3 ms·
I think algorithmic agility is exactly why TLS 1.0 has remained secure for so long (and, to a point, SSL 3 too). We're already running into compatibility probl
by jeroenhd 5y ago
I think algorithmic agility is exactly why TLS 1.0 has remained secure for so long (and, to a point, SSL 3 too).
We're already running into compatibility problems with IoT devices and server management boards because of HTTPS and that's just with TLS <1.2 being turned off after many years. I don't believe changing the protocol even faster will benefit most applications. The world has barely implemented http/2 and yet we're already on http/3 based on yet another entirely different protocol.
- tptacek 5y agoYou'd think that, but you'd be mostly wrong. Many (most, I think?) TLS vulnerabilities have been fixed not by ciphersuite configuration changes but by upgrades to the entire protocol. The most famous configuration workaround --- BEAST prompting people to go from AES to RC4 --- pushed people into an even more grievously insecure cryptosystem. For the most part, I think negotiable ciphers have been discredited among cryptography engineers. Certainly, it's a design smell in new protocols.