6 ms·
What makes this really complex for the EU is that they have tried to punish Poland for this and other various things, but a sanction requires the agreement of a
by gjsman-1000 5y ago
What makes this really complex for the EU is that they have tried to punish Poland for this and other various things, but a sanction requires the agreement of all member states, and a certain state named Hungary has an implicit agreement with Poland to never vote in agreement with the EU, and Poland the same for Hungary.
As a result, the EU tries to sanction Poland, but Hungary won't agree and so the sanction fails. Try to sanction Hungary? Poland is out, sanction fails. I have to admit that it's clever on Poland and Hungary's part, as it lets them selectively ignore some of the EU's more (from their perspective) overbearing rulings.
- loceng 5y agoSounds like they need to update the law somehow to prevent this. I can't quite figure out the starting logic for this though.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoBut to update the law (because this sanctioning mechanism is so deep in EU law), you would need agreement from all member states. You can see where this is going... The EU won't try it because Hungary and Poland would obviously vote against it. And the cycle continues. The current EU plan is to hope that Hungary or Poland's governments get replaced with one that won't support the other, and then consider doing the sanctions. The other EU plan is to pursue other punishments that don't require a full sanction and basically cause as much hurt as possible even if they can't do the ideal remedy.
- pilsetnieks 5y agoThey already tried to do a runaround when Poland and Hungary threatened to veto a Covid recovery fund - basically, just set it up anyway for the rest of the 25 as a side deal that wouldn't involve the two and they wouldn't get any funds. In the end Poland and Hungary acquiesced, yet in a petty dictatorial fashion claimed they had won by forcing the EU to include them.
- axiosgunnar 5y agoLet‘s not use the word „dictatorial“ in an extremely inflationary way. You can call it a government PR spin if you want, but I think no country in the EU is anywhere close to anything like North Korea or even Belarus.
- pilsetnieks 5y agoIf anything, it's "dictatorial" in the Sacha Baron Cohen "The Dictator" sense: "Victory! We won! We forced them to include us ...by acquiescing to their demands."
- axiosgunnar 5y agoI see, so somethink akin to newspeak: War is peace, losing is winning!
- loceng 5y agoThanks to those who downvoted showing the continued idiocy or lack of many people on HN who can't see the value that a simple comment can have even on triggering replies; and reaffirming why downvotes are stupid and lazy.
- axiosgunnar 5y agoI think it‘s the system working as intended. The EU is an international organization whose members are fully sovereign states. Unless you want the EU to be a super state that can bully it‘s members with a mere 51% of the vote? The EU would fall apart then.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoI actually agree. The EU really doesn't like the politics of Hungary and Poland (which can be understood), but the system is working as intended.
- vkou 5y agoWhat some call working as intended, others look on, and say 'broken by design'. What's even the point of issuing rulings that can be ignored by the collusion of two out of 27 members?
- axiosgunnar 5y agoIt‘s very simple. The EU was originally a market union, which every member state profited from. For some reason, the EU has been adopting more and more powers completely unrelated to international trade, and it shows because you will never get 27 different nations to agree on controversial issues.
- vkou 5y agoGenerally these sorts of organizational problems are resolved by having different thresholds of consensus required for adopting different kinds of policies. Majority, super-majority... Consensus minus one, on the other hand, is another way of saying 'Impossible'.
- will4274 5y ago> Consensus minus one, on the other hand, is another way of saying 'Impossible'. No it isn't. Some 30% of decisions are made unanimously in scotus, and this is hardly an outlier. Requiring unanimous consent makes things way slower, yes, but it doesn't prevent them. Not all organizational changes need to be controversial. Several conservative programming languages did well by requiring unanimity in initial years - only adding what all could agree was good. It only requires those members to exercise good judgement.