4 ms·
> There were jokes aplenty about the ultra-wide distortion on the camera, but this is all a fairly cheap jab at what is really a very impressive bit of software
by smoldesu 5y ago
> There were jokes aplenty about the ultra-wide distortion on the camera, but this is all a fairly cheap jab at what is really a very impressive bit of software.
No, you know what, it isn't. I'll just say it, it's not impressive software at all, and the fact that they can't apply simple lens correction is a little embarrassing. In high school, I worked in a FIRST robotics club where we had to design, program and test our own computer vision models on robots, which would need to complete various tasks to varying degrees of precision. To that point, I have seen high-school Juniors write a program that can track your face in Python, it's really not some sort of mind-blowing, next gen thing.
Overall, I'm starting to really hate these Halide reviews. Their lifeline is based on the success of Apple hardware, why should they consider themselves a credible and unbiased source in these reviews? It's glaringly unprofessional at best, and downright cringe-inducing at worst.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- photojosh 5y ago> ultra-wide distortion > they can't apply simple lens correction You're confusing ultra-wide rectilinear lens distortion with barrel or fisheye distortion due to lens construction limitations. The latter is correctable in software, whereas the former is what they're joking about. > it's really not some sort of mind-blowing, next gen thing Sure. But why has no-one else implemented it in a selfie camera yet? I'd put $ on this camera being a major marketing point for either this or next year's iPhones.
- londons_explore 5y agoBoth are correctable in software. You just need to reproject and simulate a different type of camera lens.
- grantcox 5y agoMy assumption is that the distorted image (https://cms-cdn.lux.camera/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/26160135/E1w2YkbVgAE3rDe.jpeg https://cms-cdn.lux.camera/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/261601...) is actually a corner-crop of a 120 degree wide-angle photo. For example if you took the corner of https://cms-cdn.lux.camera/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/26180019/IMG_0264-1-2048x1536.jpg https://cms-cdn.lux.camera/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/261800... Do you know if my assumption is incorrect? If that's the case, what can be done about reducing that distortion? My layman's understanding is that it's like mercator projection - you simply cannot make a two-dimensional photo of a wide field of view without distorting.
- londons_explore 5y agoBut you can make a smarter (ie. Dewarping) crop... In the same way there are better map projections for exploring Antarctica...
- jiofih 5y agoAnd that’s exactly what the face tracking feature does. That shot is a still from the wide angle cam, and not in a framing you’d normally use for video calls.