2 ms·
I think the point the author is making is that none of these systems are a distributed panacea free from corporate overlords. All of them are either dying/obscu
by bawolff 5y ago
I think the point the author is making is that none of these systems are a distributed panacea free from corporate overlords. All of them are either dying/obscure (irc, matrix, rss) or have been infested with powerful actors who have become de-facto centralized nodes (email, WWW, RSS, git). I'm not sure how that relates with the authors stated thesis of profit motives being misaligned. I guess they're arguing that for a system to be succesful it needs corporate investment, people make money out of controlling a centralized node, you cant make money out of the anarchism of a true decentralized system, hence decentralized systems will either fail or be subverted by centralized actors (maybe im reading in my own beliefs?).
Which may be true, but i didn't find the evidence presented particularly compelling, and the structure of the argument was confusing.