4 ms·
Total isolation would be a start.
by snvzz 5y ago
Total isolation would be a start.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoI would agree, but the problem is that such sanctions hurt the population the most. This is not a good choice in dictatorships as the population has no choice who to vote for. The regime top clique will keep eating well off smuggled imports, while the general population will starve.
- snvzz 5y ago>but the problem is that such sanctions hurt the population the most. This sort of coexistence has been attempted and patently failed. It's their population, not ours. An important distinction. We (rest of the world, but particularly Europe) need to get stricter.
- pdpi 5y agoWhat does that achieve, though?
- jiofih 5y agoPressure to stop pulling this kind of bs if they want to remain a viable economy in Europe. Honestly, I wish the next step would be for NATO to step in and restore the country to a legitimate government. Between this, Syria, Lebanon, Ukraine, China, Israel, the world has been way too conivent with the destruction of democracy.
- pdpi 5y agoSanctions only achieve that if they punish the illegitimate government (hopefully without punishing the rest of the population). Being tough for the sake of being tough without having a clear model for what leverage you’re getting is just political posturing.
- Jeff_Brown 5y ago> if they want to remain a viable economy What a country wants is not in general what those in power want.
- vbezhenar 5y agoBelarus is in military alliance with Russia (Collective Security Treaty Organization). Any military action against Belarus will be met with Russian army defending its territory. Also I think that the more sanctions are put from West to Belarus, the closer it gets to become another Russia state. I'm not sure if that's the outcome West wants to see.
- jiofih 5y agoAnd military action from Belarus against an EU civilian aircraft should be met with what?
- vbezhenar 5y agoBelarus was within its bounds. They did not shoot aircraft, they released aircraft and all EU citizens shortly afterwards, they have legal reasons to do so (which was likely fabricated, but one can't prove that). It's a bad accident, but it's not a war.
- fakename11 5y agoAre you seriously describing this as a "bad accident"?
- jiofih 5y agoI’m appalled. Just because they didn’t kill anyone (yet, as one passenger is on their way to the firing squad) this should be fine? This is plain and simple hijacking of an international flight and not “within bounds” at all. Laws are to be followed in principle, not just technical merit, these are not computer games.
- throwaway21_ 5y agoBelarus airspace - Belarus rules. If EU civilian aircrafts doesn't like it they are free not to enter that airspace.
- throwaway21_ 5y agoYeah, you have such a great legacy when defending democracy all over the world even in cases where you were absolutely dominant military power that this one would be walk in a park - Russia would just stand down, peacefully looking NATO invading its ally on its doorstep. Fortunately no-one in NATO has such illusions.
- Mountain_Skies 5y ago>if they want to remain a viable economy in Europe. About half of Belarus's trade is with Russia. All this would accomplish is making it 90%+ and deepen ties with Russia. Might as well suggest having Russia annex Belarus as a response to the situation.
- orthoxerox 5y ago> This is not a good choice in dictatorships as the population has no choice who to vote for. The population voted for the opposition candidate, took to the streets when the results were rigged, but had no leaders willing to escalate the confrontation when the state had its pants down. The dictator has buckled his pants and has gradually reduced the opposition to posting memes in Telegram chats. And even this activity is no longer safe.
- pedrosorio 5y ago> but had no leaders willing to escalate the confrontation when the state had its pants down Are we talking about military leaders who support the current dictator? What could the leaders of the opposition have done to escalate the confrontation further?
- sam_lowry_ 5y ago> had no leaders Leaders were either killed or forced into exile.
- Otek 5y agoI know what I will write will sound like I don’t have any empathy but… hitting population hard, to the starvation even, will make them go after Lukashenko. This is why communism in Poland was defeated by the workers. They had no bread so they had to rise. Again, I would like to underline that this is not a solution that I support but history showed us this is how u make a revolution and real change
- Tade0 5y agoThat's about the worst idea possible. Many people work in neighbouring countries and cross the border regularly to see their families. Such a move would affect them the most.
- rebuilder 5y agoThat's the point, to rile up the population so much that the regime must either cave to whatever is being demanded of them or face an uprising. Will it work? Very iffy - often the only thing worse than an autocratic regime is whatever fills the power vacuum its fall creates. Disorderly transfers of power are bad business.
- Jeff_Brown 5y agoIt's easy to call for a Hail Mary strategy from afar. Protest is becoming more common[1], but protests that successfully topple regimes remain rare. I could swear I saw recent research indicating that the fraction of protest movements that lead to regime change has fallen over time, but I can't find it now. [1] https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2020/03/10/political-protests-have-become-more-widespread-and-more-frequent https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2020/03/10/politica...
- rebuilder 5y agoI don't mean to call for anything, just pointing out that sanctions mainly hurting the population may be the intended effect.
- Jeff_Brown 5y agoThat's fair. I'll soften my point, to say merely that the call is often made, not that you were making it.
- monoideism 5y agoBelarussian population has been admirably fired up for quite some time. There have been multiple uprisings. But when they're up against armed militia and police, they can't do much (this is why so many Americans are adamant about the 1st Amendment). Targeted sanctions are the only ethical option at this point. Don't make the population suffer like we did for Iraq.