4 ms·
> I would like there to be a funding scheme for most public services similar to the UK student loan system. Where you pay out of your own pocket, ultimately, bu
by lmm 5y ago
> I would like there to be a funding scheme for most public services similar to the UK student loan system. Where you pay out of your own pocket, ultimately, but only as a fraction of your income and above a certain very livable minimum, and only for the services that you personally use.
If you do that you disincentivise the rich (who tend to also be the powerful) from using those services, and encourage a two-tier system. The British public commits to the NHS or museums because rich and poor alike can use them without fear of one day being charged; furthermore the benefits are shared by everyone even if they aren't direct users (and this is especially true for public transit, which frees up space for others, and increases the labour supply in the cities, pushing down the prices of everything). Funding from general taxation that's paid by everyone is far better than charging individual users (the flip side is that benefits should not be means-tested, for the same reasons).
- admissionsguy 5y ago> If you do that you disincentivise the rich (who tend to also be the powerful) from using those services, and encourage a two-tier system. The total payment would be capped at the actual cost (slightly above to cover for those who earn below the minimum), like the student loan. That would mitigate the issue somewhat, although admittedly not entirely. The issue with general taxation is that it leaves so many people feeling disenfranchised and apathetic with regards to their taxes due to no real idea or impact on where their money goes. It also incentivises inefficiency.
- lmm 5y ago> The total payment would be capped at the actual cost (slightly above to cover for those who earn below the minimum), like the student loan. That would mitigate the issue somewhat, although admittedly not entirely. If you charge more than the actual cost, why would anyone in the chargeable bracket not pursue a private alternative? > The issue with general taxation is that it leaves so many people feeling disenfranchised and apathetic with regards to their taxes due to no real idea or impact on where their money goes. It also incentivises inefficiency. Society is complex and barely understood, it's best to be honest with ourselves about that. I don't think "incentivises inefficiency" is true; an agency that charges users is encouraged to maximise its number of users, maybe, but that's not going to be a good proxy for the public good - for many agencies the goal should be making sure users never need that agency again.
- bullianbp 5y agoThe marginal cost of a passenger on public transport is much less than the cost of a taxi. Even if the ceiling is double this cost it's still a good deal. The marginal cost of an entry to a public museum is typically much less than the price of entry to a private museum. When you compare the relative quality of the museums it is much much less.
- lmm 5y ago> The marginal cost of a passenger on public transport is much less than the cost of a taxi. Even if the ceiling is double this cost it's still a good deal. Until private industry starts doing things like the Google buses. > The marginal cost of an entry to a public museum is typically much less than the price of entry to a private museum. Public museums may charge but they're still heavily subsidized.
- KptMarchewa 5y ago>If you charge more than the actual cost, why would anyone in the chargeable bracket not pursue a private alternative? 1) "cost" is not equivalent to a value gained by studying there. Even in extremely costly US universities, on average it's advantageous to pursue education. 2) If you charge over "actual cost" in Europe, it's still way less than US prices, inflated among others by byzantine administration. 3) In most of Europe, private universities are complete joke.
- bullianbp 5y agoIn practice many very rich people in the UK have some form of private healthcare. The NHS has historically relied on rationing by queuing - since most demand for healthcase is very inelastic you need a lot of queuing to reduce demand by much. There's also a lot of rationing by bureacracy, or rationing by telling you you can't have something and then you having to repeatedly beg for treatment that you or your child badly needs. I support universal healthcare but I think the British system is not the best. It is the best at one thing - providing near-First World quality care at near-Third World total cost. The rhetoric around the generosity of the system and how lucky we are to have it is the same thing which allows it to be degraded. Lots of (mainly poorer and less educated) people put up with substandard care, simply because they feel it would be ungrateful or entitled to ask for basic things. Lots of wealthier and better educated people, who would pay for top-up coverage in the French system, get a better standard of treatment for free simply by demanding it. And 'going private' is an either-or - once you get private coverage you opt out of the public system and no longer have any stake in it.
- iso1631 5y agoI've never encountered a queue for any urgent care. Last time I made a GP appointment I did have to wait until the afternoon though. But you're right, just pay £40 a month and get bupa if you want faster care for non urgent cases.
- bullianbp 5y agoDid I say urgent care? The existence of NHS waiting lists is a well telegraphed problem. Typically these are for medically necessary procedures which are not critical (in the sense that catching cancer fast is critical) but which when delayed cause long periods of deterioration and reduced quality of life.
- iso1631 5y agoDo you have a specific example?