2 ms·
The tree based structure of the threads encourages conversational tangents by design. The original comments are replies to the original topic, but the further i
by krapp 5y ago
The tree based structure of the threads encourages conversational tangents by design. The original comments are replies to the original topic, but the further in you go, the more comments become replies to other comments, and conversations deviate from general and abstract to concrete and specific. If Hacker News wanted every comment to relate directly to the OP, it should have a flat comment structure.
This happens on Reddit too, it's just easier to notice here because threads here tend to be deeper rather than longer.
Remember, this isn't a symposium. We're not here just to offer professional criticism or trade theses at one another. There's no rule that all conversation must strictly be relevant to the topic, and primarily of a technical nature, nor should there be. We're here to have conversations about things we find interesting, and using casual language and personal anecdotes are perfectly acceptable. The only times I've seen the mods step in for something being off topic is when a tangent violates some other guideline.