3 ms·
It took over five years to find the reservoir species for SARS, and decades for most viruses. It's not evidence at all because the facts match the expected resu
by sudosysgen 5y ago
It took over five years to find the reservoir species for SARS, and decades for most viruses. It's not evidence at all because the facts match the expected result.
I don't know exactly what information you would want. Every single paper about virology research from the institute was published with western authors. Had there been something wrong in the raw data or safety logs those authors would have said so.
Instead they say that everything is normal.
There is a weird double standard here of ignoring data that goes against this hypothesis and interpreting things that happened for every single other zoonosis in the world to be indicative of a lab escape. Such as, for example, three people out of six hundred presenting with symptoms of seasonal illnesses in the appropriate season.
- kshacker 5y agoJust because something took 5 years last time does not mean it should take the same this time. - Our SOP should be better to analyze the information. - Given the magnitude of the problem, more eyes should be on it - tools and technologies should be better It may still take longer, but all things being equal, we should not justify anything based on the past track record. Your other point is valid though: if 3 people showed up in 1, 2 or 3 hospitals with severe flu, I would not think much of it, no one would.
- sudosysgen 5y agoThe actual process of finding the viral reservoir is to go off into the wild and collect samples. It has not changed since SARS. SARS was a very big deal in China and the Chinese government allocated a lot of resources to research. As far as points one and two, that means no real improvement, as it was already in the diminishing return phase. Because of this I don't actually see why it would be any faster. SARS wasn't the first virus where finding a reservoir was tried, far from it, and the limiting factor in the search for the source is still the same. Because of this I don't expect it should be much easier this time than last time.
- encoderer 5y ago> Had there been something wrong in the raw data or safety logs those authors would have said so. Or, they thought then that the precautions were sufficient and the risks were acceptable, and they were wrong, and now would like to just look ahead and move on.
- kspacewalk2 5y ago>Had there been something wrong in the ... safety logs those authors would have said so. Not sure how you reached that conclusion. Collaborators from different institutions collaborate on research papers all the time while having no access to each others' 'safety logs'. Why would that be shared? >Instead they say that everything is normal. Which they obviously have no way of knowing, given that they are not on site, the research institute is in a secretive authoritarian country, and the implications for being 'responsible' for such a lab leak are monumental for such a regime. >There is a weird double standard here of ignoring data that goes against this hypothesis and interpreting things that happened for every single other zoonosis in the world to be indicative of a lab escape. Such as, for example, three people out of six hundred presenting with symptoms of seasonal illnesses in the appropriate season. The double standard is the exact opposite - flippantly dismissing the lab leak hypothesis without examination, on one side; a call to treat it on par with the purely zoonotic hypothesis and a recognition that neither hypothesis is close to being definitively proven, on the other.
- screye 5y ago> It took over five years to find the reservoir species for SARS You might want to check that. Afaik, it is 4 months . (read comments below, I may or may not be correct. Sars1 has been found in Civets, bats and humans. We do not yet know the order of transmission and if civets were indeed the intermediate source.) It took less than 4 months (feb 2003 -> May 2003) from identifying SARS1 as a novel virus to finding the intermediate animal (civet cats) [1] . It took 10 months to identify that for MERS. (Sept 2012 -> August 2013) Given that we know it originated in Wuhan, have dedicated order of magnitude more funding to it and all the usual suspects have come up as a negative, the lab escape hypothesis does look increasingly more likely. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Severe_acute_respiratory_syndrome#Identification_of_virus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Severe_acute_respiratory_syndr... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Middle_East_respiratory_syndrome%E2%80%93related_coronavirus#Natural_reservoir https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Middle_East_respiratory_syndro...
- lamontcg 5y ago> You might want to check that. Afaik, it is 4 months . You might want to check THAT out. They found other species could be infected with SARS-CoV-1 after 4 months and hypothesized that civet cats were the intermediate species, but that still hasn't been proven yet. After the discovery of SARS-like WIV1 in bats in Yunnan in 2013 it was determined in 2016 that WIV1 or a very closely related virus may have jumped directly to humans: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bat_SARS-like_coronavirus_WIV1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bat_SARS-like_coronavirus_WIV1 And specifically reference 4: https://www.pnas.org/content/113/11/3048 https://www.pnas.org/content/113/11/3048 "Both full-length and chimeric WIV1-CoV readily replicated efficiently in human airway cultures and in vivo, suggesting capability of direct transmission to humans." So we STILL don't quite understand the origin of SARS1 and if it used an intermediate species or not. There's still a very similar mystery as to how the closest animal coronavirus is found in a bat in Yunnan, but it showed up in humans in Guangdong roughly 700 miles away (but since it was in 2003 and there's no biological lab in Guangdong there's no competing lab-leak hypothesis over SARS1, even though the observation is exactly the same).
- screye 5y ago
- suifbwish 5y agoYou are ignoring the vast statistical improbability of the first outbreak occurring at the one wet market that happens to be within 10 miles of the ONLY two coronavirus research labs in mainland China out of THOUSANDS of other wet markets across the country. Correlation is not causation but I think it’s fairly obvious that the chances of that occurring coincidentally in the context are some pretty steep odds.
- raarts 5y agoGreat point.