5 ms·
Primates change their 'accent' to avoid conflict
- SubiculumCode 5y agoThe in-group out-group fundamentals of society held deeply in our biology. Fascinating.
- datameta 5y agoTangentially, I am reminded of how acorn woodpeckers will have extended organized territorial war over a stockpile of acorns hidden in a tree and surrounding bands of birds will leave their own territories unattended to fly in and watch. https://phys.org/news/2020-09-acorn-woodpeckers-wage-days-long-vacant.html https://phys.org/news/2020-09-acorn-woodpeckers-wage-days-lo...
- thomascgalvin 5y agoI am very accent suggestible, but I also can't do accents to save my life. If I start talking to someone from the South, or the UK, there's alike a 75% chance I'm going to start (poorly) mimicking their speech, and I'm always worried they're going to think I'm making fun of them.
- type0 5y agoI start to talk with an accent when I'm around people speaking in accent, but it only happens under the influence of alcohol. Always puzzled me, not like I'm doing it deliberately, almost becomes a sort of shtick.
- vmception 5y agoI skip syllables for brevity after a little alcohol and people think I’m Bri’ish
- Moodles 5y agoWe Brits either ignore t’s or actually pronounce them as tee, whereas for Yankees it comes out as a dee for some reason. I did actually read somewhere that linguists think the British/American accent before America was a separate colony was most likely more similar to an American accent, so actually it was the Brits who diverged their accent.
- dboreham 5y agoThere are also today many accents and dialects in Britain. To my ear some US accents sound similar to Bristol and some Scottish accents but not at all like an English RP or London accents.
- vmception 5y agoI read that too, I think further research should look at the dutch because many dutch speaking English sound very American and their colony New Amsterdam was in what is now America even earlier.
- dkdbejwi383 5y agoIt’s more like they both divulged from a common ancestor, and are both equally different and alike. See also: humans didn’t diverge from chimpanzees, but both from a common ancestor.
- Moodles 5y agoOk? THat's probably somewhat accurate as accents are always changing, but I'm literally just citing what I read from some actual linguists.
- airhead969 5y agoI go from sounding like an average Londoner to speaking in Received Pronunciation. The only problem is I'm American and not in London. I have no idea how that happened.
- vmception 5y agoSame, I’m American in USA I just tell people I travel alot and my friends English from all over the world rubbed off on me. I would actually say that for a longer time I have consciously avoided regional slang, as American colloquial English is not usually any close to academic English and it is very easy not to notice. But Europeans have no clue what you’re saying if you are simultaneously slurring words, completely altering sentence structure, using idioms, and complete slang. So maybe it just gravitates towards an enunciated and generic international form of English? Skip a syllable and there it is.
- airhead969 5y agoMaybe we should form a band and call it: The Fake British Accents ? My paternal grandmother was from Cape Cod; lived in Britain, Germany, and the Philippines; and ended-up in San Jose, CA with a New Englander-British (no pun intended) accent. My dad had somewhat of a latent British accent from eating gristle and corporal punishment at an all-boys English boarding school. Two Norwegian brothers: one was my roommate, had lived in the US for 10 years, and always spoke English like he was drunk and still working on the language; the other had never been to the States before but sounded like he lived in the US for 90% of his life. I'm wondering if it's language speaking/interpretation plasticity skill are more innate to the individual. (I'm probably more like the first brother and sound like a rube in every language.)
- antihero 5y agoI'm British but when I am drunk people think I'm Australian.
- MetallicCloud 5y agoMy wife is exactly the same, and has the same concern. She's convinced if we moved to England, she'll involuntarily pick up their accent in a few months.
- shoto_io 5y agoSame here. German though. Most people are fine in my experience. 5% get irritated.
- the_only_law 5y agoI am from the south. Last weekend I was at bar, talking to someone from Miami, just generally shooting shit. A little later 2 men, who put bluntly but accurately looked redneck, asked me what I was drinking and my accent and diction suddenly shifted for a second. This sort of thing happens often, I’ll find myself speaking differently for different Uber drivers, etc. the accent also comes out while trying to portray certain emotions or when I’m particularly tired, which I wish I could suppress.
- every 5y agoWhen necessary or simply appropriate I too can downshift into the Texas vernacular...
- airhead969 5y agoWhat yall be talkin about, usin all them big, five-dollar, city words? Not one of them "cowboys" with a big hat and no cattle, I hope? ;) My mom's extended family has an actual long-horn herd around Seguin, so they get a pass on wearing boots and a Stetson. Meanwhile, my upstairs, sociopathic yuppie, mid-West hipster transplant neighbor walks around in cowboy boots on a solid floor for no reason (and no cattle) and has a man-bun despite it going out of fashion about 2016. I wouldn't even pretend to be a "cowboy" on Friday nights without actually roping and herding cattle, otherwise I'd feel like a poser. :Waves from ATX by way of SJC; parents by way of San Anton; grandparents by way of Nocona, Vernon, and Wichita Falls:
- Aloha 5y agoI like cowboy boots as a substitute for dress shows, a nice pair of dress boots are dress shoes that I can be on my feet on all day, without killing my feet (even ones with a high cut heel). I also have leather soled pre-aged oilskin boots that have been covered in mud at various points in their life (the best 50 bucks I ever spent - you cant go wrong with 50 dollar pair Tony Lama boots, the pre-aged material means they felt wore-in right from the first time I pulled them on) - yet clean up nice enough that I can wear them to a meeting, as well as rubber soled western style boots for work (two otherwise identical pairs, one in steel toe, the other in not steel toe - I loath the narrow toe box of the steel toe ones). That said, I don't wear boots or anything with a hard heel inside my house, for fear my downstairs neighbors would kill me in my sleep. ;-) As far as me? I'd love a ranch, with cattle, but in the mean time, I'm perfectly fine being all-hat, no-cattle, besides, a cowboy hat is practical here in Texas (was in Washington too), and frankly so are boots most of the time too, besides, western shirts generally look nice, and wear well too.
- dec0dedab0de 5y agoI am the same way, I first realized when I was talking to foreign tourists on the bus in Disney world and my parents yelled at me for mimicking their accent. I was like 8 or 9
- airhead969 5y agoI once made a car-full of IITians LTAOs at my "Indian" accent that they asked me to do when I normally don't. I grew-up with numerous accented English-speakers, and I found Indian was the easiest. I can't do Scottish, Welsh, or Irish to save my life.
- dkdbejwi383 5y ago> IITians LTAOs Sorry, but what does this mean? Also I don’t know which “Indian” accent you mean, but I find Welsh English and Hindi have a similar prosody
- andromaton 5y agoPeople that attended IIT in India. Laugh their a* off.
- dkdbejwi383 5y ago> IIT Indian Institutes of Technology, for those playing at home.
- vmception 5y agoLike, yeah, high key obvious ngl
- mensetmanusman 5y agoContext switching also helps in the real world.
- dvtrn 5y agoDid you mean code-switching? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Code-switching https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Code-switching
- Blikkentrekker 5y agoHow is this article not about “the real world”?
- abledon 5y agoi am a native english speaker, but sometimes when i speak to foreigners who have a thick accent and bad grammar, missing words in phrases, i sometimes, without my realization, start to talk in their style, breaking up my sentences to mimic theirs lol.
- samus 5y agoSimplifying sentences in speech is rarely an error. People seem to ignore 80% of what you put into a long sentence, and just notice the keywords. Therefore, relying on elaborate sentence patterns to get your point across will fail in many contexts, and especially in heated situations. And it can get even more difficult with non-native speakers.
- randomopining 5y agoHonestly I’ve noticed this recently living at home. If I talk like I would with friends in the big city, it comes off as too intense for slower family members. If I talk similar to them in that drawn out way with a slight simple suburb accent, they seem to like it better.
- dboreham 5y agoLike Madonna.
- birdyrooster 5y agoI feel like there is some good science regarding the phenomenon of these species sharing accents based on geography, but the summary feels like a stab in the dark as to why. To digress further... I don't see how this is so much to avoid conflict as it is to gain access to benefits from an out group by using mimicry. Think about cuckoo birds or other parasitic species, they aren't mimicking another species to avoid conflict. Some flowers to emit the scent of their pollinating species to attract them. Certainly other types of mimicry are to avoid conflict, like in the case of eyespot patterns, but does emulating accent fit more into which of these?
- airhead969 5y agoSo that's why my mom gets a Texan accent around her family. LOL. No, I'm serious. She doesn't normally until she's around certain extended family members. Edit: She has a neutral accent normally and then switches on Texan mode after being with certain family for awhile. My ears are like "Mom, are you Texan now or what?"
- tolbish 5y agoHumans also code switch to be a good "cultural fit".
- alexpetralia 5y agoWe certainly raise our pitch to avoid conflict.
- philshem 5y agoWe are primates, after all.
- kypro 5y agoGrowing up poor in the UK with a strong regional accent and working class mannerisms I kinda relate to this. I remember when I got to university and was around non-working class people for the first time I started getting a few comments about use of language and my accent. Being at uni though it was mostly harmless banter, but when I eventually got to the professional world it was completely different. The worst thing that ever happened was having an interview terminated early because of my use of language. I basically knew an answer to a question but couldn’t remember the world I needed and said something along the lines of, “s*t, what’s that called again?”. I think I would have got away with it to be honest but what pushed them over the edge is that when they asked me why I swore I was genuinely confused why they were asking. These days I’ve learnt to hide my accent and avoid all language I think could be problematic. I don’t even joke in the office anymore because I’ve found even my sense of humour to be problematic in a lot of cases. Then the other day a new guy started dropping the occasional f-bombs and for the first time in years I found myself reverting back to my old mannerisms and joking around with this guy because we share such similar social backgrounds. As a autist I’ve always thought it was kind of weird how saying “sup, dickheads” to my friends is seen as totally normal and actually a polite way to say hi but that would be extremely inappropriate in a middle-class workspace. And it does seem to be middle-class workplaces specifically because working retail and in other working class occupations as a teenager I never once had this problem.
- e40 5y agoAt age 12 I moved from KY to Miami. I was teased mercilessly until I got rid of my southern accent.
- Zababa 5y agoHaving worked at McDonald's at some point and now in an office, I saw the same thing. However I'm glad there's not much banter in the office, I have a really hard time adjusting my level of banter to things people still find funny but not offensive so I prefer not doing it.