3 ms·
Why a password ? Passwords are terrible. What you'd ideally want is a source of cryptographically strong random numbers and some storage. If storage is cheap,
by tialaramex 5y ago
Why a password ? Passwords are terrible.
What you'd ideally want is a source of cryptographically strong random numbers and some storage.
If storage is cheap, you should have lots of storage, and then you can mint as many keys (including persistent public identity keys) as you like, indexed by context. This is preferable.
If storage is very expensive you can't afford to do that, you should mint one long-term symmetric key, never given to anybody, and then do the same trick that's inside cheap FIDO devices to mint key pairs, then encrypt the private half with the symmetric key and context, so that you can give both halves to relying parties. If played back in the correct context you can decrypt your private key again. You incur considerable practical inconveniences but you do keep key privacy and security guarantees from the above approach.
Today some places will issue you with a single long term identity key bound to your legal identity. Which is useful but (intentionally) lacks privacy guarantees, and, since it's an external device, you can lose it.
The Orphan Yatima (and presumably also the ordinary children conceived in what amounts to the "natural" way for Polis Citizens) in Greg Egan's novel "Diaspora" has public key crypto inside. Once the polis concludes that Yatima has personhood, it seals their cryptographic key management so that nothing anybody else can do (short of destroying the polis physically) can tamper with it. Yatima can prove they are Yatima, if they want, and nobody else can ever impersonate them.
- riversflow 5y ago>Why a password ? Passwords are terrible. Because our culture/society fundamentally lacks the understanding of security that you and I do. Education needs to adapt for the modern times. Media literacy, CS fundamentals, and a basic understanding of how the Internet works should all be learned well before college. If we don't have a shared cultural understanding about the way we exist relative to technology, I fear we are destined to become enslaved by it.