4 ms·
I'm surprised there is no standard for this yet. Just build it into the browser like all other privacy-related requests (location, webcam etc.) are handled. If
by paxys 5y ago
I'm surprised there is no standard for this yet. Just build it into the browser like all other privacy-related requests (location, webcam etc.) are handled. If sites don't implement it, don't accept their cookies. That way I can also manage a blanket yes/no list without getting an obtrusive popup every time.
- Hamuko 5y agoExpecting another smash success like the Do Not Track header.
- atoav 5y agoIf you could sue people for real money when they violate said header it might be taken more seriously pretty quickly.
- Hamuko 5y agoI don't believe that you can sue under the GDPR. I've always understood it to be something that you can lodge a complaint against someone with your local authorities. No idea about the CCPA but I wouldn't be surprised if you could considering how lawsuit-happy Americans are.
- atoav 5y ago> I don't believe that you can sue under the GDPR. I don't believe that either, I just think that flags like these can only be taken seriously if all actors have maximum incentive to take these seriously.
- cm2187 5y agoDo not track is a gentleman's agreement in a world of thugs. But you could block cookies at the browser level if the user clicks No.
- paxys 5y agoDo Not Track didn't work because (1) it was not enforced at the browser level, (2) it had no legal backing and (3) it was not granular enough to be useful. With GDPR, CCPA etc. in place the online privacy landscape is very different, and a new standard is very much possible today. Why did every site in the world implement all the consent popups in the first place when they could have continued to do nothing?
- djxfade 5y agoThe problem is that I can't possible imagine Google implementing this, as it would hurt their data hoarding
- lostcolony 5y agoWhy? The browser has access to it at all times, and you can still ask for it anywhere. So Google (via Chrome) isn't losing anything. In fact, everyone else (including Google via analytics) is probably get more data; make it so that in the same way the browser form fills address and phone number and things automatically based on past fills, have a standard API in the browser to handle that. Now users just have to click "okay" to share all that data, rather than enter it in.
- skohan 5y agoWell seeing as a lot of sites use dark patterns to confuse users into accepting more liberal tracking, I'm not sure I would agree that this would lead to more data collected
- zibzab 5y agoIt may surprise you, but Google was not the villain here: https://www.cnet.com/news/apache-web-software-overrides-ie10-do-not-track-setting/ https://www.cnet.com/news/apache-web-software-overrides-ie10...
- seoaeu 5y agoThe problem is that sites will just pretend that any such standard doesn't actually exist. All of these sites could suppress cookie popups for clients that send a do-not-track header, but choose not to.
- kmeisthax 5y agoThey did. It was called Do-Not-Track and Microsoft had the bright idea to pull an iOS 14 and turn it on by default in IE. At that point the few ad companies that had supported it basically told the browser vendors to pound sand and it became entirely useless for anything but fingerprinting.
- MiddleEndian 5y agoDo not track should have been on by default. But the idea that anyone would ever obey it without the legal force was always a fantasy. If 90% of people checked "do not track" do you think they would have started to follow it? Of course not. They would just have some other reason.
- eli 5y agoEveryone's talking about DNT, but P3P from Microsoft circa 2002 is probably more instructive: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/P3P https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/P3P Privacy is nuanced. It's' really hard to encode all ways you may or may not want your data used into a few boolean questions.
- Hamuko 5y agoOne of my favourite Stack Overflow answers still is making your privacy policy a potato. https://stackoverflow.com/a/16475093 https://stackoverflow.com/a/16475093
- eli 5y agoI definitely spent time in like 2004 trying to understand what to put in the field to make my SSO work in IE until I found out everyone just lied.