4 ms·
What we have to worry about in the mean time is environmental changes leading to crop failures. The earth will be fine, whether we are able to continually feed
by asdff 5y ago
What we have to worry about in the mean time is environmental changes leading to crop failures. The earth will be fine, whether we are able to continually feed ourselves in this society is an open question that we are actively trying to solve. But it's an uphill battle when even liberal minded people have villianized GMOs. GMOs are the tools we need to use to ensure our world is not like what was pictured in Interstellar. Inaction means famine.
- ozim 5y agoThat is the point I always see when someone is promoting "save the Earth", Earth will be fine. It is humans who will have it tough while some bugs or bacteria will not even notice when those pesky people died out.
- 77pt77 5y agoIt's not save the Earth. It's save me and my descendants. It just doesn't have the same ring to it...
- Buldak 5y agoIf you just mean that the earth will continue to exist, or that some manner of organism will live on it, then yeah that seems like a safe bet. But a lot of people think it would be a bad thing if we drove elephants to extinction, or destroyed the Great Barrier Reef (and not for any prudential reasons tied to human interests, either), and that's what they mean when they urge us to "Save the Earth."
- robben1234 5y agoExtinct elephants and destroyed reefs are small steps towards the total annihilation of humanity. It'd be much easier on personal level for everyone to justify not using plastic and voting for people who prioritize sustainability over short-term profit if green movement campaigned for saving our grand children from living in hell, than saving a floaty rock from an ephemeral threat.
- ifdefdebug 5y agoI am fine with GMO and other genetic technology in principle. But I am not happy about GMO with the sole purpose of deploying more and more herbicides. Unfortunately that's what it has been about mostly in the past.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoNot sure I agree with that. There have been several GMOs that improve yields, or improve nutrition ("golden rice").
- Loughla 5y agoYes, but OP's point is that GMO has been mostly used to enable chemical use. I am inclined to agree with them, without data. BT corn, roundup ready corn and beans, and other herbicide tolerant strains of common field crops are very, very prevalent and enable the use of not just more glyphosate to compensate for resistance in the weeds, but also accompanying chemicals for the same reasons.
- asdff 5y agoThere is more to this narrative than meets the eye. Before roundup ready crops we used far worse herbicides and pesticides that are much more prevalent in runoff and in the local ecology, like atrazine, metribuzin, and alachlor. So while they use more pounds per acre in some cases, it's usually stuff that is far less harmful to the environment. BT corn is brilliant. Bt has been used in organic farming for 50 years and doesn't harm people or animals or pollinators. Having the corn produce it directly rather than having to spray excess amounts of it regularly over your crops is a boon. You use far less since it's concentrated at the site where it matters: in the tissue the insect bites into. We have to take these measures. If we didn't treat with pesticides and herbicides, we go back to biblical plague levels of insect blight and are unable to feed our population. It happens even in backyard gardens. I've seen cabbage loopers turn my tomato plant into swiss cheese in a matter of days.
- 5y ago
- developer93 5y agoCrops can't grow in barren soil however hardy they are. Soil is dying at an amazing rate right now, it's a living ecosystem that gets renewed and changes constantly, with all the bacteria, fungus, worms, dead organic matter, minerals, air and water cycling around. Many farming methods that we use at the moment don't prioritise it, and long term they destroy the productivity of the soil. GMOs might be part of the solution but they aren't all of it.
- asdff 5y agoWith GMOs you would have a wider variety of profitable crops to rotate in your fields to rebuild soil conditions between harvests of certain crops. This sort of practice is already done in some areas where this farming is permissive, like with corn and soybean. No till practices and other soil rebuilding efforts are also finding their way into larger and larger operations.