4 ms·
Are you arguing that arranging to commit a crime is protected speech? I don't think that one will fly anywhere, even in the US, let alone in the UK with no cons
by pjc50 6y ago
Are you arguing that arranging to commit a crime is protected speech? I don't think that one will fly anywhere, even in the US, let alone in the UK with no constitutional protection only the much weaker ECHR one.
- tux1968 6y agoRead the second sentence of my post.
- SyzygistSix 6y agoThat's pretty much every protest ever. You would make organizing protests against marijuana laws or laws against homosexual behavior illegal? Moxie Marlinspike has argued that it is important to be able to break the law and that perfect surveillance means the end of making social progress in a civil manner. https://www.metafilter.com/161351/I-think-it-should-actually-be-possible-to-break-the-law https://www.metafilter.com/161351/I-think-it-should-actually...
- ben_w 5y agoAs the law recognises that the law can be changed, protesting to change the law is not generally itself a crime. Laws get interpreted by humans, not by computers, so they should not to be taken literally and in isolation — they’re both harder and laxer in different ways.
- WindyLakeReturn 5y agoIn some cases changing the law is itself illegal, which brings us back to the original question. There is also the matter of protecting a persons right to commit a crime when it involves behaviors that should not be criminalized. A same sex couple being in a relationship is something that we should protest for, even if it is illegal. Not just making it legal, but also protesting specific examples of it being criminalized. Is free speech itself something worth protecting enough that we should give it some level of special protection? In a world where the only person who doesn't have to know the law is the cops enforcing it, who are given their own special protection from harm they cause, I don't think it is an unreasonable request.
- M2Ys4U 5y ago>let alone in the UK with no constitutional protection only the much weaker ECHR one. I think that's overstating the situation a little. The Human Rights Act (which enabled domestic courts to give effect to the ECHR) is considered to be as much of a constitutional document as one can be in the UK. Laws can't accidentally go against Convention rights. Secondary legislation can be struck down if it breaches the HRA/ECHR, and even primary legislation (Acts of Parliament etc.) isn't completely immune. Primary legislation must be interpreted by courts to be compatible with the ECHR, even going as far as to reverse the plain meaning of statutory language in some cases. It's only where there's an express contradiction or one that can't be "interpreted around" where the court has to apply the statute as-is.
- pjc50 5y ago> The Human Rights Act (which enabled domestic courts to give effect to the ECHR) is considered to be as much of a constitutional document as one can be in the UK. Yes - that is, it can be overruled by a simple majority of MPs plus the unelected House of Lords. So constitutional change can be achieved with the support of only a minority of voters.