4 ms·
IMHO installing apps is definitely one of the top two non-intuitive things about Macs. Not to mention it's not even consistent -- sometimes you drag to Applica
by crazygringo 5y ago
IMHO installing apps is definitely one of the top two non-intuitive things about Macs.
Not to mention it's not even consistent -- sometimes you drag to Applications, sometimes you double-click a .pkg file, sometimes you go to the App Store.
The other thing, of course, being an application open without any windows but a menubar present. Start QuickTime and... nothing happens except for the menubar changing, which is incredibly easy not to notice at all. Even worse, some apps automatically close when closing the last window (e.g. System Preferences) while others don't (most other apps).
The installation one should be easy to Apple to fix -- when you double-click a .dmg, auto-detect if it contains an .app or .pkg, and just automagically expand, mount, copy or run, unmount, delete expanded file and leave just the original .dmg behind (perhaps asking if you want to delete that too). (Also, macOS needs a centralized place for uninstalling apps as well, particularly .pkg ones.)
The menubar one is trickier. But it doesn't seem unreasonable to either expect an application to quit when closing its main window (e.g. Activity Monitor should follow System Preferences in this), or else for document-centric apps, to open a standardized "start" window with options for types of new documents, a list of recent documents, etc. when all document windows are closed (e.g. what TextEdit and QuickTime could do).
- m463 5y agoThe .dmg drag thing has benefits - many times you can run an app from within the .dmg You can also drag into locations that are not /Applications
- crazygringo 5y agoSure, and that can be reserved for power users. You can right-click on applications to open them as folders, and the same could be done with DMG's. 99% of people just want to install or uninstall with a click, which is why I wish Finder made that the default workflow.
- m463 5y agoThe dmg is just one drag. Meanwhile an installer flow seems to be more of a gauntlet you have to get through. For macos it is several mostly standardized pages, for windows it is more annoying, complete with dark patterns.
- crazygringo 5y agoJust one drag? More like unzip, double-click, drag, close, open a Finder window if you're on the desktop, find the mounted volume, click to eject, close window, select DMG and/or ZIP, delete. I think it's having to locate the mounted volume and eject it in order to delete the DMG that is the dumbest part. How a regular user is supposed to even figure that out is a mystery to me. And, I mean, they don't: https://discussions.apple.com/thread/7145087 https://discussions.apple.com/thread/7145087
- ninkendo 5y agoThe package installer now asks you if you want to move the installer to the trash after installation (it's been this way for a few OS releases now). This will eject the .dmg and delete it for you as well. I think it only does this if the .dmg is in the Downloads directory though.