3 ms·
Tale as old as time! I remember getting into almost a shouting match with a UI designer over this common conflict. Is it more important that the app's UI is con
by ryandrake 5y ago
Tale as old as time! I remember getting into almost a shouting match with a UI designer over this common conflict. Is it more important that the app's UI is consistent with other apps on the user's computer, or is it more important that it is consistent with the same app across all platforms (and consistent with the company's self-defined "branding")? I argued that the user expects all his apps to be consistent and look like they fit in with their other apps on the system, and the designer argued that the user doesn't care, and that our company's designers knew better than Microsoft/Apple/etc. about the best User Experience for our particular app. Seems like reasonable people can disagree about this.
- acdha 5y agoThis is also a great example of why you need good user testing: a designer is hyper aware of what they’re trying to do design-wise, developers tend to focus on implementation and support, and we’re all too familiar with the product to represent users well. I’ve seen plenty of things like that where everyone spends months on it and the outside users don’t notice/care or point out that, say, the custom design didn’t work with their system font settings or screen reader.