4 ms·
> Ultimately the real question is, does it affect our survivability as a species. Biology is a rich and wealthy system of evolved solutions for living on earth
by echelon 5y ago
> Ultimately the real question is, does it affect our survivability as a species.
Biology is a rich and wealthy system of evolved solutions for living on earth.
We could turn everything into people, but we'd lose so much information. Fungal growths on rocks may not seem like a lot to a layperson without appreciation, but such species took more work than the sum total human thought to arise. Killing it off is akin to burning the entire library of congress. Worse, perhaps.
We're too primitive to harness the wealth of information in our biosphere today. In a hundred years, there will be solutions in biology readily available to biochemical problems we're only beginning to characterize.
We hate that we killed the dodo and the woolly mammoth. But more than just erasing animals we learned about in childhood, and more than leaving holes in ecosystems, we destroyed the living and breathing universe solving unique and beautiful ways of dealing with itself. Solutions too complicated for humans to comprehend, and not even close to within our capacity to replicate.
- Mediterraneo10 5y agoThat is an interesting perspective. It seems like the complete 180 degrees of the "singularity" fad that peaked a couple of decades ago, which envisioned humans eventually turning all matter on Earth (including the biosphere) and in the solar system into computing hardware, because that would be information-maximizing.
- defterGoose 5y agoThe problem with that line of thinking is that we're simply not wise enough to know what should be computed. Life computes more life, but humans seem to be able to do no better than cryptocurrency on the average.
- courtf 5y agoBeautiful comment,thank you. The closer we look at anything, like fungal growths, the more we realize how little we actually understand. Trying to tease apart the microscopic mechanisms that underlay the behaviors of fungal spores and slime molds is enough to make an atheist reach for God. The world is still very much inexplicable and so exquisite, it puts our efforts as builders to shame. Everything is a rabbit hole stretching back to the creation of the universe, just as humans have inherited life from an unbroken chain of organisms stretching back to the first cell. We are still evolving, still bringing our frontal cortexes fully online, like teenagers. It is hubris to assume we are anything more than the link between our past forms and our future forms, although we may not survive through this particular transition.
- nahuel0x 5y agoWe are not much different of a paperclip-making AI gone rogue