8 ms·
> Who has the right to tell me I must obey by some group's rules first (the union in this case)? In principle, no one. The whole idea of a union is everyone wa
by matheusmoreira 5y ago
> Who has the right to tell me I must obey by some group's rules first (the union in this case)?
In principle, no one. The whole idea of a union is everyone wants the same thing and will refuse to work if these wants are not met. If people want different things, the union doesn't actually exist.
> But unions can't have special privileges granted by politicians, and unions must never be mandatory to join.
> Mandate to join an union is immoral.
I agree in principle but in practice things get ugly fast. For example, developed countries have immigrant workers whose legal presence in the country is conditional on their continued employment. Corporations have a huge amount of leverage against these workers and will probably exploit them. Their ability to exploit these people leads to significantly diminished power of unions. I just have no idea how they're supposed to solve this issue in a way that keeps these principles intact.
- whitepaint 5y agoGood point. However, those immigrants wouldn't be in a country if it wasn't better than the alternative - which is their country. Of course it's not always the case, sometimes they are forced to which is fucking horrible. The exploitation of people is obviously wrong but I suspect the unions is not the answer.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoYeah, it sucks. The market is ruthless in exploiting economic disparities. For example, right now 1 USD is valued at 5.31 BRL. A salary of $20k/year is a ridiculous amount of money in my country. It's more than what the vast majority of people make working here. If corporations can exploit something like this, they can effectively reduce the value of their american workers. The solution in this case is to somehow make companies ignore these economic opportunities. Make them pay immigrants the same salary they'd pay a worker from their own country.