9 ms·
>The USA, in my opinion, should show leadership and step in to make it clear that such affront against democracy The US is rarely interested in affronts agains
by pydry 5y ago
>The USA, in my opinion, should show leadership and step in to make it clear that such affront against democracy
The US is rarely interested in affronts against democracy unless there's a geopolitical advantage to be had by leveraging it.
From a practical standpoint, US interventions almost always make things worse for the people who live there, and in a lot of cases less democratic.
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoThe US only intervenes if a rich American has a profit motive that benefits them. Standing up for the Bosnians was the last rare instance where this wasn't the case. Selling bombs to both sides to maintain perpetual conflict is the usual favorite play.
- dnautics 5y agoThe US intervenes in plenty of places where there is no profit motive outside of the standard military industrial complex. I think, for example, it's hard to argue that there was a profit motive in somalia, or bombing that pharmaceuticals factory in the sudan, going back further and getting out of africa, Grenada, e.g. Not that these interventions weren't stupid for other reasons.
- pydry 5y agoNot sure about Sudan but Somalia is a key shipping chokepoint. There very much is a profit motive there.
- sthnblllII 5y agoThen why did piracy spike after the US intervention?
- pydry 5y agoI didn't say it was a success. The US is no stranger to strategic military intervention that costs lives and money and achieves nothing very substantial - from Vietnam to Iraq to Afghanistan.
- dnautics 5y agoSpeaking of which - what was the profit motive in Vietnam? There was definitely geopolitical motive, but I can't imagine there was a "rich American" person or corporation calling the shots for themselves in indochina
- type0 5y agoWhat are you talking about, the military industrial complex made an insane amounts of money from that war.
- dnautics 5y ago> The US intervenes in plenty of places where there is no profit motive outside of the standard military industrial complex. It was the cold war. I'm pretty sure the MIC could have justified so much spending in other ways besides vietnam, but we are venturing into counterfactual territory.
- krono 5y ago"It is possible to commit no mistakes and still lose" - Captain Picard
- sthnblllII 5y agoThats not what happened. There was no piracy problem. Then the US toppled the government. Then there was a piracy problem. The US didnt intervene to stop a problem that didnt exist. I was responding to the claim that destabilizing the Somali government in 1993 was profitable to wealth Americans because shipping lanes are near Somalia. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piracy_off_the_coast_of_Somalia https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piracy_off_the_coast_of_Soma... >After the collapse of the Somali government and the dispersal of the Somali Navy, ... groups, using small boats, would sometimes hold vessels and crew for ransom. This grew into a lucrative trade, with large ransom payments. The pirates then began hijacking commercial vessels
- krono 5y agoThanks for the insight, I really wasn't aware of the extent of their actions. The quote I posted is a bit cryptic by itself. What I meant by it was that perhaps the US had plans that would lead to greater benefits for them in the region, but these plans backfired by inadvertently creating the Somali piracy problem. They did everything right with regards to whatever they were hoping to achieve, but they still failed and then pirates happened.
- dnautics 5y agoGeographically. Somaliland might be, but that's a de facto independent region only marginally connected to Mogadishu, where the intervention was.
- pacija 5y agoRight, US stood up for Bosnians for the goodness of their hearts, not to weaken Serbs, historically Russian allies, and to signal Turkey and middle eastern oil holders "we support your foothold in Europe".
- outside1234 5y agoProbably, but it was also the right thing to do. And it was also clear nobody in Europe cared or was going to do anything, even if it was also in their craven interest. Probably didn't align with their August vacation schedule plans or something.
- pydry 5y agoThey were a little more hesitant to engage in airstrikes because they knew that Serbia would step up the ethnic cleansing if they did. & they did. The US was more concerned with there being instability in Europe than any overriding moral concerns.
- pacija 5y ago300,000 of Serbs forced out of Croatia in period from 1991 to 1995. Where were US bombs to prevent that particular ethnic cleansing?
- throwaway21_ 5y agoUS bombs landed on Croatian Serbs on multiple occasions thus enabling ethnic cleansing. But no biggie, what's small ethnic cleansing between NATO friends?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dnautics 5y ago> and in a lot of cases less democratic Almost all. I can really think of two counterexamples, Japan and Korea (and it took a very long time ~30 years? for korea to figure itself out). Maybe Jugoslavia can be put into that bin too, though it's not clear if the US intervention hurt or helped.
- froh 5y agoyou can add Germany to the list, albeit France and UK also had a say there
- mdiesel 5y agoSetting up the Weimar Republic after WW1 didn't go so well, then the aftermath of WW2 there were decades of east+west Germany. I don't see that as a positive example of a foreign power setting up a government.
- scythe 5y agoI have to preface this with a very emphatic the ends absolutely do not justify the means, but, defying ill repute and near-unanimous pessimism, Iraq seems to have been able to slowly stitch its parliamentary system back together and respond to democratic pressures (protests, elections) without resorting to fraud and violence. It's too early to celebrate, but things look a lot better than they did ten years ago.
- Jeff_Brown 5y ago> The US is rarely interested in affronts against democracy A Mig fighter jet was dispatched to shepherd the airliner. This represents a threat to anyone on a flight through or maybe even near Belarus's airspace.
- ethbr0 5y agoKuwait 1990 Haiti 1994 Bosnia and Herzegovina 1995 Kosovo 1999 Colombia 2000+ Afghanistan 2001 Libya 2011 Iraq 2014 There have been a lot of catastrophic $&@$ ups and terrible ideas, but it's selective history to claim there have been no positive outcomes for the people who live there.
- hervature 5y agoSmall nitpick, the country is Colombia, the university is Columbia.
- ethbr0 5y agoThanks! Not enough coffee. Corrected!
- pydry 5y agoIraq? A million people died as a result of the Iraqi intervention.
- ethbr0 5y ago2014 was preventing the Iraqi government collapse to ISIL https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_in_Iraq_(2013%E2%80%932017) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_in_Iraq_(2013%E2%80%9320... IMHO, it seems like most Iraqis are better off living under a government than IS, but your opinion may differ.
- whydoibother 5y agoISIL existed/exists directly due to America’s waging of war on Iraq. It’s disingenuous to list that there.
- emn13 5y agoJust because a previous intervention was ill advised does not mean a later one was; quite the opposite; you could even consider it taking responsibility for damage caused. It's clearly not disingenuous to include the 2014 intervention in the list of the more reasonable ones. I mean, if you present it as somehow excusing the earlier mistake; that'd be a different issue.
- irrational 5y agoAre there any cases when the USA has increased democracy in the world on a lasting basis? Even within the country we see the current Republicans trying to smother democracy by denying voting rights to citizens and inciting an insurrection.
- tomohawk 5y agoThat sure didn't take long.
- katbyte 5y agoIs that comment inaccurate?
- newthreefifths 5y agoThe GOP just wants people to show ID when they vote. If it's so easy to get vaccinated that anyone can do it and we should expect people to show vaccine cards to travel or go about their regular lives, people like you need to stop acting like minorities aren't smart enough to figure out how to get an ID to provide in order to vote The Democrats want illegals to count in the census to boost their own voting power in places like California. They count for representation but can't vote. Remind you of any past compromises? Democrats always liked getting to vote on behalf of disenfranchised minorities in their state. You need to consume news from some organization that isn't a tabloid. These organizations are tabloids: MSNBC, CNN, The New York Times, The Washington Post, Vice, Vox, Slate, The Huffington Post
- devoutsalsa 5y agoThe GOP wants to check IDs because their voters are more likely to have ID. That’s the only reason. It’s not some noble effort to protect the sanctity of our elections. Illegal immigrants don’t vote.
- faichai 5y agoSouth Korea and Taiwan perhaps?
- dillondoyle 5y agoPutin's ambitions seem like a geopolitical risk. Maybe on both sides; it seems Autocrats right now like a good 'buffer' - e.g. North Korea. Plus a new forming 'axis' vs 'democracy' power struggle Hard to argue with the second when looking at the past 2 decades, but looking broader in the past century I think there are many more arguments the other way. Most of Europe for one.
- throwaway894345 5y ago> The US is rarely interested in affronts against democracy unless there's a geopolitical advantage to be had by leveraging it. Who are the countries who are willing to intercede militarily purely to liberate a country? > From a practical standpoint, US interventions almost always make things worse for the people who live there, and in a lot of cases less democratic. I think this is a fair criticism—intercession is hard—but the question isn’t whether things are better or worse than they were, but rather whether they were better or worse than they would have been under Soviet influence. And you can analyze this as “whether or not a specific country is better or worse” as well as “whether or not the world is better or worse for the diminished soviet influence that would have been afforded by that country falling under Soviet influence”.
- katbyte 5y agopretty sure the issues that belarus has is more to do with its dictator lukashenko then "soviet influence": https://www.iheart.com/podcast/105-behind-the-bastards-29236323/episode/part-one-alexander-lukashenko-the-dictator-70346499/ https://www.iheart.com/podcast/105-behind-the-bastards-29236...
- lmilcin 5y agoMost likely, yes. But consider none of this would be happening without Russian backing.
- baybal2 5y agoSoviet influence it is. Lukasenko was a party boss in USSR Putin was KGB mafia boy. Kravcuk, and Kucma were party bosses of state enterprises. Aliyevs were KGB men Shevardnaze was USSR's foreign minister The whole of Central Asia is basically ruled by exactly the same Moscow's satraps since late eighties, with exception of wild tempered Kyrgyzstan. Mongolia, "the 16th republic," also had communist comeback, only ended by an extreme, Norko style economic collapse. The only country of ex-USSR where CPSU did not recapture the power outside of Baltics was Armenia, but only thanks to power going to their nazis. A medicine worse than the poison.