5 ms·
A lot of very confused weird comments here. This article is about a fairly large sized tech company adopting a fairly recent but increasingly mainstream & popu
by rektide 5y ago
A lot of very confused weird comments here.
This article is about a fairly large sized tech company adopting a fairly recent but increasingly mainstream & popular tool that helps them understand their operations. It'll give them a standard way to see what their computers are doing, across their various systems.
OpenTelemetry is one of the key emerging cloud standards, and I expect many many many many more articles like this going forwards, from all kinds of companies.
As for concerns about user tracking & privacy, that's not generally what these operational tools are used for. I haven't heard of a single case of them being used for user tracking or behavioral analytics. Thusfar these are purely operational tools, to understand the health of systems, to debug & typically to understand what happens to an incoming request as it works through dozens of systems & services to get processed. That said, I tend to think over time the importance of this distributed after-the-fact log we are building is going to become inverted. That we will start to see the potential to harvest these records for analytics, and more generally, to forward-feed them into other processes to automatically build & advance Event Sourcing systems. Right now these systems are relatively pure & good, but what's really at stake here is that we've been doing computing blind, with no record of what's happened, and OpenTelemetry is a key first step in lifting that veil of ignorance as to what computing has happened. We are beginning to capture the data of what compute occurred. Many things will emerge as we open this box.
- AlexandrB 5y ago> As for concerns about user tracking & privacy, that's not generally what these operational tools are used for. I'm not sure that the intended use matters. Unless the telemetry systems are carefully designed to not capture PII at all they become yet another channel that must be secured as if they are collecting PII. For example, see Windows 10 telemetry vs. HIPPA: https://hipaaone.com/2015/09/22/windows-10-and-hipaa/ https://hipaaone.com/2015/09/22/windows-10-and-hipaa/
- random3 5y agoThey are agnostic data collection protocols/ systems / libraries. Just like a protocol they could do PII collection and unlikely to prevent that. Ultimately the intended use matters more than the tech. And in this case it seems purposely built to measure performance.
- AYBABTME 5y agoI suspect you're tripping on the flowers of the carpet. Telemetry here is not a word meaning "call home and report user data", it means "telemetry" in the sense that a Mars rover sends back positioning & orientation data back to NASA for control. The usage of this tool is equivalent to having a query engine for application logs, or a statsd server to render graphs. It's just a protocol to see how systems are performing, but a better one than statsd or logs.
- cogman10 5y agoAgreed. This comment section is bizarre for HN. It's sort of like getting scared that "Prometheus" collects "metrics". Or that "Kafka" tracks "events". These aren't scary things.
- handrous 5y ago"Telemetry" has come to be associated with activities that definitely qualify a product as spyware (though they've become fairly common—thanks, "data-driven" marketers). From reading the OpenTelemetry site, that doesn't seem to be their main, stated purpose, but thefounder's post in another part of the thread leads me to think it may, in fact, see that kind of use, too. [EDIT] damn, sorry, downvoters, for explaining the reason this is getting knee-jerk negative reactions from people, when someone expressed confusion about it. Again, I think the main reason is the word used, and what it's mostly associated with now, among some folks.
- infogulch 5y agoEvery tool is also a weapon, obviously. We haven't stopped making hammers because they can be used to hit people.
- handrous 5y agoIt's why people are making these assumptions about the term "telemetry". In certain circles it usually means spyware. One of those circles includes front-end web, which is pretty well-represented on HN. [EDIT] and, especially, that's why they're jumping to the conclusion that github is gearing up to do more spying on its users, which is the part that I think people are bothered by, not the existence of this software package.
- cogman10 5y agoOpenTelemitry isn't useful for spying purposes. It just isn't. If github wanted to spy on users they have way more direct methods that don't involve collecting the time your browser executes a function or waits on an AJAX request.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- infogulch 5y agoEven other responses to your comment are confused. The primary use case is to trace requests that go through your backend of distributed microservices. The fact that it can also be used to collect PII-adjacent data as in sibling's example is about as relevant as the fact that it uses the HTTP protocol. I didn't see any similar comments raging against the HTTP protocol on the last curl post that came through here. People here are blindly rage-triggered by the word "telemetry" without even taking 2 seconds to glance through to see what it actually is.
- yannoninator 5y agoWait, you said: > I haven't heard of a single case of them being used for user tracking or behavioral analytics. and then you said: > That we will start to see the potential to harvest these records for analytics… So this can be used to gather analytics of any sort of data, such as spying then? This is still worrisome.
- geofft 5y agoIn that sentence, "these records" means "information about how GitHub's servers are behaving," not, say, "user data." It is technically true that such a tool could be used on any sort of data, in the same way that, say, Perl or SQL can be used on any sort of data.
- Lazare 5y agoIt's a bit disappointing, really. There are people commenting who clearly have no idea what the tool even is, haven't even tried to figure it out, haven't read the other comments already here. I'd really hope for better among the HNews readership.