3 ms·
> noting is the intrinsic incoherency of the "left-right" divide. Gabbard is an economic populist who makes calculated appeals to the white working class. She's
by rayiner 6y ago
> noting is the intrinsic incoherency of the "left-right" divide. Gabbard is an economic populist who makes calculated appeals to the white working class. She's a purer incarnation of what Trump represented in 2016, and nobody felt Trump was to the left of even Hillary Clinton.
Trump didn’t support universal healthcare, have an F rating from the NRA, etc.
> What gives away the game is that you only hear spirited defenses of Gabbard from right-libertarians. Gabbard is herself a marginal political figure and the fact that we discuss her at all is itself an indication that something is wrong.
I don’t know anything about “right libertarians.” I was curious about Gabbard because she was the only one besides Klobuchar who sounded like she wasn’t reading from some memo everyone got. I also have no idea why the Democratic Party functionaries hate her so much.
The occasional heterodox take she has, “we shouldn’t be racist against white people” or “maybe safe, legal, and rare was a good position,” are not controversial.
- tptacek 6y agoTulsi Gabbard ran in 2019 in part on rapprochement with the NRA, so that's not a great example. Trump ran against Cruz in 2016 on universal health care, and was attacked relentlessly by the GOP field for it. See what I mean? I think Gabbard is horrible but I'm not interested in selling you on that. Rather, I'd just like to point out that she's a complicated figure, and not a good left-right benchmark.
- rayiner 5y ago> Tulsi Gabbard ran in 2019 in part on rapprochement with the NRA, so that's not a great example. Trump ran against Cruz in 2016 on universal health care, and was attacked relentlessly by the GOP field for it. See what I mean? I really don’t. In the House Kirsten Gillibrand had a 100% rating from the NRA. Gabbard merely said she’d talk to the NRA President, analogizing him to the Syrian dictator! She didn’t sign the assault weapons ban in 2018, which was a smart move if she was running for President. Being a left wing pro-gun Democrat was a thing like five minutes ago. Sanders, Dean, etc. Has the party moved that far left? > I think Gabbard is horrible but I'm not interested in selling you on that. It’s not that I’m not sold, it’s that I don’t even understand the argument.
- tptacek 5y agoI think it's not important, especially not on HN, that you understand my dislike of Tulsi Gabbard. Another way to come at this is that Gabbard is loathed by people in every faction of the Democratic coalition; the leftists don't like her, the centrists like me don't like her, the Black voters don't like her, certainly the LGBT activists aren't having anything to do with her. She's a gadfly, she has no constituency, and, as I said upthread, she's obviously used by opponents of the coalition as a cudgel.
- pen2l 5y agoI think tptacek's / geofft's point is that using Tulsi as a representation of the far-left is a questionable choice. And I think I agree with him: While the points you raise about NRA ratings are true, the perception on the ground is far from that. She is reviled by most blue outlets and cast as "one of the good ones" from the red ones (searching for "tulsi" on brietbart, nearly all results are painting her in a positive light: https://www.breitbart.com/search/?s=tulsi#gsc.tab=0&gsc.q=tulsi&gsc.page=1 https://www.breitbart.com/search/?s=tulsi#gsc.tab=0&gsc.q=tu... and conversely on HP, most results are painting her in a negative light: https://www.huffpost.com/news/topic/tulsi-gabbard https://www.huffpost.com/news/topic/tulsi-gabbard ). You know, if you want to have your finger on the pulse of the "real voters" out there (and I'm not being facetious here!), you should visit freerepublic once in a while as well as r/politics, just to see the tenor and positions of folks on opposing sides of political spectrum up-close.
- rayiner 5y agoI didn’t say she was “far left.” I said she’s “solidly left wing.” Which based in her positions she is. The fact that Democrats in the media don’t like her doesn’t mean a thing. They’re the reason nearly every major 2020 candidate raised their hand to wildly unpopular ideas like decriminalizing illegal border crossing and universal healthcare for illegal immigrants. Catering to them destroyed the candidacy of Elizabeth Warren: https://nymag.com/intelligencer/article/elizabeth-warren-book-persist-campaign-memoir-2020.html https://nymag.com/intelligencer/article/elizabeth-warren-boo.... They’re the reason why Democrats nearly lost 2020 until voters of color saved their butts by making Biden the candidate (which the Warren supporters in the media had written off totally). The fact that folks on the right like her also proves nothing. That’s just the opposite side of nearly every 2020 Democratic candidate marching in lockstep to extreme positions. Gabbard gets attention from the right because the entire lineup (besides Biden) is “celebrate your abortion” while Gabbard was like “hey, a third of Democrats identify as pro life, so let’s stick with safe legal and rare.” (https://www.vice.com/en/article/43k5db/tulsi-gabbards-stance-on-abortion-is-stuck-in-the-90s https://www.vice.com/en/article/43k5db/tulsi-gabbards-stance...) People on /r/politics and other “very online people are not “real voters.” Those are the people who thought Elizabeth Warren was a viable candidate. The real voters are people like my parents who tuned in on Super Tuesday to propel Biden to the nomination.