7 ms·
>openness at the expense of security This is a false dilemma. You can have both.
by 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y ago
>openness at the expense of security
This is a false dilemma. You can have both.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoThis is an opinion, and Apple does not believe this opinion, nor do they have to. Furthermore, I think that if you look at the comparison of malware prevalence on Android and iOS, the claim that you can have security and openness simultaneously does not appear to be true.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agohttps://googleprojectzero.blogspot.com/2020/12/an-ios-zero-click-radio-proximity.html https://googleprojectzero.blogspot.com/2020/12/an-ios-zero-c... https://googleprojectzero.blogspot.com/2019/08/a-very-deep-dive-into-ios-exploit.html https://googleprojectzero.blogspot.com/2019/08/a-very-deep-d... https://www.tomsguide.com/news/police-say-android-phones-are-harder-to-crack-than-iphones https://www.tomsguide.com/news/police-say-android-phones-are...
- haswell 5y agoApple's goals with a highly curated app marketplace and the existence of exploits are orthogonal to each other. Nor is security just about "can the device be exploited or not?". What are you trying to explain with these articles? How does the existence of iOS exploits support your thesis that Security and Openness can co-exist?
- daveidol 5y ago> Apple does not believe this opinion, nor do they have to Hopefully if they lose this case (due to the market reality of being a duopoly) then they will be forced to at least entertain it. Android's way of handling sideloading or multiple app stores is far from the only way to do it. I'm sure Apple could find a better middle ground between what we have now (incredibly locked down, anti-competitive, with arbitrary rules and Mafia-like enforcement of prices) and a total free-for-all.
- macintux 5y agoFrom my cursory and amateur reading of the law, a duopoly is only actionable if the two companies conspire together against consumers’ best interest. Wage fixing aside, and that was years ago, the companies don’t appear to collaborate a lot anymore, much less conspire, other than the payments Google makes to retain its position as the default search engine.
- heavyset_go 5y ago> Furthermore, I think that if you look at the comparison of malware prevalence on Android and iOS iOS exploits are cheaper than Android exploits because iOS exploits are so plentiful[1][2]. [1] https://www.theregister.com/2020/05/14/zerodium_ios_flaws/ https://www.theregister.com/2020/05/14/zerodium_ios_flaws/ [2] http://zerodium.com/program.html http://zerodium.com/program.html
- haswell 5y agoAnd this is an oversimplification. Will you share some thoughts on how you can have both in an ecosystem like Apple’s?
- zepto 5y agoAlthough I totally think open source should attempt to produce an ecosystem with the security of Apple’s ecosystem, there is no evidence that this is even theoretically possible.
- lern_too_spel 5y agoAccording to Gartner and the exploit markets, open source has surpassed iOS's security for a few years now.
- zepto 5y agoYou’re not talking about how end users are protected against installing malicious applications, so at best this is irrelevant.
- lern_too_spel 5y agoAt least half a billion malicious app installs on iOS and none from F-Droid. It does seem like open source wins there too.
- saagarjha 5y agoI would ERB surprised if F-Droid even had half a billion installs total.
- zepto 5y ago> At least half a billion malicious app installs on iOS and none from F-Droid. It does seem like open source wins there too. You must realize that this is a meaningless comparison, since F-droid is barely used and not a target comparable to iOS. I’m quite sure you are aware of the relative sizes of the stores. If that is a mistaken assumption, please say.
- lern_too_spel 5y agoI am well aware of the sizes of the stores. Are you aware that the relative amount of malware is is not merely proportionally less? Are you aware that F-Droid-style reproducible builds are not possible on iOS? People using an iOS device can never be sure they are installing the secure app they wanted to install or some switcheroo. On the other hand, Google's and Amazon's app stores are not open source but built for an open source platform, together have far more users than the Apple App Store and far fewer malware installations. Discovery in the Epic case dug up some documents showing that Apple had no dynamic analysis for App Store apps at all. Google and Amazon both run Android VMs in their datacenters to catch fishy behavior that can't be found via static analysis.
- fauigerzigerk 5y agoI think you're right when it comes to security, but in order for that to work Apple would have to admit that checking apps for security issues is not inseparable from imposing rules that are supposed to benefit their own business model. That said, here's a challenge for everybody (including myself) who doesn't like Apple's app store monopoly and side-loading ban: Apple now requires apps to ask for permission before tracking users. Facebook is _very_ unhappy about that. Imagine what would have happened if alternative app stores were allowed on iOS. How long would it take before a Facebook/Google sponsored app store would emerge that would carry all ad funded apps? How would you prevent this from happening?
- swiley 5y agoThe security comes from the sandbox, Apple's curation is pretty mediocre and they only remove malware once it's popular or if it's extremely obvious during the short review. iOS malware authors tend to publish their binaries as unsigned dylibs and don't need Apple ID accounts so they aren't even banned when they're caught. instead they convince other developers to ship it in seperate apps (there are various ways, money, convenient APIs, both in the case of Facebook.)
- gbanfalvi 5y agoI can guarantee you that the sandbox can be circumvented if you can just run an IPA on the device. iOS has a humongous set of APIs and that attack surface is impossible to protect properly. Don’t get me wrong, I’d love to have an iPhone I can install anything on - but there is _no_ way I would ever install anything from the open internet on the same device use to read my email or log in to my bank.
- swiley 5y agoMost of us don't want to run everything we find on the internet, we want to be able to run one or two apps that Apple doesn't like.
- fouric 5y ago> How would you prevent this from happening? Very simply - enforce security permissions at the OS level, rather than the app store level. There's no technical reason an app store also has to handle permissions. Leave the discoverability/reviews/curation functionality in the app store, and then just move the app installation functionality into the OS - the app store delivers an app package which the OS accepts, parses the manifest file, prompts user for permissions. Put APIs behind a sane, capabilities-like model where the OS has to approve everything. Facebook and Google can make their own app stores - but they still won't be able to spy on you by using privileged APIs without your consent. (yes, they'll still be able to spy on you using data collection and aggregation - but then Apple's App Store privacy labels becomes a differentiating feature that build user trust and add value to the system, and Apple could add a warning when you install another App Store "privacy labels don't transfer, etc.")
- bitwize 5y agoYou can have both, but only if you take responsibility for managing the system, setting policies, making sure that updates are applied, screening for malware, etc. Apple does all that for you. That's why they win. "General purpose computing" is for nerds -- ordinary people would much rather have an iPhone.