6 ms·
The major problem with enabling sideloading from Apple's perspective is that if they allowed sideloading, all of the big tech companies that compete with Apple
by gjsman-1000 5y ago
The major problem with enabling sideloading from Apple's perspective is that if they allowed sideloading, all of the big tech companies that compete with Apple would happily, immediately, force users to sideload their app.
Case study: Facebook. Hates Apple for the App Tracking Transparency prompt. Hates that they get substantially less revenue from iPhone users, according to leaked slides, due to restrictions on what APIs they can use to fingerprint and track users. Hates having a Privacy Label in the App Store. Solution? Force users to sideload. They'll most likely do it because they want Facebook, Facebook doesn't need to follow Apple's rules anymore, problem solved.
In that case, it is less that Apple is afraid of giving users the choice, as much as that large apps that people use will force users to make the choice for them.
And for that reason, while some users would legitimately want their iPhones to be able to install apps from anywhere, most users hitting the "Allow Sideloading" button would have essentially been forced into doing so, without actually wanting it.
- endemic 5y agoNot sure if that would be a panacea for Facebook in this case. Aren't the privacy controls built into the OS?
- gjsman-1000 5y agoNot everything. The transparency prompt would still appear, but Facebook wouldn't need to show users that Privacy Label in the App Store. They could also access restricted iOS Entitlements that the App Store would not permit. These entitlements can do things such as "read data from other apps" or "see what apps are installed in the system" or other functionality that the App Store doesn't allow under almost any circumstances. If sideloading was enabled, Facebook could claim use of those entitlements. iOS could potentially show a prompt forcing users to OK their use, but Facebook would obviously hope most people just tap the button without thinking.
- clairity 5y agofurther toward the ideal consumer outcome, the apple app store would be compelled to compete with any other ios app store (e.g., cydia) but apple would be allowed to be as stringent about security and privacy of the device as they’d like (promoting competition in the mobile phone market, in addition to the apps/app store market). then, facebook couldn’t circumvent the protections that consumers want in their mobile devices by hopping to another app store.
- cloogshicer 5y agoThere is one thing I would like to expand upon in what you said: > Apple is afraid of giving users the choice, as much as that large apps that people use will force users to make the choice for them. That assumes that users have no choice but keep using the side loaded software. But that's not true. People could just stop using Facebook entirely. I guess the majority wouldn't, but the choice is there at least. In regards to privacy, I agree with Apple's stance. But what about other areas? I don't want one single company dictating what I can or can't use on my device.
- gjsman-1000 5y ago"People could just stop using Facebook entirely." If people are still using Facebook, today, knowing all that has happened, the odds are most people will continue using it though one can dream. I would honestly expect 90%+ of Facebook users to sideload if Facebook required it. "But what about other areas? I don't want one single company dictating what I can or can't use on my device." If you told this to an Apple Engineer, he'd look at you in the eye and tell you that the iPhone isn't for you and to buy an Android. You have that choice. The iPhone doesn't fit your use case and Apple isn't interested in making it fit your use case.
- smoldesu 5y ago> If you told this to an Apple Engineer, he'd look at you in the eye and tell you that the iPhone isn't for you and to buy an Android. Easy solution for Apple then: stop selling things labelled as "pro". I was already burned when I bought the 16 inch Macbook Pro, which was a shockingly incapable and undocumented device. Lenovo provides better documentation on their entry level laptops than Apple provides for their Pros, despite the order of magnitude difference in price between both devices. So to the "Apple Engineer" out there, I'd encourage you give people the choice anyways. In other words, North Korea doesn't justify their atrocities by telling the rest of the world that their culture "isn't for them". Apple is no less accountable for their own product line, particularly when they're some of the most profitable electronic hardware being manufactured right now.
- 5y ago
- asiachick 5y agothere is zero evidence this is true. none of those companies are asking users to sideload on Android.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoActually, there is much evidence. The Google Play Store is significantly less stringent on Android than iOS. For example, Google is estimated to get less than 1/10th the data from an iOS user as an Android user. The Play Store also, currently, doesn't effectively enforce the use of Google In-App-Purchase. Because of that, there are less reasons to sideload away from the Play Store (from a company's perspective) as there are on iOS.
- my123 5y ago> The Play Store also, currently, doesn't effectively enforce the use of Google In-App-Purchase. https://www.cnbc.com/2020/09/28/google-to-enforce-30percent-cut-on-in-app-purchases-next-year.html https://www.cnbc.com/2020/09/28/google-to-enforce-30percent-... Starting from September 30, that's no longer the case.
- Despegar 5y agoThat's exactly right. Apple is the users' union that protects them from developers.
- handrous 5y agoThat's a great way to put it. Absent government bans on a bunch of the bad behavior Apple outlaws in its store, I'd really rather keep the choice of selecting Apple's "users' union". When spying on users and hoarding the resulting data is illegal, and anti-fraud laws and truth-in-advertising laws and laws mandating a standard interface for subscription management exist or are much better-enforced, then, sure, let's grab the torches and pitchforks and burn down the App Store. Meanwhile, I'm paying Apple to be my private regulation agency, backed by their sheer size (as a company, and of their market) to prevent companies and developers from simply refusing to do business with them (and so, not forcing, but strongly encouraging them to provide me with regulation-compliant products and services).
- Ruthalas 5y agoThis seems only partially accurate, in that the users have no say in their representation, unlike a union.
- redler 5y agoFurthermore, any big vendor (e.g. Facebook) with its own vast audience and ecosystem would immediately launch its own app store, with its own payment model and revenue cut, its own exclusive titles, developer relationships, and (one assumes) its own vastly more liberal policy with respect to privacy-exploitative dark-pattern apps (notwithstanding that Apple's app store certainly doesn't restrict all such things). The sideloaded Facebook "app" would not simply be Facebook, but the Facebook App Store.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoAnd where does that end? Google's got a bunch of apps like Gmail and Google Drive, so the Google Play Store for iOS would probably enter the ring too. The point is more that if the App Store is to be the only App Store on iOS, and Apple wants to maintain its rules on privacy and other systems and not become Android, sideloading logically cannot be permitted.
- heavyset_go 5y ago> Furthermore, any big vendor (e.g. Facebook) with its own vast audience and ecosystem would immediately launch its own app store And yet there is no precedent for this happening, because this didn't happen on Android, Windows or macOS. The Play Store shows the same scary privacy warnings the App Store does for Facebook, and there still isn't a Facebook app store that some people like to fearmonger about.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoThe Play Store cannot be compared to the iOS App Store, the Windows Store, or the macOS App Store because the iOS App Store is substantially more stringent than the Play Store in what apps are even allowed to request permission for, their sandboxing restrictions, and their privacy requirements. For example, Google gets more than 10X the data from their Android app than they get from their iOS app according to estimates. Also, Google Play only shows a request for Permissions, while iOS shows the entire list of what data is collected that is linked to you, and the data that is collected that is not linked to you, which means that the "scary privacy warnings" are substantially scarier on iOS and don't bear the comparison to the permissions-only Play Store.
- josephcsible 5y ago> if they allowed sideloading, all of the big tech companies that compete with Apple would happily, immediately, force users to sideload their app. Google allows sideloading on Android. Neither Facebook nor any other similarly-popular app that I can think of forces users to sideload there. Why would it be different on iOS?
- BugsJustFindMe 5y ago> Why would it be different on iOS? Facebook hasn't taken out any full page ads in the New York Times, Wall Street Journal, Washington Post, and probably others about Google Android not allowing them to track you without asking first. Clearly the circumstances are different.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoDoes Google currently provide the same abilities to block tracking as Apple?
- josephcsible 5y agoWhy does that matter? Why would Apple's technical features to block tracking suddenly stop working just because an app was sideloaded?
- lotsofpulp 5y agoComparing Facebook's decision to not side load on Android is not a comparable situation if the incentives to side load are not the same.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoIf an app finds a way around Apple's user privacy wall, in the App Store it can be pulled.
- handrous 5y agoNot all of the tracking-blocking is technical, and those parts can't be technical, either.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gnopgnip 5y agoThis isn't the case though. Anyone can install Facebook, or Apple music, Netflix, any of the Microsoft or Amazon apps on Android through the play store, without needing to sideload.
- arvinsim 5y agoI honestly don’t get it. I thought that sideloading just concerns installation of the app, not accessing private APIs.