6 ms·
>Hard to see how that could be true. In just about any field, computers today provide much better situational awareness than was possible in 1970. You sure abo
by Barrin92 5y ago
>Hard to see how that could be true. In just about any field, computers today provide much better situational awareness than was possible in 1970.
You sure about that?
https://twitter.com/hatr/status/1361756449802768387?s=20 https://twitter.com/hatr/status/1361756449802768387?s=20
>Waymo runs self driving cars today in very specific locations
Ernst Dickmann had autonomous cars on the road in very specific locations in the 1980s
https://youtu.be/_HbVWm7wdmE https://youtu.be/_HbVWm7wdmE
- dtech 5y agoI don't see how this is relevant. Computers in the 1970 had no situational awareness about people interviewing for jobs. So yes, that software might be crap, it still has infinitely more awareness.
- Barrin92 5y agowhat even is "infinitely more awareness?" is that an actual metric? Computers today have exactly as much awareness as they had in the 1970s, situational or otherwise, which is none. The algorithm in question does not know what a bookshelf is, does not know what a job interview is and it does not know how the two relate. It correlates a bunch of pixels and creates the illusion of having awareness, but this is an anthropomorphization and nothing more.
- croes 5y agoSo you are saying Computer 1970: 0 situational awareness Computer nowadays: 0 * infinity = undefined situational awareness. Pretty useless.
- gjm11 5y agoHow much would you bet that human interviewers' opinions of a candidate after a video interview wouldn't be affected if they were visibly in a room full of books? Or if they wore glasses, or had a painting hanging on the wall, or the various other things the researchers found made a difference to the AI's assessment? To be clear, I am super-skeptical about the ability of AI systems to do a good job of judging an interviewee's personality from a short video clip. But (1) this seems obviously to be a really hard problem, and one that couldn't even have been attempted in 1970, and (2) I am also pretty skeptical about the ability of human interviewers to do it.
- csmpltn 5y ago> "But (1) this seems obviously to be a really hard problem, and one that couldn't even have been attempted in 1970" Apollo 11 landed on the moon July 20th 1969. You think that didn't take a degree of "AI" and "ML"? Or maybe we just had a different name for these things back then... It's been 52 years since then. We're simply focusing on the wrong problems.
- CryptoPunk 5y agoI think that's just a matter of 1. resources and 2. risk tolerance. 1960s USA had a less superficial political culture, so was more willing to tolerate PR-sensitive risks in pursuing major technological achievements, and it could allocate a much larger proportion of GDP to the Apollo program, as government directed social welfare spending consumed a far smaller share of GDP: https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/what-is-driving-growth-in-government-spending/ https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/what-is-driving-growth-...
- rightbyte 5y agoThat project has way to little coverage. It is like the 70s automatic hamburger joint. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=FmXLqImT1wE https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=FmXLqImT1wE I recall some Ford(?) project which guided the cars by rail that was quite old.
- krallistic 5y agoIts easy to point at the bookshelf example and say "Haha AI is stupid", but its actually quite impressive. One could easily argue that most human interviewers have similar bias, and that it can detect such complex signals (books, glasses etc) IS impressive. The problem is this case is the data and/or wrong objectives, but the "AI" here has a lot of awareness, just on the "wrong" signals.
- klmadfejno 5y ago> You sure about that? Single dumb human posts singular dumb ai example to show that all ai are dumb and fails to recognize the irony.