3 ms·
The underlying assumption in this scenario is that global demand for fossil fuels without carbon capture and sequestration will remain constant. This is certain
by epistasis 5y ago
The underlying assumption in this scenario is that global demand for fossil fuels without carbon capture and sequestration will remain constant. This is certainly not the case.
Shell can either start capturing carbon to lower their emissions, or perhaps they can sell to smaller firms. But those smaller firms are now under the same gun that Shell currently is. So investors in these smaller firms risk losing everything as well.
Already it is getting far far more difficult for fossil fuel companies to raise money for new extraction. Their stock prices have already taken massive hits.
Capital sees the writing on the wall, as does every single fossil fuel exec. It's not a matter of if extraction stops, but when. Many thought that there could be one more round of exploration, but this court decision is just one more huge hurdle for actually extracting anything from new exploration.
The tides are turning, we have alternatives to emissions now, the only question is if when we switch.
- JamesBarney 5y agoYou are arguing the very long term prospects for oil and gas aren't great. I agree. But that has little to do with whether or not this case will have any impact on oil and gas extraction. It's just a PR move, which won't affect the number of barrels pumped out of the ground each year.
- epistasis 5y agoI'm not quite sure what you mean by "just a PR move" since this has strong legal implications with a timeline for one of the big players. Shell has been dealt a major legal blow, and precedent has been set for all the smaller players. This will have big impacts for financing future fossil fuel extraction, because all the financiers see what's happened here. This has major implications, there's no PR anywhere near this.
- JamesBarney 5y agoIt might have small impacts on drilling financing in the Netherlands.