3 ms·
>transparent displays are a lazy trick of film makers who overestimate the importance of characters in science fiction, and underestimate the importance of sett
by krapp 5y ago
>transparent displays are a lazy trick of film makers who overestimate the importance of characters in science fiction, and underestimate the importance of setting.
Characters are always more important than setting. You can tell a compelling story with a character alone in a room, but without any characters even an interesting setting has nothing to say.
- dagw 5y agoCharacters are always more important than setting. Not among sci-fi fans. There are lots of classic and beloved scifi books that are all about the world and setting and technology where the characters are 2d cardboard cut outs that only exist as an excuse to move the story from set piece to set piece.
- watwut 5y agoYeah, but at least to me, they became unreadable as I grew to be able to recognize how much the 2d carboard is not unrealistic and empty. I like sci-fi, but when I encounter these, they annoy me. Good sci-fi writers dont go lazy on characters and actually develop them.
- goatlover 5y agoWould you consider the characters of The Three Body Problem to be all that interesting? Yet it's widely considered to be a great novel. Not sure whether The Dark Forest or the third book do a better job with characters, but the plot and the ideas make the story.
- watwut 5y agoI haven't read it, so I don't guess. It is unfair to judge quality of characters in book one did not read.
- TeMPOraL 5y agoThat's the mainstream view, yes. But honestly, in case of sci-fi, I mostly disagree. Most literary genres are defined by the flavor of character exploration you do. Any character-focused story you want, you can find a genre for it. Science fiction is defined as speculative exploration of interactions between people and hypothetical advancements of science and technology. If you laser-focus on the characters, you lose what makes the genre interesting and distinct from all others. That's not to say that characters aren't important. But, in the kind of sci-fi I like, technologies and societies and institutions become "characters" themselves, and need to be treated with equal importance.
- watwut 5y agoScience fiction is full of character focused books, movies and what not. All solidly within science fiction category.