5 ms·
The author is a former postdoc, who was active in academia in the 1970s, and then reappeared on the scene in 2017 to write this paper. https://www.researchgate
by lupire 5y ago
The author is a former postdoc, who was active in academia in the 1970s, and then reappeared on the scene in 2017 to write this paper.
https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Eugen-Muchowski https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Eugen-Muchowski
- ajarmst 5y agoHowever, his Doctorate is in Chemical Engineering and what field and area for his postdoc research isn't identified. A postdoc Chemical Engineer wouldn't normally be working on the theoretical foundations of quantum mechanics. I also have to assume that the claim that he is retired after a "[p]rofessional career in the industry" means that he is a retired Chemical Engineer, not a postdoc researcher in quantum mechanics, despite identifying his alma maters as his research affiliation with only a tiny footnote disclosing that he is 'retired'. This is also the latest of multiple attempts to publish this work over a period of years---and is apparently only the second paper he's written. If he has indeed 'refuted' Bell's Theorem (and thus undermined the foundations of large swaths of theoretical Quantum Mechanics), one might expect he'd have at least one collaborator, a current research affiliation, and the interest of a journal with an impact factor greater than 2. It's possible he is the mythical solitary untrained genius, shunned by the establishment and producing Nobel-prize caliber research in his basement. That's probably not the way to bet, though.
- newdude116 5y ago"A postdoc Chemical Engineer wouldn't normally be working on the theoretical foundations of quantum mechanics." Sure. But it is not forbidden. Besides the odd circumstances, what outs me off is that he tries to link himself with former (well known) universities. He may have attended them, but he is in no way affiliated with them anymore. Crackhead-alarm
- GistNoesis 5y agoI'm curious to know what/who would be needed to convince the scientific community.
- gus_massa 5y agoIt's difficult to know, but I'll copy one of my comments, with a few additions. The problem is that (ignoring MA3) until the section "Predicting measurement results for the initial context" (inclusive) it is totally trivial if you have a background in Physics and Quantum Mechanics. It's not the usual model because it uses one (or two?) hidden variables, but it's easy to understand. But the next section "Predicting measurement results for an arbitrary context" is totally unintelligible. My guess is that the unintelligible part is hiding that when you measure a photon with a polarizer with an angle alpha, the other photon gets that information with an implicit faster than light communication. I have read it three times and I gave up. To convince the scientific community it will be good to implement this model and post it in github or something. * One function that create a pair of entangled photons X and Y. * One function f that takes the photon X and the angle alpha and says if it passed the filter. * One function g that takes the photon Y and the angle beta and says if it passed the other filter. Bonus points if f and g are the same functions (or the only change is a pi/2). No cheating, like using alpha in g, or assuming that alpha is 0. Run a Montecarlo simulation and show that it gets the expected result. It's like 30 lines of Python or Fortran or whatever. Transforming this to an analytical calculation is easy, but in an analytical calculations is easier to hide a change of variables and another trick that "transmit" alpha from one detector to the other.
- GistNoesis 5y agoWould something like this do the trick : https://gist.github.com/unrealwill/2a48ea0926deac4011d26842627b69c9 https://gist.github.com/unrealwill/2a48ea0926deac4011d268426... (Straight implementation of Kupczynski Marian Closing the Door on Quantum Nonlocality https://philarchive.org/archive/KUPCTDv1 https://philarchive.org/archive/KUPCTDv1 )
- gus_massa 5y agoExactly, something like that. (Note for others: This is not an implementation of the OP method, it's another paper with a somewhat similar topic.) It's an interesting model, but I don't like some details. It generates a pair of (not entangled) photons with the same polarization (actually, +pi/2). Then it has two detectors. In each detector the first secret parameter is equivalent to the usual calculation of the probability that a photon that has a polarization that is not aligned with the polarizer pass. If you can buy perfect/magical detectors that has the second secret parameter equal to zero, then this is just equivalent to the usual model with non entangled photons. And it should not break the Bell inequality. The second secret parameter of each detector tries to model that the detectors sometimes miss a photon. I still don't like the model they are using, but it's not my specialty. Anyway, usually noise and fluky detectors make the result look more like classic results, so I expect that this second parameter makes the result not break the Bell inequality. The problem is that it is possible to make very careful experiments that break the Bell inequality, so I don't understand what their model tries to show.