7 ms·
> Leftover laws are weird things. Fun fact: just like this old tax that the Italian residents are unhappy with, every single person that was old enough to vote
by sneak 5y ago
> Leftover laws are weird things.
Fun fact: just like this old tax that the Italian residents are unhappy with, every single person that was old enough to vote for their representatives who then voted to ratify the income tax amendment in the USA is now dead. There is no one alive in the USA that was in any way represented in the vote for income tax; conversely everyone that is alive in the US today and is subject to it did not have any input into it: they were simply born into it, unrepresented, just as these Italians were.
There is a strong argument for all laws having an expiration date a few years past the expected lifespan of the youngest constituent of the represented population that passed it, otherwise we end up ruled primarily by those long dead, entirely unknown to us, as the laws pile up, amended in perpetuity but never aging out.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- CogitoCogito 5y agoToday's voters are capable of electing representatives who could repeal that amendment. It's not like voters are left without recourse.
- sneak 5y agoIt appears that elected officials have an extremely strong bias to adding/amending versus repealing/scaling back. I'm not sure the current approach is long-term viable.
- yunohn 5y ago> elected officials have an extremely strong bias to adding/amending versus repealing/scaling back I find this to be a crippling problem of how politics works in modern democracies. Taxes are a great example, because almost every country will increase it, but never decrease it. They’ll think of a 100 new ways to extract taxes, but never remove outdated ones.
- jokethrowaway 5y agoVery true: my personal solution is to shop for better countries. There's no way to meaningfully influence the government's overreach. Hopefully this will become a trend and the cheapest countries will attract better talent.
- reedjosh 5y agoUN, WHO, WEF, WTO, and more... Where will you shop to as these unelected organizations gradually ascend?
- munk-a 5y ago> Hopefully this will become a trend and the cheapest countries will attract better talent. Hrm, I disagree. I think the most beneficial countries will attract better talent. Having a low tax bill doesn't mean much if I need to pay for things privately. I also personally emigrated from the US owing to the fact that healthcare there is immoral and it felt like (about a decade ago when I left) the country was on the path to major unrest. I've been quite happy up here in Canada where I pay more taxes but get to work with people who aren't burdened down by the stress of untreated health issues.
- ateng 5y agoNot necessarily. 50s / 60s US income tax is much, much higher than current rate. I just think the cycle of going up and down is extremely long. https://commons.m.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Historical_Marginal_Tax_Rate_for_Highest_and_Lowest_Income_Earners.jpg https://commons.m.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Historical_Margina...
- intrasight 5y agoWho else sees a software dev analogy here. Perhaps we need a law that says every 10 years we have a "sprint" to address the "technical dept" of anachronistic laws.
- MrBuddyCasino 5y ago> I'm not sure the current approach is long-term viable. Can anyone of the downvoters say a few words? To me this seems both obvious and non-partisan. What we're doing is accruing ever more laws, creating a centuries-old legal code base without ever removing technical debt. This seems unwise.
- munk-a 5y ago(I wasn't a downvoter but sure) Law isn't a simple practice due to the breadth of subjects it covers - but it is very simplified by the human factor. When laws are enforced they are done so after advocacy from a pair of humans and by the judgement of a human for penalty and possibly guilt (in some cases guilt is determined by a pool of jurors). This means it's very different from programming where we have a dumb machine that is, at it's best ability, able to look at two numbers and tell you which one is bigger. When it comes to software edge cases must be explicit and factors must be encodable - violations must be recognizable by an algorithm and all cases must be covered. Compare that to the law where generally there are a set of guidelines that have slowly evolved over time to cover more and more edge cases - but viewing any law ever written as completely true to the letter would be a mistake - there will always be carve outs and reasonable judgement entering the picture. I think the main problem with criticizing the creation of more laws is that we don't currently have laws to cover every situation and it's unreasonable to think we ever will - it'd be nice to get rid of some of the stupid ones but I strongly suspect you'll see this town in Italy end up being freed from any obligations since this hereditary claim is pretty bonkers. Lastly I might point at countries with a long continuous legal history like England which hasn't changed governments violently or due to outside influence in a loooong time. There are a lot of really crazy real estate claims there, sure - but for the day to day stuff, the laws work. The cost of training lawyers might slowly be creeping up[1] but we aren't anywhere near a critical point of being unable to apply laws. I suspect that point will never be reached and we'll just see more and more specialty in legal professions - instead of an advocate in 1820 you can now hire a lawyer specialized in watershed rights. I expect that trend to continue with specialties deepening and growing further apart just like we've seen with development. You couldn't hire an "ops" guy in the 70's - everyone was expected to be well versed in operating system configuration, interaction and most were probably expected to be familiar with design. So, I don't think this is actually an issue at quite the level you mentioned - but I do think it's one of these slowly creeping growth factors that makes us more vulnerable to societal system collapse. 1. I'd guess really slowly though since even in the US where precedent is a factor most relevant case rulings are probably from before 1870.
- _jal 5y ago> I'm not sure the current approach is long-term viable. If your long-term is long enough, you're guaranteed to be correct... Putting that aside, even if you think your 'big change' is right and prudent and will Make Things Better, other people have their own plans. Now, unless you get rid of popular representation, you have legal hysteresis, and everyone's planning horizon lasts until the Next Big Change. Suddenly nobody's building nothing. So you're left with a mess or an authoritarian government. Resistance to wild swings is actual conservatism at work, and is a very good thing.
- reedjosh 5y agoI do not believe this true. War over the past 20 years has been overwhelmingly unpopular. Have we in the US been able to stop that? What then also of the minority that lives under these laws? I never once consented to them, and yet must submit to the majority.
- mullen 5y ago> What then also of the minority that lives under these laws? I never once consented to them, and yet must submit to the majority. And you receive their benefit too. You might not like paying taxes but you receive the benefit of paying taxes, that is why you are forced to pay taxes like everyone else. Some people get more benefit than others but we all get something from paying taxes. If you don't like paying taxes, then you are free to move to a place where there are no taxes and no benefit from them. I recommend Somalia, I heard it's lovely this time of year.
- reedjosh 5y agoAnd what of the wars?
- munk-a 5y agoThe US has a severe representation issue. Other folks have spoken well about the advantages of proportional representation vs. FPTP but if you're looking for something to blame for an effective lack of representation I'd look there first. Honestly, if the US election before this previous one didn't have primaries and was an open field race there is almost no chance the former president would have been elected - and if the government was run on a parliamentary system even if his party had won there's no chance they would've brought him in as PM. I am a one issue voter and my issue is proportional representation.
- reedjosh 5y agoI like CGP Grey on this issue. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s7tWHJfhiyo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s7tWHJfhiyo I completely agree as far as voting methods are concerned and do think it would be a better system, but I still don't like giving a group of people rights to commit acts considered immoral when done by an individual.
- barrkel 5y agoYour "strong argument" is in direct opposition to the fundamental principle of common law: precedent.
- jokethrowaway 5y agoIncome tax in the USA was meant to be a temporary measure to support a war effort. There are similar stories in other countries. There's nothing more permanent than a temporary government plan.
- yonaguska 5y agoI hope that no one is making this same comment about masks and social distancing in 20 years.
- brewdad 5y agoMasks suck but I enjoy having a bit of my personal space back.
- bluGill 5y agoNo it wasn't. Those for it said that, but it is clear from their efforts of the many decades prior that they wanted it to continue forever.
- bm1362 5y agoIn modern monetary policy, income tax is used as a deflationary measure and our government is funded by the fed.
- drdec 5y agoUnfortunately they have a way of making war last forever as well.
- bigbillheck 5y agoThere's also no-one now alive who voted for women's suffrage, or the banning of the international slave trade, or the right to bear arms.
- reedjosh 5y agoNon-aggression and property rights are the only laws that truly matter. Natural rights stem from these principals. > women's suffrage If a government doesn't have a monopoly of force, nobody needs to vote or even acknowledge the government. > banning of the international slave trade Your body is your possession. Slavery violates that and the non-aggression principle. > the right to bear arms Who grants this right? The government doesn't have the right to take any property. It does so via aggression and violates natural rights.
- bigbillheck 5y ago> Non-aggression and property rights are the only laws that truly matter That's certainly an assertion, but not one that I accept.
- kristjansson 5y ago> If a government doesn't have a monopoly of force, nobody needs to vote or even acknowledge the government. Meaning disputes with a government are settled (resisted) by ... force and violence?
- aliasEli 5y agoHow about Switzerland? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women%27s_suffrage_in_Switzerland https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women%27s_suffrage_in_Switzerl...