3 ms·
In the smaller ones, the planar transformer takes up most of the board area, so there's no benefit to assembling two different PCBs. The larger DC-DC converter
by tomn 5y ago
In the smaller ones, the planar transformer takes up most of the board area, so there's no benefit to assembling two different PCBs.
The larger DC-DC converters are not as cost sensitive as a raspberry pi product; they tend to be used in low volume industrial/scientific/medical devices and might cost £70 each. When you consider that they are also mostly inductor by area, and factor in the additional complexity of manufacturing a multiple-pcb assembly, it's also not worth it.
IIRC there are also some larger PCBs in that video; for those it's possible that they already had enough layers for routing signals that it was easy to integrate the transformer core directly.
Another factor I haven't seen mentioned is the manufacturing complexity. It looks like the transformer could be placed by a normal pick and place machine, while assembling a transformer around a PCB would be more of a specialised or manual process. I suspect that might be the real reason, as the transformer PCB doesn't look like it has that many layers.