3 ms·
Even without going archaic, I had to take insurance when I bought a terrace, because a lease existed on the land at some point but the owning company had dissol
by toyg 5y ago
Even without going archaic, I had to take insurance when I bought a terrace, because a lease existed on the land at some point but the owning company had dissolved years prior and no lease had been paid for a long time. This is very common in a country (UK) where the State has had strong continuity for several centuries, so land rights and entitlements can be tracked very far back.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoThese things really are to extract money and commissions during the property purchase. In most cases there is no issue at all but no-one is going to question paying a few pounds extra on a property purchase "for peace of mind".
- ajdlinux 5y agoWhen the likelihood of the risk is small, but the potential damage bill could be financially catastrophic, I think it's perfectly rational to buy insurance if the premium is so low.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoSure. My point is that often the risk is not small, it's non-existent. When I bought my current house my solicitor suggested that the seller should pay for insurance cover for the fact that there was no planning paperwork for a small side extension. Of course I said OK and of course the seller also agreed. But that extension was even shown on the land registry plan and was obviously 20+ years old. Since planning breach action is limited to 4 years there was no chance of any problem. Free money for insurer, commissions, etc.
- gambiting 5y agoSo I've done the same when I bought my last house(conservatory built 20 years ago, seller couldn't produce the correct paperwork for it), but the issue wasn't the planning permissions per se, it was that the original builder of the house(Belway) hasn't given permission and they reserve the right to do so for 99 years after construction(even though the house is a freehold now, the entire estate is still Belway's leasehold). So the insurance was against that as well. Like, are the chances of Belway complaining and landing us in legal trouble close to zero? Yes, they are, but like said above - it was £50 and I got the seller to pay for it. When we sell the house I'll do the same just to avoid any bumps in the process because of it.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoHence why I wrote 'often'. There are obviously cases where there is a real, if small, risk. Another thing: You already say that you would be fine paying for the person you will buy the house in the future. However, many indemnity policies run in perpetuity so in principle will still apply and there will be no need to buy a new one.
- TheCoelacanth 5y agoHow do you make sure that the possibility is actually non-existent? If it's only a small one-time payment, then it probably makes sense to pay someone that much just for doing the work to verify that it's not going to happen.
- willyt 5y agoPlanning enforcement is 12 years from the date at which it became obvious that building works had been completed. So if you build a castle inside a agricultural shed and take the shed down after 12 years, the timer starts after you take down the shed. Also, there are many caveats and Planning law is complicated and often quite vague in Britain, so you should take advice on your specific situation.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoIt's either 4 years or 10 years from completion depending on cases except if it was deliberately hidden [1]. In my case, the development became immune after 4 years, that's the most common case (e.g. extensions, conservatories, fences, etc) [1] https://www.gov.uk/guidance/ensuring-effective-enforcement https://www.gov.uk/guidance/ensuring-effective-enforcement
- quietbritishjim 5y agoPlanning enforcement for domestic development in England is definitely 4 years, I agree with the parent comment. There was that one guy who covered his castle in hay bales for just over 4 years before revealing it and they took enforcement action successfully, but that's a bit different. I'm guessing that's why you said "became obvious that building works had been completed" but actually the rule is simply completion date but the courts decided that this guy was taking the piss so much that he still violated the intended meaning of the law. Your odd agricultural shed example may well fall foul of the same thing but I don't see what that has to do with the parent comment. It's 10 years (not 12) in some cases but they wouldn't concern most domestic developments. Any insurance of the type referred to by the parent comment is 100% definitely a swindle.
- toyg 5y agoIt was literally a one-off £4 in 2006. I doubt it helped the solicitor in any way...
- ajdlinux 5y agoIndeed if you have a fixed fee conveyancing deal (I'm not sure about the UK but it seems common over here) the solicitor is probably losing money just on the administration of filling out the paperwork and then billing you that 4 pounds...
- mytailorisrich 5y agoThose indemnity policies are so common that any related admin work has to be included into fixed fee conveyancing deals. In fact I suspect that these policies are so common partly because of they save solicitors' time and efforts, not least when they are on a fixed fee: They don't spend time looking into things they just suggest indemnity policies so they are covered and move on.
- darkarmani 5y agoIn the US there is adverse possession, so if someone openly claims the land (living, using, maintaining, etc) for many years (10-20?), they can end up owning the land. It helps settle minor arguments between property lines where fences existed for 50 years but the true line was not on the fence line.