poverty. Or you can just leave them to their devices.
- acuozzo 5y agoThe government doesn't send you a bill if you elect to have a baby at home. Most US citizens have babies in hospitals. Many either don't know that alternative options exist or think of them as dangerous / an unnecessary risk.