4 ms·
The response and cause are inputs in the same system. An economy of belt-tightening is not inflationary. > silly Enough said.
by wolverine876 5y ago
The response and cause are inputs in the same system. An economy of belt-tightening is not inflationary.
> silly
Enough said.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> The response and cause are inputs in the same system. But not to the same state. The description is of inflation at T(<n) producing belt-tightening at T(=n). You are complaining that the belt-tightening doesn’t explain the inflation. Of course it doesn’t. Now, sure, there’s a valid question of “what is causing the inflation”; is it offsetting belt loosening in another group? Is it supply issues? But
- wolverine876 5y agoWe are in early days with little inflation. In the sequence of time T(1 .. N), what you describe applies only to T(1). For all time T(>1), the belt-tightening is an input. If 83% of Americans are doing it, inflation isn't an issue for T(>1), in which case it's a moot issue.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> If 83% of Americans are doing it, inflation isn't an issue Since I already explained why this is wrong in my first post (and you acknowledged it in your response, but shifted your criticism of thr headline to that the belt-tightening doesn’t explain inflation even though it is consistent with inflation from other causes), I think we've come full circle here.
- wolverine876 5y ago> I already explained why this is wrong Oh sorry, I didn't realize you forbade me from expressing a different opinion.