5 ms·
Actually, it's somewhat worse than the headline mentions. It seems that the script targets channels that merely mention Libera in the topic. The topic of an aff
by jcranmer 5y ago
Actually, it's somewhat worse than the headline mentions. It seems that the script targets channels that merely mention Libera in the topic. The topic of an affected channel I was in said: "See also #foo on irc.libera.chat" (as we hadn't decided whether or not to move). And everyone in the channel was banned from both the #foo and the ##foo channels on Freenode.
Needless to say, Freenode kindly decided for us whether or not we should move to Libera for good.
- ashtonkem 5y agoThat’s both a hilarious way to sabotage the IRC server you just paid money for, and a good way to help others sabotage other channels.
- dspillett 5y agoThey've learned nothing from classic films. The would-be empire is tightening its grip, and more & more channels are slipping through their fingers.
- henvic 5y agoIt seems to be the act of a loner. RIP freenode.
- fellellor 5y agoThe founder of Private Internet Access and also… the Crown Prince of South Korea it seems. XD
- jcranmer 5y ago> the Crown Prince of South Korea it seems Alleged crown prince of the Joseon Empire. Which hasn't existed for ~110 years, and is based on an ennoblement by one of several contenders for the current head of the former imperial family, so it's an even weaker claim than most pretenders of former monarchies have.
- birdyrooster 5y agoFake it till you make it
- wearywanderer 5y agoI believe his 'official' title is now Fresh Prince of Korea.
- bierjunge 5y agoMore like LEEnode now. The network is dead and will never recover, even if Andrew steps down.
- duckfang 5y agoAnd this should be a sign to every founder-wannabe and capitalist: You can buy hardware, trademarks, and DNS, and stuff. YOU CANNOT BUY COMMUNITY. YOU CANNOT BUY GOODWILL.
- sva_ 5y ago>YOU CANNOT BUY COMMUNITY. This is false. Communities get sold successfully all the time (thing of tech giants buying up unicorns or whatever). But doing that with a (predominantly) FOSS community was definitely doomed from the start.
- handrous 5y agoIt's less that the communities were FOSS than that it was built on a widely-implemented, stable, open protocol. Moving to a new server means everyone takes 30 seconds to add the new server and join the new channel, but keeps using the same client. Maybe you have to change a line of config on some bots and restart them. Done. We see fewer of those developed now precisely because it forces providers (free or paid) to behave well or else be easily abandoned. Facebook, Twitter, Google, et c., do not want that, for obvious reasons.
- Strom 5y ago> YOU CANNOT BUY COMMUNITY. YOU CANNOT BUY GOODWILL. How much did they try paying people? I haven't received any offers, but I will happily idle in some freenode channels for a monthly fee.
- duckfang 5y agofeel free to come into irc.libera.chat #reprap and offer to pay us to go back. I'll tell you where to put your money.
- Strom 5y agoYou seem clearly passionate, but also confused. First off, I am not affiliated with freenode or libera. I am just an unrelated guy who happens to use IRC. I am not offering any money to anyone for any IRC related things. Secondly, you claimed that it is not possible to buy communities or goodwill. This does not match what I have witnessed in life. Communities get bought all the time, e.g. Facebook buying Instagram. Goodwill also gets bought all the time, often by making a giant donation and then running a giant PR campaign to let everyone know about the good deed. Distributed organic communities like freenode aren't immune to this, as I showed by pointing out that I, a long time freenode user, would be willing to accept payment.
- mxmilkiib 5y agofreenode is the communities, it just renamed itself and moved hosting
- TheCraiggers 5y agoPerhaps they have; you're just thinking of the wrong films. I keep wondering if this is a The Producers situation, with the caveat that I can't imagine this being as wildly successful as Springtime for Hitler. Frankly, they are running service so badly that I can't think of any reason other than purposeful sabotage.
- utucuro 5y agoSpeaking from my own experience during my stint as a network admin on a national IRC network 2 decades ago, this fits the psychological profile of certain people I encountered quite well. No intent to sabotage is needed, various things about IRC just bring out the worst in some people, and my guess is that this mostly begins with the channel modes; socially acceptible privilege and power over fellow humans which can be had by networking with the channel owner. At the network operator level, concurrent user numbers become an issue of pride, total registered user counts, total active accounts likewise... The more people view the network as a worthy entity for itself instead of just a tool for communication, the worse it gets. In this whole thing, one thing in particular is interesting to me since freenode was not just an IRC network, but an IRC network with a focus on FOSS projects: Freenode / rasengan seems to insinuate by his actions that a project does not have the right to choose an official realtime communication forum for itself; that it is freenode which brings the users to the project channel instead of the other way around.
- rolph 5y agoi too remember the k3wl d00d5 and the chanops takeover mobs
- tootie 5y agoWhat exactly does "hijack" mean though? I don't speak IRC so it's not clear what they're actually doing to the channels.
- ashtonkem 5y agoLooks like they’re replacing the channel mods with Lee’s people the moment Libera is mentioned.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- fsflover 5y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27288590 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27288590
- klodolph 5y agoIRC has a concept of "ops" or operator privileges, which are per-channel moderation priveleges. The exact privileges depend on the IRC software running, but it usually means that you can change the advertised topic message, mute / un-mute users, and kick users out of the channel. Hijack means removing those privileges from someone else and assigning them to yourself.
- masklinn 5y agoRemoved all existing ops (channel admins), set the channel to invite-only, set the channel to ops-only. Basically removed all the existing mod team then made the channel mod-only, which kicked all users.
- victor9000 5y agoWow, that seems incredibly hostile to everyone involved.
- kjrose 5y agoHonestly, there's an pretty solid rule you don't crap on your channel owners by using chanserv. That's the number one way to be clear that having your channel on their server is fundamentally unsafe.
- BoorishBears 5y agoI was unaware not putting all your eggs in one basket was "crapping" on the first basket...
- niconii 5y agoI think you misunderstood the comment you're replying to. They're saying Andrew Lee is the one crapping on the channel owners by hijacking their channels.
- BoorishBears 5y agoGood on your for clarifying and not being another useless downvote! HN should remove the downvote button, but the hivemind might lose its cohesion then
- Grollicus 5y agoI'm disappointed it seems nobody thought of the "Don't go to irc.libera.chat, freenode.net is much better!"-Topic joke yet.
- mxmilkiib 5y agoTo quote a #freenode op "users were being forced to another IRC network because the channel was +m". So, instead, the various community groups are being forced to stay on freenode? And the post-structural turn was like 50 years ago.. they have jumped (off) the clue train.
- jcranmer 5y ago> To quote a #freenode op "users were being forced to another IRC network because the channel was +m". And the channel I was in wasn't +m until freenodecom decided to hijack it and make it +m.
- johnklos 5y agoI wonder what happens if you want to talk about Liberace.