3 ms·
Remember Mats Järlström? He was an engineer, but not a "licensed professional engineer" who complained about traffic light timings, and the state board tried to
by cratermoon 5y ago
Remember Mats Järlström? He was an engineer, but not a "licensed professional engineer" who complained about traffic light timings, and the state board tried to fine him $500?
https://ij.org/press-release/oregon-engineer-wins-traffic-light-timing-lawsuit/ https://ij.org/press-release/oregon-engineer-wins-traffic-li...
- loeg 5y agoSure. What point are you trying to make with the connection? This is a different state, with different licensing laws, and a different scenario.
- paxys 5y agoIt was a First Amendment ruling which applies to all states and jurisdictions regardless of their licensing laws.
- pavon 5y agoYes, although if I recall, that case turned in large part on whether the law could restrict calling oneself an engineer in general as opposed to misrepresenting oneself as a Licensed Professional Engineer. In this case, Marohn was unambiguously representing himself as a PE, for example in this article that was written during the period in which his license has lapsed (see author bio at bottom of page): https://web.archive.org/web/20191227151521/https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2019/12/12/four-ways-traffic-engineers-thwart-public-will https://web.archive.org/web/20191227151521/https://www.stron... So this case will have to push a bit further than that previous one, although the precedent may help.
- cratermoon 5y ago> applies to all states and jurisdictions Federal courts and precedents don't work that way. The ruling came from the federal district court for Oregon. As such, it's only binding for the district. If a federal court in another district comes to a different conclusion, then an appeal to the circuit court might happen. Michigan and Oregon are in different appellate circuits (6th and 9th, respectively) so if there were different rulings in each circuit, and an appeal to the Supreme Court succeeds and the court rules, only then does the ruling become binding across all states an jurisdictions. For now, the ruling is only binding in the District of Oregon.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> The ruling came from the federal district court for Oregon. As such, it's only binding for the district. No, trial court rulings aren’t binding precedent even on the same trial court. > If a federal court in another district comes to a different conclusion, then an appeal to the circuit court might happen Appeal to circuit courts from district court are a matter of right, a split between districts is immaterial not only as to whether such an appeal is filed but also to whether it is heard. > Michigan and Oregon are in different appellate circuits (6th and 9th, respectively) so if there were different rulings in each circuit, and an appeal to the Supreme Court succeeds and the court rules, only then does the ruling become binding across all states an jurisdictions. At this level, a circuit split is traditionally a factor which weighs in favor of the Supreme Court hearing an appeal (as its appellate jurisdiction is generally discretionary), but it is neither in itself either necessary or sufficient. But, yes, it is only when the Supreme Court rules that precedent is universally binding rather than persuasive. > For now, the ruling is only binding in the District of Oregon No, for now it is only binding between the parties to the earlier case (and only as regards the specific facts of that case), under the principle of res judicata rather than stare decisis which makes decisions binding on particular (or all) courts.
- cratermoon 5y ago> under the principle of res judicata rather than stare decisis Thanks for the clarification.
- bsder 5y ago1) He is not a professional engineer. And it only takes a bit of time and probably about $500 to become a PE. His not taking the time to become a PE speaks mountains. The $500 was a "nuisance fine" because he was being a pain in the ass with his complaints without being a PE. 2) He is funded and supported by some heavily suspect people.
- cratermoon 5y agoI 100% agree with everything you're saying. Saying he was being a pain in the ass is being nice about it. The case was a terrible one for testing the limits of what a professional licensing organization can do. However, it's now legal precedent and almost certainly impacts the Strong Towns case.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> However, it's now legal precedent Not binding precedent on any court that would hear the Strong Towns case.
- cratermoon 5y agoCorrect. The only court in the US that could issue a decision binding in both cases would be the Supreme Court, should any appeals make it that far. However, courts can and do look to existing opinions in case law.
- kazoomonger 5y ago1) The case in question is about "engineer", not "professional engineer". The legal system agreed with him, so I'm not sure what your complaint is? 2) That's very vague. Can you elaborate?
- bsder 5y agoTake a look at who bankrolled him through the legal case.