14 ms·
You’re doing exactly what you condemn in your post. I said a boring riff specifically because I wanted to highlight that there’s a huge magnitude difference whi
by Spivak 5y ago
You’re doing exactly what you condemn in your post. I said a boring riff specifically because I wanted to highlight that there’s a huge magnitude difference while being able to use the most common term for the particular line of reasoning.
You’re right, writing an OS for Google isn’t some world shaking ethical conundrum and it certainly wouldn’t be enough to turn down a FAANG salary and the experience for. But that doesn’t mean that the company’s corporate strategy for the product (i.e. the entire reason the project is funded) is suddenly irrelevant and you can wash your hands of it. If the business reason for pushing this OS is so that Google can have a desktop OS with lock-in to their services and have data collection at the deepest level like they do with Android then that doesn’t meet the bar for avoiding harm and that as engineers we ought to be empowered to push back or outright say no to to buildings things that hurt our users.
Nothing about this has anything to do with Israel or Pizzagate, or Black Lives Matter. Politics encompasses far far more than the things you see on CNN. I’m not saying that people should be advocating for random political causes they care about in the workplace. I’m saying that people should be able to act politically for things that are literally their work.
* Pushing for accessibility features being a requirement to ship is political.
* Pushing for telemetry to be anonymized is political.
* Pushing for ML datasets to include people with dark skin so they actually work is political.
* Pushing for data collection being opt-in is political.
* Refusing to build a product that interferes with EMT radio frequencies is political.