6 ms·
> if someone tells me , I want to port my data to competitor, because my UI better then theirs, but they still prefer competitor, why should I care about this r
by TeMPOraL 5y ago
> if someone tells me , I want to port my data to competitor, because my UI better then theirs, but they still prefer competitor, why should I care about this requests, why should i spent a single second of my engineers time to implement that?
Because you're a good person and care about providing value to your users, and not just extracting value from them.
But since in practice, we can't rely on every business to be run by good citizens, this needs to be made a legal requirement, to remove the competitive advantage from being predatory and locking users down.
- ohwanderu 5y agoIt would also be highly valuable to me as a user to receive a $500/week check from all the services I use. Who at Emergynt can I reach out to in order to get this?
- TeMPOraL 5y agoNo one, since you aren't using any of Emergynt's services. Also, nice low-effort doxx. Reminds me I need to update my LinkedIn profile.
- golergka 5y ago> Because you're a good person and care about providing value to your users, and not just extracting value from them. That's a false dichotomy that is also misrepresents the nature of a typical business transaction. If you're a good person and a business owner, you're looking to make mutually beneficial business transactions. If someone is looking to move away from using your business, then it's them who's trying to extract value from you, without giving anything in return. Of course, sometimes, as just a good person, you want to do good for other people without anything in return — but you can do it as a private person, putting your profits into charity funds. Separation of concerns is a good thing that make things clear. Also, from any moral point of view, money spent on engineer salary that allows some food app user to migrate to a competitor is probably not spent as well as feeding hungry or providing health care to sick anyway.
- TeMPOraL 5y ago> If you're a good person and a business owner, you're looking to make mutually beneficial business transactions. Exactly this. The transactions become much less mutually beneficial if the business is trying to hold my data hostage. Especially if they gave no indication of it previously, back when I was still evaluating the value of the transaction. We had a good time, I got value from their services, they got my money and perhaps some extra benefits too - now it's time for us to part ways, I'm packing and I want my stuff back. > If someone is looking to move away from using your business, then it's them who's trying to extract value from you, without giving anything in return. Transactions on the market are supposed to be voluntary. This means I should be free to move away from using any business, after discharging all my obligations to it that I voluntarily accepted. By switching to a competitor, I'm not taking any more value from the company. As for asking for my data back, a business should consider my data loaned to them. It's their obligation - social, and now legal - to give it back. GDPR specifies more than one way to do this. Controller to Subject transfers are a no-brainer. It's my data, I want it back. Controller to Controller transfers are gated by "where technically feasible". This point is there to ensure that businesses which don't have the necessary infrastructure in place aren't forced to spend time and effort to build it up. Only those that can do it at negligible costs are being forced to provide this option.
- jrochkind1 5y agogolergka's daycare service: you can check your kids in, but you can never check them out. it just wouldn't be mutually beneficial, sorry.
- colejohnson66 5y agoIf you went with a hotel service, you could’ve made a Hotel California reference ;)
- ryandrake 5y agoWhile I agree 100% with this response, let's for the sake of argument assume OP is not a good person, and doesn't actually care about providing value to users. An answer to "why" that does not depend on voluntary goodness is: Enough people is the world generally think representative democracy is a good thing. We stand by that system for making the rules. Enough people in part of the world think there is enough of a problem to the point where a rule was made. If you want to do business in that part of the world, you need to be bound by that rule. That's why you should spend time on it. As incomprehensible as it might be, it's important enough to those citizens that they are willing to levy a penalty on you if you don't. ...and so far, at least three people actually took time out of their day to go find the "down" arrow on this obviously raving insane viewpoint :) I love you guys!
- TeMPOraL 5y agoAgreed. I'll add another argument that doesn't depend on voluntary goodness, just on longer-term thinking: if you can establish a reputation that you're not making it hard for users to migrate away from you, people will be more likely to try your services out in the first place. And yet another long-term thinking argument: if being able to easily export and migrate data between competing services becomes commonplace, then you'll not only have an outflow of users to competitors, you'll also have an influx of users migrating from your competitors. If you're trying to put a superior service on a market dominated by inferior incumbents, it's in your interest to promote data portability, as - if your service is truly as good as you think - user flow will predominantly go towards your business.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoDemocracy takes precedence over markets and profit, what kind of madness is this?
- jpttsn 5y agoInvoluntary goodness. Is the point that you should feel good about any regulation, by virtue of its being the result of a democratic process? For (counter)example, I might not normally feel good about implementing “Muslim ban” functionality even if I recognize the nominally democratic process that forces me to.
- toolz 5y agothe spirit of such a law is great, but there's a huge problem - what does the implementation even look like? Are we going to have regulatory committees oversee which types of data should be portable and when? Who writes the protocols? The implementation of such a law is impossible as far as I can tell and opens up huge vulnerabilities to smaller companies. Just imagine when large companies can hire lobbyists that can force a data protocol on the smaller businesses. The spirit of many laws is great, the implementation is unfortunately, what actually matters and I don't see solutions to these hard problems. Allow me to go on a soapbox here, but far too many laws are created with good intentions that are destroying competition and hurting the end users.
- capableweb 5y ago> The implementation of such a law is impossible as far as I can tell and opens up huge vulnerabilities to smaller companies. Have you actually read the article from GDPR about "Data Portability"? (https://gdpr-info.eu/art-20-gdpr/ https://gdpr-info.eu/art-20-gdpr/) It's easier than you think. Offer a endpoint that spits out a ZIP file with JSON/multimedia of all the data you have associated with the user. Now you're done, you don't have to do anything else. If possible, you should provide a good format (see my other comment https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27278816 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27278816) but you're not strictly required to. The intent of the article is not to allow people to import Facebook posts into Twitter, the intent of the article is to force businesses to allow people to export their data in a machine-readable format. What that entails exactly is up to each company to decide, and court of law to determine if it was followed properly.
- toolz 5y agoI hadn't read the law yet, thanks for the link, but I don't think that solves any problems at all and has potential for plenty of issues. The devil is in the details and the people already have the power to only use services that allow data exporting. You're attempting to force companies to behave in a pro-social manner but if that company never wanted to behave in a pro-social manner we'll have just given them another attack surface with their lobbyists to use to kill their competitors. I'll withhold judgement until I see how this plays out, it could end up being a great thing, the issue with laws isn't that they can't help - the issue is that laws that end up hurting almost never go away.