4 ms·
It is probably too late to save Computer Science Research. Efforts in that direction are likely wasted. More important is to keep the contagion from spreading t
by ncmncm 5y ago
It is probably too late to save Computer Science Research. Efforts in that direction are likely wasted. More important is to keep the contagion from spreading to allied fields. Grants probably should stop immediately. People doing serious work will need to move to another area where they might be able to contribute. People evaluating work in these other areas will need to guard against allowing theirs to be overtaken by the same downward spiral.
In perhaps a generation, a similar specialty might be bootstrapped and begin to take on problems had been of interest in the old one. What to call the new specialty will be its smallest problem.
- wolverine876 5y ago> It is probably too late to save Computer Science Research. Why do you say that? Do you have any experience in the field?
- Twisol 5y agoWithout any personal context, this stance appears very "baby meets bathwater". In particular, I'm not sure I see anything about this particular situation that renders it purely a problem of CS research. What makes other fields (presumably) immune or less predisposed to these kinds of issues? Your position also paints CS in very broad strokes; in my experience, the only commonality between some subfields of computer science is that they use computers. Graphics, hardware architecture, programming languages, networks, and so on, are all essentially loosely coupled with their own organizing communities and directions. Some of these subfields are more closely tied to mathematics or electrical engineering than strictly to other parts of computer science. If there is an incurable "contagion" that afflicts all of these, I must admit it hard to believe that this contagion would not prove (if not already be proven) effective beyond the artificial confines of the term "computer science".
- wmf 5y agoWhy shouldn't we assume that similar collusion exists in every scientific field?
- neffy 5y agoOh it does. I'm interdisciplinary. I've been offered the "opportunity" to be part of two citation rings in Economics, and that's from attending a handful of conferences. Which if one looks at the state of economics right now, is an object lesson on this kind of stuff never ending well.
- wmf 5y agoI guess economists can say that they're "just responding to the incentives of the market".