4 ms·
The only extensions people should install are uBlock Origin and EFF's Privacy Badger. Everything else is potential malware.
by matheusmoreira 5y ago
The only extensions people should install are uBlock Origin and EFF's Privacy Badger. Everything else is potential malware.
- sneak 5y agoYou forgot Cookie Autodelete, NoScript, and HTTPS Everywhere.
- cortesoft 5y agoI think the fact that people are listing different sets of extensions they trust is good evidence that you can't just say "this list is the only list of extensions you can trust"
- lmkg 5y agoFrankly this is why I prefer a "maximalist" browser like Vivaldi (and old-school Opera) that focuses on building features into the core browser rather than supporting extensions. There are benefits to having a feature be provided directly by the browser, not the least of which is the trust model. There's a trade-off of fewer features overall and less customization, but it's a trade-off I'm personally fine with.
- sneak 5y agoOutside of a small list of security extensions numbering a dozen or fewer, you can't really trust much of anything in the extension webstore.
- josefx 5y agoDifferent people use different extensions. I have seen quite a few people avoid NoScript, not because they don't trust it, but because they considered manually selecting which scripts could run not worth their time.
- quink 5y agoOr extension that limit themselves their permissions to specific sites. Like SponsorBlock and Reddit Enhancement Suite. That's actually the complete list of plugins I have, uBlock Origin, Privacy Badger, SponsorBlock and RES.
- cortesoft 5y agoWhat makes those extensions not "potentially malware"? I am assuming it is because you (or someone you trust) vetted them and decided they were trustworthy. Why wouldn't this same idea apply to any other extension? You are right, everything is potential malware (the two extensions you mentioned included). There is nothing magical about the two extensions you mentioned.
- edoceo 5y agoUBO is good cause like the whole internet trusts Raymond Hill (gorhill). And 1000s of eyeballs are on those works.
- lupire 5y agoUblock Origin only exists because gorhill's original Ublock became evil due to a critical management mistake onboarding an untrustworthy parry. Everything is a risk.
- dankwizard 5y agoI'd argue it's getting counter-intuitive though, similar to the bystander effect. Yes it is popular but if everybody thinks everyone else is verifying the source, then no one is. When is the last time you checked out the UBO Git?
- cortesoft 5y agoSure, but the comment I relied to seemed SO sure that those were the only two legitimate extensions. My point was that there might be others that also have built up that level of trust, and to assume that you know the exact list of trustworthy extensions is putting too much confidence in your knowledge of everything.
- Barrin92 5y agoThere are plenty of reasonably trustworthy extensions. The logic of "it is a cybersecurity and privacy product, therefore it is the only thing I trust" is kind of terrible. That's if anything a category of products that is full of strange software, see "antivirus" software
- lmkg 5y agoGP very much did not say to trust security and privacy products in general. They said to trust two such products in particular, which are well-established and trusted. There are prominent examples within the past few months of "privacy" extensions embedding trackers and monetizing user data.
- hungryfoolish 5y agoNo, GP said to only trust these two extensions and no other extensions. While they are entitled to their opinion, IMO that is such ridiculous. There are many many extensions which provide value which don't do shady things.
- xmprt 5y agoMany antivirus products are bordering on malware these days.
- ttt0 5y agoAnd all the other software is bordering on spyware.
- YinLuck- 5y agoCould someone with pull PLEASE tell Chrome/Firefox to make 'Video Speed Controller' a default feature in their respective browsers. Its a must-have for me but it feels like something that could easily be made a default feature in a browser.
- xg15 5y agoI remember a not-so-long time ago that people were worried chrome would drop the extension system as a whole and therefore drop the ability of users to customise how they view web pages. Now extensions are a "security threat". Here we go...
- eli 5y agoboth those things are true
- xg15 5y agoOk and now what?
- derefr 5y agoIs this snark meant to imply that you think that people shouldn't acknowledge a dilemma when one exists, unless they also have a solution to offer for said dilemma? Google has nigh-on monopoly power over the browser ecosystem. Also, extensions are by-and-large malware. Making people aware that extensions are mostly malware helps Google to consolidate its monopoly; but also (obviously) helps people to avoid malware. We don't want Google to control the Internet, and we don't want browsers to be full of malware. That's a dilemma. It has no obvious solution. But it's better to be aware of the dilemma — and so realize there is no easy solution — than to ignorantly push for one side or the other to "win."
- userbinator 5y agoAt this point I'm convinced that there has to be a really strong opposition, or the Internet becomes Google's jail. We are basically seeing the dystopian side of "zero crime policies" acted out online as they slowly but surely evolve the definition of "malware" and erode away at our freedoms. Google could be educating users to make their own responsible decisions, but it's far more profitable to keep them uninformed and feed them propaganda to maintain the paranoia that lets it monetise and take control away from them. Being ultimately an ad company, it thrives on deception. and so realize there is no easy solution — than to ignorantly push for one side or the other to "win." Twenty years ago, what Apple Google Microsoft do today with their software would be widely considered adware/spyware. One side has already won the battle; we can't let it win the war. "Give me liberty or give me death," as the famous saying goes.
- ocdtrekkie 5y agoSo much this. Every extension is an attack vector. They have post-decryption access to all of your web content and largely make the entire benefit of HTTPS moot if you have a bunch of them. Every extension you install should be carefully vetted and only enabled as long as absolutely necessary. It's the top malware vector I see today.
- xg15 5y agoIs it more of an attack vector than the hundreds of unvettable third-party scripts the site usually loads itself?
- jay_kyburz 5y agoA script loaded by a site needs to escape its sandbox. I assume an extension script is not in its own sandbox so it can read you banking details when you visit a banking website. I imagine they can read key presses so an extension can know your banking passwords.
- hungryfoolish 5y agoWhich is why extensions also nowadays only served via a web store which has moderation policies and moderators which look for this kind of stuff.
- ocdtrekkie 5y agoThe Chrome Web Store is functionally a malware distribution system. There's no real moderation to speak of, and the vast majority of desktop PC malware is distributed by it.
- ocdtrekkie 5y agoAbsolutely. Scripts compromise your activity on the site they're loaded on. Extensions compromise your activity on every single website you go to.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dws 5y agoLastPass, 1Password, ...
- iso1210 5y agoSo I shouldn't have my bitwarden extension?
- fapjacks 5y agoDecentraleyes is also very helpful on the privacy front. It will cache commonly included libraries like jQuery from various CDNs like Cloudflare, preventing them from tracking you across the internet. ClearURLs is another one that I install on a freshly-opted-out Firefox, to avoid those ubiquitous tracking parameters in various URLs.