6 ms·
I dunno, Musk has already indicated he'd put people in feudal serfdom to pay off a loan if they want a trip to Mars. And he'd get people volunteering for it.
by Cthulhu_ 5y ago
I dunno, Musk has already indicated he'd put people in feudal serfdom to pay off a loan if they want a trip to Mars. And he'd get people volunteering for it.
- ben_w 5y agoI’ve seen people claim that, but the closest I’ve actually seen from Musk is this tweet: https://mobile.twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1217991853615677440 https://mobile.twitter.com/elonmusk/status/12179918536156774... Do you have a better citation? Because loans are not feudalism — and if you want to insist they are, only Islamic Law jurisdictions (which bans interest rather than loans but eh) are non-feudal.
- lucideer 5y ago> loans are not feudalism Loans in themselves are not 100% "feudal", though I don't think it's a binary "is feudal" -vs- "is not feudal"; more of a "how feudal". The implication above was that loan repayment via mandatory labour is feudal (or at least "more feudal"). > if you want to insist they are, only Islamic Law jurisdictions (which bans interest rather than loans but eh) are non-feudal That's a pretty big "eh" tbh; I don't many people think interest is the problematic part of loans. Don't think Islamic Law can be excluded here.
- HappySweeney 5y agoNo entity based on Earth has juristiction on Mars. Over there, SpaceX will be the law. I don't see them forgiving loans and shuttling "contract-breakers" back to Earth for free.
- Robotbeat 5y agoThat’s false. The Outer Space Treaty means anything launched from Earth remains the responsibility of the nation who launched it. SpaceX most certainly is under the jurisdiction of the US and will remain so for the foreseeable future.
- dkersten 5y agoWill it make a difference? If it’s a one way trip, what’s earth going to do about it if some guy decides to play warlord on mars and commits atrocities to do so?
- ben_w 5y agoIf that person owns the rocket company which got everyone there in the first place? The response will probably include seizure of all Earth based assets including the rockets, use of those rockets to fly to Mars, and by way of this give the idiot who thought it was a good idea to be obviously dangerous while in charge of interplanetary ballistic missiles a personal introduction to dangerous end of the first real human space marine. Needless to say, the likely-Earth-based shareholders are likely to be unimpressed by such a colonial government. If they don’t own the rocket company and don’t threaten the main colony? That might end up like Jonestown.
- dkersten 5y ago> If they don’t own the rocket company and don’t threaten the main colony? And if they do threaten the main colony or even take it over entirely? My point with my comment was that because mars is far away, any earth response on mars would be rather slow. Mars would have plenty of time to react if earth ships soldiers over or whatever and they wouldn't care about seizure of earth assets. As for ballistic missiles, to what end? Kill all the innocent colonists to get rid of the warlord? Even if it was the person that owns the rockets, if they're on mars, they may no longer care about the earth assets. I mean, if its a one way trip, they wouldn't be able to do anything with them other than send supplies. I assume if they were to play warlord, its at a point where they no longer care about the supplies. If earth used those rockets to invade mars, mars would still have plenty of time to come up with a plan to shoot them down or whatever. > Needless to say, the likely-Earth-based shareholders are likely to be unimpressed by such a colonial government. If mars is a one-way trip away, why would they care about Earth-based shareholders? Not saying such a takeover would end well for mars, just that the isolation leaves it wide open for some maniac to play warlord. I also think its more likely that its not the person who owns the rockets, if someone does decide to do that.
- viraptor 5y agoIt's all speculation of course, but "with loans available" sounds like it's SpaceX that will offer the loans. And how can you repay them after arrival, apart from working on a colony designed and controlled by SpaceX? This basically smells of "we'll offer you cheap food and tools at the company store".
- emteycz 5y agoBy working for the other companies there, investing on the Martian stock market, playing poker, marrying a rich partner... A repayable loan is not feudalism.
- ben_w 5y agoDoes the colony itself have to be owned by the transport company? At Musk’s target price for Mars flights, someone as rich as Bezos could pay for half a million people to go to Mars. (That said, if I had Bezos’ money, I’d buy flights from SpaceX to build a factory on the Moon to research space-based mining and manufacturing, and launch loops, with a view to expanding that into a full-blown colony over time).
- sangnoir 5y ago> At Musk’s target price for Mars flights, someone as rich as Bezos could pay for half a million people to go to Mars. That won't matter if SpaceX has a monopoly on the air they breath, the food they eat and the water they drink. One of the first legal questions they will grapple with is "Does earth law apply on Mars/to Martian citizens? Or is Bezos' contract moot" Look at the history of colonization if you want to see the dynamic of human nature/greed/fiefdoms away from the mother country that is several-month's journey away. The Dutch East India company or the British South Africa Company may be decent case-studies, the only difference being that they could "live off the land" and exploit the natives. There are no natives on Mars, but I can't rule out exploitation.
- ben_w 5y ago> That won't matter if SpaceX has a monopoly on the air they breath, the food they eat and the water they drink. Does the colony itself have to be owned by the transport company? Any of the colony? Including the life support, the factories which make the life support, the mining equipment which digs up the resources these factories use, or anything else? I’m not expecting great things from human nature, but I expect Terran governments to forcefully insist on non-Monopolistic behaviour very quickly, even in the absence of abuse of power, as they’ll be lobbied by both potential investors and military hawks with “isolationism bad” rhetoric.
- meowster 5y agoWhat happens when those people have kids? Do the kids owe their soul to the company store?
- hef19898 5y agoUS history answers that question for you. For the first colonists becoming rich as sell as for their imported cheap labor force.