7 ms·
Like everything in technology, you have a choice. If you want openness at the expense of security and privacy, you can purchase an Android or Windows device. If
by gjsman-1000 5y ago
Like everything in technology, you have a choice. If you want openness at the expense of security and privacy, you can purchase an Android or Windows device. If you want security and privacy more than openness, you buy an iPhone. The Hacker News crowd is unique in that we want to have our cake and eat it too by making the iPhone work more like Android and expressing outrage that such a choice exists.
So even though I wish iPhone would become more open, I find it strange that people are saying that we must break the iPhones App Store requirement to increase choice, even though that removes the choice to have a safer but locked down experience from the market.
- realusername 5y agoWhat if you got a used phone or tablet though? Are you just supposed to throw it away to the trash and get another one because the manufacturer doesn't approve you using it? And what about devices which aren't supported anymore?
- bombcar 5y agoI think an interesting attack on this loophole would be a law that requires that the relevant signing keys/bootloader access be opened 1-3 years after official support for the hardware ends. Sure this would complicate things a bit (Apple would have to have different keys for different hardware revisions), but it would allow devices to be "officially" jailbroken after support ends.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoLike this, I would really support this. However, Apple would probably point out the Third World countries might have more obsolete devices coupled with more oppressive governments and that puts them at more risk or something.
- realusername 5y agoobsolete devices aren't maintained anymore, the only security you get against known attacks is provided by the community, not from Apple.
- zepto 5y agoI would support opening it as soon as the first unsupported software release is made available.
- rodgerd 5y agoThat would be great in theory, but in practice it's far more straightforward to run an iOS device for many, many years (supported by Apple, no less) than to run a device that ships with Android.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y ago>openness at the expense of security This is a false dilemma. You can have both.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoThis is an opinion, and Apple does not believe this opinion, nor do they have to. Furthermore, I think that if you look at the comparison of malware prevalence on Android and iOS, the claim that you can have security and openness simultaneously does not appear to be true.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agohttps://googleprojectzero.blogspot.com/2020/12/an-ios-zero-click-radio-proximity.html https://googleprojectzero.blogspot.com/2020/12/an-ios-zero-c... https://googleprojectzero.blogspot.com/2019/08/a-very-deep-dive-into-ios-exploit.html https://googleprojectzero.blogspot.com/2019/08/a-very-deep-d... https://www.tomsguide.com/news/police-say-android-phones-are-harder-to-crack-than-iphones https://www.tomsguide.com/news/police-say-android-phones-are...
- haswell 5y agoApple's goals with a highly curated app marketplace and the existence of exploits are orthogonal to each other. Nor is security just about "can the device be exploited or not?". What are you trying to explain with these articles? How does the existence of iOS exploits support your thesis that Security and Openness can co-exist?
- daveidol 5y ago> Apple does not believe this opinion, nor do they have to Hopefully if they lose this case (due to the market reality of being a duopoly) then they will be forced to at least entertain it. Android's way of handling sideloading or multiple app stores is far from the only way to do it. I'm sure Apple could find a better middle ground between what we have now (incredibly locked down, anti-competitive, with arbitrary rules and Mafia-like enforcement of prices) and a total free-for-all.
- headmelted 5y agoPhilosophically I agree with you, but I also have kids, and I’ve seen the wild west that is the Play Store. Admittedly, the same problems exist on the App Store, but not to the same why-even-try level of anything goes. The amount of kids apps, that are marketed as kids apps, certified as age appropriate, then contain ads for zombie gorefest horror was enough to make me give up trying with Android entirely. I have every confidence Google will eventually address this (if they haven’t already in the intervening years). In the meantime while I dislike how restrictive iOS is I’ve begrudgingly come to accept that I need it that way, at least until my kids are older. That said, it's not clear if Apple will win or lose this Epic suit, so who knows what happens after that if they do?
- gjsman-1000 5y agoI’m surprised you think that Apple is going to lose the epic lawsuit, because if you look at any legal commentary (I’m following Hoeg Law’s extensive coverage of the case), the odds of the App Store being broken from this lawsuit or even sideloading being allowed appears to be extremely unlikely.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- smoldesu 5y ago> the odds of the App Store being broken from this lawsuit or even sideloading being allowed appears to be extremely unlikely. From what I've seen, Epic's primary intention is to get Apple to publicly admit the compromises they make to maintain their ecosystem, and then use that to drive a wedge between the court's interpretation of the situation and Apple's defense.
- smoldesu 5y agoThe issue isn't with one platform being more open or closed than the other; if you kids want, they can watch pretty much anything they want. They have YouTube and a browser, how are you going to stop them? I sympathize with your distaste for crude advertising, but every platform has it's fair share of people abusing it. Just a few months ago, developers were coming out en masse to denounce Apple's weak regulation in the app store, filtering obscenities but completely missing predatory pricing structures, ponzi schemes, stolen code and frequent double standards/unequal ruling. The bottom line is that the internet is scary, and your kids are growing up faster than any generation before. The more you try to interfere with stuff like this, the more animosity they'll perceive in your relationship.
- ActorNightly 5y agoI still dont get how people pretend Apple cares about privacy. By default Apple devices phone home and collect data on you, and this is not optional, and they will hand that data to law enforcement. They also have the ability to change their data handling policieson a whim since there is nobody holding them accountable. THIS IS NOT PRIVACY. Not that windows or android devices are better as they come out of the box, but at least any computer that runs windows can run linux where you have full control, and certain android phones can be rooted/unlocked and flashed with custom roms without google or run firewall apps to block outgoing data.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoYou’re in an echo chamber. By default, iPhones do send diagnostic data, but that data can be disabled in Settings. They also upload your files in an encrypted connection (but without end to end encryption) into your iCloud backup, and that can be handed over with a subpoena, but you can disable iCloud backup or simply not pay for it.
- vlunkr 5y agoNothing you said contradicts anything they said. By default, Apple collects all this data.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoRead it closely, the poster said it wasn’t optional.
- ActorNightly 5y agoHe said it can be disabled in settings, which is not true. Anyone can repeat this experiment at home with a laptop and 2 usb to ethernet adaptors.
- ActorNightly 5y agoNope. There is data that it sends that is non optional. Proof: go into settings and disable every tracking options, and then capture traffic from the device through a router with openwrt running tcpdump or wireshark on a computer with a bridge setup with ip forwarding and iptables rule. Did this experiment already twice to prove to people that Apple device do phone home plenty. Then I repeat the same experiment with my rooted android phone running a custom rom, and people watch the sparse wireshark trace with the only packets being sent are dns then ntp to the android ntp server.
- daveidol 5y ago> Like everything in technology, you have a choice. If you want openness [...] you can purchase an Android or Windows device. Windows Phone is dead. And what happens if Android decides to be like Apple and lock down sideloading more? There is nothing forcing them to continue allowing this "freedom of choice" for consumers if they decide it would be better for their bottom line. So, what would be the next best choice after Android in that scenario? Basically nothing, because smartphone operating systems are a duopoly. > So even though I wish iPhone would become more open, I find it strange that people are saying that we must break the iPhones App Store requirement to increase choice, even though that removes the choice to have a safer but locked down experience from the market. I know many people (including Apple) prefer the iPhone ecosystem to be more locked down, but given the market realities (monopoly) it seems like a compromise would make more sense than forcing everyone to pay 30% and lose out on things like cloud gaming, emulation, "objectionable" content, etc. to cater to the lowest common denominator. A few possible compromises that Apple likely will never agree to without being forced to via regulation: - Apple could probably keep the singular App Store model, but lower their fee to closer to cost, add more types of parental controls and/or special "expert only" areas of the store. This way they are more of a neutral hosting platform that still enforces security via app review (frankly, if they had done this to begin with, people probably would have let the whole singular App Store thing slide). - Apple could allow alternate payment processors and let the user decide if they want the convenience of Apple Pay vs alternatives. This would let the market dictate the real value of their IAP infra. (Hell - at least let subscription apps link to their web site to purchase if they don't want to do IAP! This seems highly anti-competitive.) - Apple could allow federated third party app stores to enforce certain levels of spam and security prevention (even off the App Store) - if one of these trusted third party app stores falls short in terms of security they get removed. - Apple could just go the Android route and allow sideloading, but put it behind a ton of warnings etc. Continued investment in app sandboxing and permission prompts for each and every app would already do a lot to cut down on straight-up malware. Phishing, scams, etc. are already an issue for iPhone users in the browser or email clients (plus we've seen these kinds of things on the App Store as well), so user education on how to deal with these things is already unavoidable. I think it's fair for us as consumers to demand more from Apple and want both security and freedom with reasonable tradeoffs.
- anoncake 5y agoI don't think anyone would mind if Apple offered two -- otherwise identical -- versions of each Iphone: One locked down and one not. Or Iphones could be unlocked by default but you can pay extra to have them permanently locked. People would pay for that if locking down their phones actually provides value to them.
- myrandomcomment 5y agoWhy would they? It is more work. It is 2 code paths to write, to test and plan for. There is a cost associated with this that will not likely be recovered in any reasonable price difference on the phone versions.
- bpye 5y agoI would be surprised if Apple don’t already have something like this internally…
- saagarjha 5y agoThey do.
- myrandomcomment 5y agoI do not think that Apple is maintaining a full GA level release cycle testing and release planning for a version of IOS that can allow 3rd party apps. The key here is the RELEASE TO GA. Of course they have internal builds that are signed and allow you to do whatever they want internally, but having a shipping GA with the normal protects and support for all the work and validations that would go into supporting 3rd party installations. Your resume says you where an Intern at Apple, so I am sure you are correct in the fact that they have an unlocked internal build, however my points are valid about the difference between that and a GA PRODUCTION release. Note, Apple has some pretty strict NDAs so...
- saagarjha 5y ago
- temac 5y agoI don't understand why anybody would consider to be at risk if an alternate store, that nobody would be forced to use, and which could even be subject to identical or even better rules, exists. And I'm not even talking about transforming an iPhone into a potentially open computer, but here too the same principle can be applied: if it is optional, it is something more, not less. The UX can be made good enough to actually have your cake and eat it, see Chromebooks.
- massysett 5y agoOptions drive up support costs for Apple and for carriers, with no corresponding benefit for people who were uninterested in these options.
- Vvector 5y agoAn alternate app store would be a risk for tricking people to download and install all kinds of malware. "Your iPhone is out of date. Tap here to install the latest security tools to stop hackers from stealing your bank account"
- oceanplexian 5y agoWho is to say an alternative App Store wouldn’t have better security than the Apple App Store? Lots of things with terrible privacy and security practices have made it past the mostly automated review process. With a 3rd party paid App Store, you could pay a subscription to ensure that every app is reviewed by a human, doesn’t violate privacy, and is free of malware.
- Gaelan 5y agoRight, but the scammers aren't going to tell you to go there to install your Important Software Update, they're gonna point you towards the store with no restrictions at all, possibly one they run.
- PandawanFr 5y agoThe issue is other factors may force you to use an alternate store. My college uses Proctorio for online test-taking. I am required to use this for the class. The issue is, the extension is only available for Chrome (I've tried other Chromium browsers and those don't seem to work as well). As a Firefox user, I don't really like having to switch to Chrome just to use an app that I never wanted to use but am forced to. The same could apply with app stores—if a company, school, or other requires that you use an app that is only available on a less privacy-friendly or perhaps more intrusive app store, that doesn't sound like an optional/risk-free alternative to me. Once you open the walls there's no going back.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]