4 ms·
I have an older relative who thought I was crazy to go to law school straight out of college. She thought that instead I should work, save money, and then when
by gnicholas 5y ago
I have an older relative who thought I was crazy to go to law school straight out of college. She thought that instead I should work, save money, and then when I had enough money use it to pay for law school.
But the math doesn't work at all. I could have saved maybe $10k/yr at the absolute maximum, and law school cost $120k for 3 years at that time (now it's around $200k). If I had followed her plan, I never would have actually enrolled.
I remember thinking my relative was foolish for suggesting that I was taking too big a risk by financing law school with loans. But when the financial crisis hit one year after I graduated, I realized that her advice was not all bad.
I ended up weathering the recession fine, but if I had graduated one year later I would have been in a much tougher position.
TLDR: leverage can be great — assuming everything goes well.
- spoonjim 5y agoBut really what were the possibilities? If you were unemployed with no assets and no savings the debt collectors wouldn’t really get anything from you. And once you got back on your feet you’d start making payments. I don’t think there’s that much difference between making $12/hr and making $12/hr with $200k debt that you make no effort to pay off.
- gnicholas 5y agoI'm not sure I understand what you're asking. Student loan debt is not dischargeable in bankruptcy, so it would be terrible to take out $120k in debt on the assumption that a job paying $160k/yr would be waiting for you. Also, where does the $12/hr figure come from? edit: thanks for the downvote, but could someone explain what I'm missing? I literally stared at it for five minutes trying to understand it.
- crooked-v 5y agoThe point you're missing is that for someone who graduates with heavy debt during a recession period where they can only get a low-paying job (say, $12/hr) or no job at all, debt collection is entirely irrelevant because they don't have anything to collect in the first place.
- the_only_law 5y agoI'm in the process of returning to school here soon, and I expected it to be expensive, but man I underestimated it. Luckily I'm already a software developer (though I don't make anything most people here would consider a good salary), so I can do the first couple years at a community college out of pocket an maybe put aside some for later, but its almost guaranteed that the last two years will require some amount of loans, since I'll have to quit working. I'll swallow it because I don't believe it will be too bad, and most decent employers have some form of tuition reimbursement.
- gnicholas 5y agoI'd be curious to know what field you're in that most decent employers offer tuition reimbursement. I've mostly heard of this in the context of existing employees, whom companies will reimburse if they go get a degree (and stay with the company afterward). Do companies do this for new hires as well?
- jsjohnst 5y agoLarger tech companies generally offer this perk to new hires, sometimes after a probationary period. It’s not Ivy League tuition level, but enough to get by at a local school generally.
- DavidPeiffer 5y agoWith the insane cost of college - it's healthy to express concern for someone you're close with. Some of the people in the worst financial positions got part way through school and had to stop for some reason. They took on a good part of the debt without getting the higher salary they sought. And to top it all off, the debt is not dischargable in bankruptcy with very few, quite extreme exceptions. Taking the advice of Clark Howard, another personal finance radio personality, your student loans shouldn't exceed your first year's salary. This feels like a pretty good rule of thumb overall. That would keep the payments manageable and you would still have room in a budget for other goals, even when paying the loans down faster than minimum payments. And for the higher income range, The White Coat Investor doesn't give a rule of thumb, but emphasizes that everyone should buckle down, live like a resident, and pay off all their loans with 5 years of finishing their training.
- gnicholas 5y ago> The White Coat Investor doesn't give a rule of thumb, but emphasizes that everyone should buckle down, live like a resident, and pay off all their loans with 5 years of finishing their training. Living like a law student while working as a young lawyer helped me keep the golden handcuffs at bay and build a nest egg so I could leave and start a startup when the opportunity presented itself.