3 ms·
Why is it generally bad for bosses to solicit sex from their employees? Clearly there is something distinguishing some power imbalances from others.
by whimsicalism 5y ago
Why is it generally bad for bosses to solicit sex from their employees?
Clearly there is something distinguishing some power imbalances from others.
- incrudible 5y ago> Why is it generally bad for bosses to solicit sex from their employees? Because, unlike a sugar baby, that's not what the employee signed up for.
- whimsicalism 5y agoThey can quit, generally one's job role doesn't stay entirely static. Oftentimes, a role changes to something that an employee didn't sign up for. Perhaps there is something unique about sex and how it interacts with power dynamics? I want to capture the intuition that we generally all share around stuff like this. A statement like > Just because it’s related to sex does not make it more of an imbalance. does not seem to capture this intuition that most people hold.
- incrudible 5y ago> Oftentimes, a role changes to something that an employee didn't sign up for. ...which is also generally bad if the role is materially different and goes on top of what was signed up for, with little to no extra compensation. > Perhaps there is something unique about sex and how it interacts with power dynamics? Suppose that your boss asked you, in addition to your current duties, instead of giving sexual favors, you follow him home and do all his laundry - with the same implication that your career hinges on it. Would that change the power dynamic? I don't think so. The only thing that "sex" changes is that it arouses attention.
- whimsicalism 5y agoYes, I think it would be worse if my boss said I must have sex with them in order to keep my job than if they asked me to do their laundry. Both are bad, but I disagree with your moral intuition - and suspect most people would as well. The key moral fact here is more than just "it's not what you signed up for"
- incrudible 5y agoWhether you signed up for it is they key distinction. Suppose you had signed up for sex with your boss, but then he also also asks you to do the laundry - which wasn't part of the deal. That's bad. Vice versa may be worse, but either is bad. We wouldn't consider it fair just because it doesn't involve sex. In either situation, the power balance is the same. Your boss doesn't get more power just because he asks for sex instead of laundry.
- darkwizard42 5y agoIt is bad because the boss has generally direct control of your economic security. Coercing someone into a sexual relationship as a condition of your employment (that has nothing to do with that relationship sexual or otherwise) is wrong (and illegal in the US). If the entire relationship is premised upon sexual favors or sugar daddy style relationship, there is definitely a different power imbalance than one where you are being blackmailed/coerced into something you didn't originally sign up for.
- whimsicalism 5y agoYour contract generally doesn't state your job duties. The person paying you for sex also has control of your economic security. Are you saying the relevant important factor is that they are an employee and not a contractor? > wrong (and illegal in the US). Sure, but prostitution is also generally illegal in the US as well.
- DocTomoe 5y agoBecause sex is not usually part of your job description. That obviously was different on this platform.
- whimsicalism 5y agoWould you feel equally icky about employees being asked to do other things that weren't part of the original job description? If you are hired as a coder, and the boss asks you to start also joining sales/marketing calls with them (not in your job description) is that of equal moral ickyness as if the boss asks you to have sex with them or a third party (similarly, not in the job description)? I think not, but the explanation provided definitely doesn't capture that intuition.
- DocTomoe 5y agoEvery single software engineer contract I've seen in my career had something about 'providing consulting services' in it. But it comes down to personal comfort zone. Someone who tries to get a coder job is comfortable with coding, but may not be comfortable with doing electric installations, which clearly is not in the job description - and I would expect any of my team to tell me to go fish when I come to them with 400 meters of copper cables and a screwdriver. Women who are on that platform obviously are comfortable with the idea of exchanging sexual favours with clients. They may have limits on certain practices, and they probably would not be comfortable doing something icky and morally corrupt as coding. Moral is something very subjective, and I consider it pretentious for someone to push their own morals on others. If the people involved in that platform are ok with this, if they do these transactions out of their own volition, it is obviously wrong to send a sharia morality police after them because some grandma or some priest might be offended.