3 ms·
The board’s concern is pretty well precedented. Holding one’s self out as a professional engineer when unlicensed is bog standard violation for licensed AEC pro
by brudgers 5y ago
The board’s concern is pretty well precedented. Holding one’s self out as a professional engineer when unlicensed is bog standard violation for licensed AEC professions.
Neither is there anything unusual about the circumstances of the board’s concern.
Investigations are almost always complaint driven...boards don’t have the resources to conduct dragnet operations.
Finally, inattention to details is a piss poor defense in the context of professional engineering. The whole idea is that professional engineers are aware of and beholden to compliance with all things legal and regulatory.
This is just StrongTowns making drama. At worst there is a small fine, some administrative costs, and maybe some educational requirements.
Or to put it another way, the response to the issue is unprofessional.
- jessaustin 5y ago"Professional engineers" in USA should make sure that structures are built well enough to be safely used by the public. They have no business weighing in on the sorts of issues addressed by Strong Towns. The fact that they have done so in the past is proof of this, because streets and roads in USA are organized very poorly when compared to those in similar nations. [EDIT:] Also, Marohn is licensed as one can see here: https://www.mn.gov/aelslagid/roster.html https://www.mn.gov/aelslagid/roster.html
- brudgers 5y agoThey weighed in on a person advertising themselves out as a “professional engineer” while their license was lapsed. The claim that this is because of Strongtown’s position is not supported by any evidence. It is a very ordinary complaint and board action. The only thing extraordinary here is lay people reading about it.
- jessaustin 5y agoIt's "ordinary" for a random person in a different state to make such a complaint, after the license was already reinstated? It's ordinary to require one stipulate to "dishonesty" when he was never actually dishonest? Such travails await every engineer who misses some mail? That seems like... dishonesty to me. All people, whether they are engineers or not, have the right to sue for equal treatment under the law.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> It's "ordinary" for a random person in a different state to make such a complaint, after the license was already reinstated? The complaint was made first. The subject wasn’t aware of the complaint until later..
- brudgers 5y agoYes. It is pretty ordinary. Given that the Dakotas neighbor Minnesota, it would not be unusual for an out of state engineer to have a license in a neighboring state. Indeed it is ordinary for professionals to have licenses in many states because clients often have work in many states. In addition the motivation for the complaint, is different from the motivation of the license board. The license board almost certainly treating the case the same way it treats other cases. If it were not, StrongTowns would have sound procedural grounds for challenging the board. There is nothing unusual here. The First Amendment suit will almost certainly be thrown out. There does not appear to be any supporting case law. And lots of precedent against it.
- jessaustin 5y agoThe license board almost certainly treating the case the same way it treats other cases. I've seen no evidence of this.
- colinmhayes 5y ago>The board’s concern is pretty well precedented. Holding one’s self out as a professional engineer when unlicensed is bog standard violation for licensed AEC professions. Yea that's the entire problem.
- Nicksil 5y ago>Yea that's the entire problem. How so? Do you prefer people without the requisite knowledge, skill, and experience to design and construct the infrastructure you and you family use on a daily basis?
- colinmhayes 5y agoI think licensing boards shouldn't be able to fine people for giving speeches.
- Nicksil 5y ago>I think licensing boards shouldn't be able to fine people for giving speeches. You'll be glad to know that this one didn't. The issue being presented isn't that someone gave a speech -- because that would be ridiculous -- it concerns a very specific thing stated within that speech. But you know that already so I'm not sure I understand your comment.
- colinmhayes 5y agoI think a licensing board shouldn't be able to fine people who previously worked as professional engineers who call themselves professional engineers in a brochure about there speech.
- brudgers 5y agoThe regulation of building trades goes back to the Code of Hammurabi. Literally as far back as the oldest written laws. The legal precedent is 3500 years older than the First Amendment.