4 ms·
AWS pricing is extremely thorough and not at all comparable with Apple's App Store: - AWS charge you on bandwidth used, Apple don't charge developers for the n
by hnlmorg 5y ago
AWS pricing is extremely thorough and not at all comparable with Apple's App Store:
- AWS charge you on bandwidth used, Apple don't charge developers for the number of downloads
- AWS charge you on compute time, Apple don't charge you for ongoing use of their services beyond one initial charge for app submission
- AWS charge you for storage, Apple don't charge you for storing your app
I'm not a fan of Apple's App Store terms any more than the next person, but the GP's comparison to eBay is a hell of a lot more apt than your comparison with AWS.
- lukeramsden 5y ago> - AWS charge you on compute time, Apple don't charge you for ongoing use of their services beyond one initial charge for app submission Yes they do, the fee is yearly, and they make billions in revenue from this. Google charge one-time.
- thayne 5y agoNot to mention that you have to purchase expensive apple hardware to develop for iOS.
- wincy 5y agoI saw the new Mac Mini on sale at Costco for $600 yesterday, I don’t see how Apple hardware can be called “expensive” anymore.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- slenk 5y agoDon't you still need to buy a monitor and all peripherals?
- fshbbdssbbgdd 5y agoThose don’t need to be apple products - the mini has standard ports.
- wincy 5y agoI mean you also need to buy a monitor and peripherals for a PC. Since they’re not built in you could find a 1080p monitor on Facebook marketplace locally for almost nothing. If you’re just doing iOS development the Mac mini should be fine.
- slenk 5y agoDoing iOS development includes a whole other bundle of costs associated with it. $1000/yr if you want to even try to sell on the app store?
- GSimon 5y agoThe new M1 Mac Mini might literally be the first 'affordable' Apple machine that isn't underpowered. Will need to cough up some $ for display adaptors if you want more than one monitor for development though.
- TaylorAlexander 5y ago$600 is a lot for a small dev who already has a computer. What if they’re a windows gamer and they’re happy with their old desktop? $600 is a lot to many people if it’s not strictly necessary.
- Xevi 5y agoI don't know why you're getting downvoted, you're right. Besides, the cheapest Mac Mini M1 is $1000 in my country. Not everyone can afford that.
- Google234 5y agoApple is not obligated to make tools for every platform...
- thayne 5y agoApple does more than just not make tools for other platforms though. They make it impossible for anyone else to make tools on other platforms that can deploy to the App store. And after a certain scale, it isn't even the development machines that are the problem, it's your CI/CD pipeline.
- robertlagrant 5y agoBillions in revenue on $99/year? Is 1% of the planet a paid up iOS developer?
- gigel82 5y agoMath much? 20 million (that's 3-year old numbers [1]) apple developers. Probably a lot of them on the $299 enterprise plan, but let's assume they're all using the $99 one. 20mil * $100 = $2 billions. QED [1] https://techcrunch.com/2018/06/04/app-store-hits-20m-registered-developers-at-100b-in-revenues-500m-visitors-per-week/ https://techcrunch.com/2018/06/04/app-store-hits-20m-registe...
- altncatchfire 5y agoTo be fair, the 1% isn't off either. The figure available was "billions". For ease of calculation, say it was 7b. That means if each developer pays $100 and total revenue was 7b, 1% of the world must be a developer. (1% of 7b * $100 = $7b) Also, by your own figure, 20 million is already ~0.25% of the world population.
- tmp231 5y agoWho cares how much they make? If you’re unhappy, go to Google or petition Microsoft or Amazon to get back in the game. I’d also like a provider that allows other app stores and has high quality like Apple — one of those companies should do it. But it’s ridiculous to force apple to do it when you could go elsewhere.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kriops 5y agoSo they are making billions -while- creating an effective incentive against spam on their platform? That must the most obvious case of profits well deserved in the history of modern LTDs, good for Apple and their shareholders!
- mschild 5y agoApple's App Store has plenty of scummy apps. A yearly 100 fee isn't going to stop that from happening. https://9to5mac.com/2021/02/11/app-store-scam-apps-how-to-spot/ https://9to5mac.com/2021/02/11/app-store-scam-apps-how-to-sp...
- Closi 5y ago> - AWS charge you on bandwidth used, Apple don't charge developers for the number of downloads Their point is that Apple could charge based on bandwidth used, and that this could be more fair for some developers. > AWS charge you for storage, Apple don't charge you for storing your app I would be pretty happy with Apple charging for app storage if it was at S3 rates - it would amount to almost nothing.
- azinman2 5y agoS3 is actually quite pricey. Not as much on the monthly storage (tho it can be depending on size), but network egress is really where they get you. On the scale of the App Store where the app might be 100mb but it gets downloaded potentially millions of times it gets expensive fast. Now imagine your app is free. Yet you have to pay for all these downloads. There wouldn’t be any free apps anymore.
- Closi 5y agoAt $0.05 per gb transfer, it would be half a penny per 100mb app download. Someone has to pay for that - at the moment Apple subsidises the free apps, presumably because they think they are good for the ecosystem. Although lets be honest here, free apps could easily continue to be subsidised by Apple in any future model. We are talking about far less than a dollar per iPhone in terms of hosting/bandwidth costs for all the apps, so this really is something that Apple could easily just swallow. Let's not forget that the availability, quality and abundance of apps, made by developers, is a key driver of success of the iPhone, and Apple makes plenty money from hardware sales. I won't lose sleep over the thought that they might have to pay for some hosting.
- majewsky 5y ago> $0.05 per gb transfer That's including AWS's insane profit margin, though. I have my cloud deployments with Hetzner, where extra traffic costs € 1.19 per TiB, so that 100 MiB app download would not be half cent, it would be 1/100th of a cent. (And that's before we consider that Hetzner gives 20 TiB per month free traffic with every VM.)
- amaBasics 5y agoThe point is that while Apple doesn’t charge like that, they could.
- hnlmorg 5y ago"Could" is doing a lot of heavy lifting there. My point is AWS and Apple's App Store are very different business models. Once is about providing compute resource while the other is about providing a single pane of glass for software purchases. Sure, the App Store "could" follow AWS's pricing model, but it makes more sense for it not to given the App Store is more analogous to a shop like eBay or even a physical store like Argos than it is a cloud computing data centre. This is why I said the AWS/App Store comparison isn't apt.