4 ms·
It's not possible to lend digital media out without making a copy(remotely streaming it still copying), which isn't protected by the first sale doctrine. Redbo
by rhino369 5y ago
It's not possible to lend digital media out without making a copy(remotely streaming it still copying), which isn't protected by the first sale doctrine. Redbox isn't making a copy. That's the big difference.
- jbay808 5y agoIs it possible to play a DVD without making a copy in the DVD player's RAM? What if I extend an HDMI cable from my DVD player to your TV? My library manages to lend ebooks; they even have wait lists for them.
- d110af5ccf 5y ago> My library manages to lend ebooks; they even have wait lists for them. Those are made available in that format by the publisher. No equivalent for movies is available (as far as I am aware). Also my understanding is that it was never entirely clear if lending ebooks like that in the US was legal or not. The publishers and lenders both carefully avoided the issue going to court IIUC. (Prior to the Internet Archive's actions, that is.)
- thayne 5y agoAssuming that is true that seems like yet another place where the law isn't well adapted to a digital world.