3 ms·
My biggest issue with the visual aspects of The Expanse is one that I don't think can be fixed. The story is set approximately 3-400 years in the future. All o
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
My biggest issue with the visual aspects of The Expanse is one that I don't think can be fixed.
The story is set approximately 3-400 years in the future. All of the technology, however, looks, if not immediately familiar, then more or less "around the corner from now".
Go back to 1621, and imagining projecting a future 2021 based on "minor tweaks to what we're using now". Clearly, it would be absolutely nothing remotely like the actual 2021 that we live in.
I enjoy the Expanse a lot, but if there are humans around in 2400 or so who get a chance to see it again, I'm fairly sure they will be besides themselves with laughter at its "vision" for their time.
- manmal 5y agoThey do have the Epstein drive, holographic displays, anti-cancer-cell „dialysis“, a solar-system-wide internet, miniaturized electron microscopes, and insanely long-lasting batteries. But, I must admit that eg the terminals look like phones from 2050. And I‘m sorely missing AI, humanoid robots, and way more bionic implants a la Cyberpunk. However I think those were left out deliberately to allow the story to be mainly about the human experience. AIs like the one in „Her“ might be realistic on a 400 year time scale, but I find stories like that rather awe-inspiring than relatable.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoYes, the tech developments have happened, no question. But the look of the vessels, the homes, the offices, the computing devices ... these are all circa 2030 (or maybe even 2024).
- nirav72 5y ago>I‘m sorely missing AI, humanoid robots I remember reading somewhere that the authors of the book series intentionally left out AI in the story - as to not take away from the human aspects of the story. AI is there, just in the background with context specific voice activated commands.
- biztos 5y agoOr maybe they'll be sad their present isn't as cool as we thought our future would be?
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoI think that the Expanse (books & show) do a fairly good job at explicitly not making the future look that cool. Despite the specific new technologies that are around, people's live contain about the same amount of misery, tech breakdowns and general impossibility as we do today.
- thepasswordis 5y agoSailing technology today is similar to technology from the 1600s, just more convenient. Same thing with books, paper, pens, etc. It seems likely that the idea of "screen, mouse/touchscreen/keyboard" will be around forever (like books have). However we might have NEW technology (like an epstein drive).
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agobooks haven't been around forever, and in particular printed books are only about 600 years old.the basic concept of a bound set of pages is about 1500 years old. pen technology in 2021 looks absolutely nothing like pen technology in 1621. I don't think a person from that time would visually recognize a modern pen, even if they could understand its purpose once it was explained or they got to use it. paper is only about 1200 years old. None of these technologies has "been around for ever", although one could clearly make a case that barring total civilizational collapse, they might truly be here to stay. I don't think that the same could be said for any current computing technology. Sailing technology is similar, except that very few people ever sail, travel in sailboats, receive goods shipped in sailboats, or even see a sailboat. The things that have largely replaced sailing would look very foreign to someone from 1621. I suspect the same will be true in 2400. There will still be some people (perhaps) using technology that we're familiar with today, but most people will use something else.