4 ms·
Is it just that the folks who took over freenode are stupid and short sighted, or is there an actually rational reason behind their actions?
by mikewarot 5y ago
Is it just that the folks who took over freenode are stupid and short sighted, or is there an actually rational reason behind their actions?
- teekert 5y agoYeah I’m following this from the sidelines but by now I’m really wondering what the Freenode staff was expecting and what their goals are?
- wchar_t 5y agoI'm probably wrong, but from what I can tell rasengan was the only person behind this. He nuked channels and then disappeared, leaving his utterly confused staff to listen to the music from all the upset users/chanops.
- mercer 5y agoMy impression is that rasengan (Andrew Lee) does really seem to care about IRC, and he does see himself as the 'good guy', but his thoughts on how to make it all work clash with the somewhat more anarchic volunteer-based way Freenode worked, as the most charitable interpretation. Slightly less charitably, it comes across as a rich dude wanting, expecting, and/or being used to being boss, and being (legitimately) confused as to why this is causing so much trouble from his volunteer underlings. It's hard to be a prince in this world...
- geofft 5y agoEven under the charitable interpretation, he "cares about IRC" in a way very different from how any of the projects that use Freenode care about IRC. Ask Gentoo or Ubuntu or Wikipedia what they want out of an IRC network, and they'll probably say, hm, more stability and less spam, I guess. Ask Andrew Lee what he wants abut IRC and this is what he says (from https://irc.com/ https://irc.com/): > Refreshed mobile apps, intuitive web apps, friends lists, working team support, video calls and file sharing. All within a few taps of the mobile device as people have come to expect.
- vfclists 5y ago> Refreshed mobile apps, intuitive web apps, friends lists, working team support, video calls and file sharing. All within a few taps of the mobile device as people have come to expect. i.e. he wants to evolve/transmogrify IRC into a system that is more amenable to centralization, data collection and monetization.
- bellyfullofbac 5y agoHmm, sounds like he wants to make another WhatsApp, and probably expecting a few billion Zuckdollars buy-out. Hah, with all the users (the reason Zuck pays billions) abandoning the sinking ship, Lee's dream is evaporating in front of his very eyes. Say bye-bye to that superyacht, Mr. Prince!
- mercer 5y agoI imagine either Freenode will still end up doing fine, or he'll just conclude that us nerds don't understand the concept of ownership and threw him under the bus after all his donations and hard work, and then he'll move on to the next plaything. He'll probably get his superyacht eventually.
- daenney 5y agoI personally wouldn't mind IRC (also) having some of those features, and a client with a more Discord-like UX for those that want it. But I doubt you'll achieve that by single-handedly destroying one of the biggest IRC networks out there and basically guaranteeing folks won't want to work with you.
- Wxc2jjJmST9XWWL 5y agoTo offer a different point of view: If I were to create my own chat protocol, I would actively try to make it next to impossible to implement it on mobile and consider this a feature. Nothing is gained by mobile users. From the features/interfaces they expect, the kind of communication people are accustomed to on mobile, and to them just being idlers 24/7 anyways. Let people who want smileys, gifs, fancy UI, backlogs upon reconnect, reply features, friend lists, voice features use discord and whatever, and please let IRC be a stream of text messages and old school and a haven from this modern shiny crappy world.
- ashtonkem 5y agoHonestly, it screams impulse control problems to me, that or a catastrophic misunderstanding of how people actually think and act.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- izacus 5y agoOn some Freenode channels I've seen the channel owners effectively ban/block all conversations before leaving. This would mean that even if people chose to stay on Freenode, they wouldn't be able to talk on channels dedicated to some projects at all. A lot of those channels got taken over and bans removed.
- p_l 5y agoOn most of those channels, the previous state was that it is an official, supported channel of a given organization (especially if it's a non-grandfathered single-# channel). The mass bans and such are the only way to mass-notify in reliable way that an official channel moved elsewhere. In all cases I've seen so far, the channel hijacked by new ircops was not a random community channel, and in fact freenode had policy even before that about prioritizing official org ownership.
- izacus 5y agoI find this explanation a bit dishonest - mass ban of people talking about topic to push them to another server is not "the most reliable way" of communicating anything. The whole point of IRC is that people can create channels and talk about things without those channels being owned by someone. If team members want to go somewhere else that's completely fine - but preventing people from staying and talking about a project goes against core of IRC and IMO Freenode ircops are well within rights to prevent channel squatting and forceful bans.
- kemayo 5y agoSure, but Freenode has a "namespace" system. A channel with a single # is supposed to signify that it's officially affiliated with whatever project it's about, while a channel with a double ## is something community-driven. It's thus perfectly reasonable to me that, if the project decides to move networks and stop using the official channel, it should shut it down and redirect it. (If for no other reason than because the project won't be moderating that channel any more, and it reflects poorly on the project if something that's flagged as being "official" turns into a cesspool.) It's not stopping people from creating a ## community channel on the old network to keep talking. That's irrelevant, of course, because Freenode hijacked a lot of channels that weren't doing the full shutdown, and just had a soft "we're moving to X soon" topic set, thus punishing the gentler communications you'd prefer.