15 ms·
Unfortunately, Apple has to maintain this rule because otherwise developers will implement workarounds to avoid charging in the App Store altogether. Remember
by crazygringo 5y ago
Unfortunately, Apple has to maintain this rule because otherwise developers will implement workarounds to avoid charging in the App Store altogether.
Remember when eBay charged a commission on the sale price but not shipping? Suddenly $50 items became $1 with $49 shipping -- so eBay had to charge the commission on the shipping too even though it didn't seem "fair".
Same here -- every app would turn free, and charge to unlock features within using their own payment mechanism. Apple's App Store revenue would drop to zero. No developer in their right mind would let Apple take a cut of anything.
As a general rule, app stores simply don't allow third-party payment in apps that don't go through the store, for this exact reason. It's not just Apple with this policy.
- secondcoming 5y agoCouldn't Apple recoup any losses by charging app publishers 'rent' to be listed on the app store?
- natch 5y agoNo. Think it through: free apps would not be able to afford the rent, so they would need a discount. Then in the limit all apps would become free, so as to get the discount. But some apps would be making a killing with external payment methods, while other apps would be making nothing. Meantime Apple would also be making nothing. I would think Apple has thought about this.
- joshuaissac 5y agoThey already charge this: 99 USD annually. https://developer.apple.com/programs/how-it-works/ https://developer.apple.com/programs/how-it-works/
- nsajko 5y agoIs your argument that Apple shouldn't themselves bear the responsibility of choosing an unsustainable/immoral/illegal business model?
- matz1 5y agounsustainable ? It sustained alright for many years and has brought lots of profit for apple immoral? Its subjective. I disagree and apple likely don't think its immoral illegal? isn't that what the trial is for ? to decide whether this is illegal.
- svaha1728 5y agoAnd free + ads is a moral business model?
- tmp231 5y agoNo ones forcing you to buy an iPhone; if this is really bothering you, go to Android or petition Microsoft or Amazon to start up their phone efforts again.
- josephcsible 5y agoThe problem with that is that this isn't just about end-users. Apple is being unfair to developers too, and just leaving iOS isn't a viable choice for them. Apple has a 50% market share in the US, so any American company who cut ties with them would instantly lose half of their customer base, since most people won't buy a new phone over a single app.
- tmp231 5y agoYou act like it’s the developers fault that they hitched their wagon to apple. They knew going in with eyes wide open what the deal is. They can always leave en masse to Android if they feel the deal is not fair.
- josephcsible 5y agoYes, they knew going in how unfair Apple is, but they knew the alternative, being shut out from half of their customers, was worse. And are you really suggesting that all app developers need to form a cartel to level the playing field with Apple? If not, how do you suppose they all leave en masse, rather than some staying behind to steal the market share the others left behind?
- karmakaze 5y agoThere are other ways if you're honestly trying to be fair. eBay for instance could have made 10% of (price+shipping) exempt assuming 10% was the nominal fraction before abuses.
- tyingq 5y agoI never understood why eBay didn't resell shipping to their sellers. They could have gotten very favorable rates from the carriers with that kind of leverage.
- lemoncucumber 5y ago> When you print a shipping label on eBay, our negotiated rates let you save money relative to what you would pay at the post office or to a carrier for most services, and you'll save time by not having to stand in line. The cost of the label is then charged to your invoice, PayPal account, or Processing funds if you're a managed payments seller. Source: https://www.ebay.com/help/selling/shipping-items/labels-packaging-tips/buying-printing-shipping-labels?id=4157 https://www.ebay.com/help/selling/shipping-items/labels-pack...
- tyingq 5y agoAh, well then that would have been the easy path. No commission if you pass-through charge eBay rates.
- dawnerd 5y agoYou’re also not really lying commission on the shipping when you factor in the discounts they provide and what they charge the customer. There’s some cases where you get screwed a little but it’s not as bad as a lot of people think. I still make money on shipping if it’s beaver and goes out priority.
- mapgrep 5y agoNot true, the eBay analogy is pretty flawed. Unlike with eBay this isn’t a matter of simply shifting classification of revenue - the app store is guaranteed to be the most convenient and obvious way to charge for any given app or service related to that app due to Apple’s other rules. They prevent developers from mentioning or linking other payments avenues. And if you want to charge in app of course it’s only via Apple. From what I’ve seen only big existing and strong brand services like Netflix are able to overcome these barriers and even some of those still pay Apples feee (Spotify). The playing field remains tilted heavily in Apples favor. But they (apparently) wanted even more - extensive compensation for economic activity that happens far from the App Store even when the link to the App Store is secondary. The economic history of this sort of activity is well documented, and the extent to which it distorts markets well established. It’s plainly an antitrust violation, and both society and the software market would be free-er and more prosperous if our laws were enforced here.
- truth_ 5y agoThis is bull. Apple deserves a "rent", and not a "cut". They are providing infrastructure and services, and they deserve a minimum rent for these, which they already take. But Apple should not take cut on every purchases made through the app. It makes no sense. AWS does not take a "cut" on every Netflix subscription bought. They just charge for the storage and traffic. This is how App Store should function.
- spiderice 5y agoI find it telling that you use AWS as an example because they are different than the apple model, while ignoring all the companies using the exact same model as apple, including how Epic charges developers to host content on the Epic store.
- bendmorris 5y agoEpic is a great example. Their own store lists alternative stores on the Epic store, like itch.io. But they don't take a cut of games bought from those stores. Once you launch itch, you're in itch.
- dijit 5y agoSteam is a better example as Epic is operating at a loss position to disrupt the incumbent.
- verall 5y agoMy friends and I play Apex through Steam, which I downloaded for free. When you click to purchase "Apex coins", it takes you straight to EA's website. Apple wants to enforce a cut on every purchase of in-game currency. Steam does not do this. And Valve allows you to sell steam keys on your own website also without paying the cut, so long as you don't undercut the steam store.
- ninjinxo 5y ago
- mthoms 5y agoApple requires developers to offer sign-in with Apple if they use other sign-in systems (like FB). They could have the same requirement with payments. Users should be given the option of using Apple's system if they want to. After all, It's Apples' argument that their payment system is light-years better for consumers. If true, then users will naturally gravitate towards Apples' payment system. Right? This would result in a cycle where Apple (and other payment systems) are incentivised to continuously improve. What's wrong with that? Why not let the consumers decide what is best? Let Apple's payment system compete on its actual merits. Apple says it's a much better system after all. I say - let them prove it. They should "put up or shut up", so to speak.
- pkulak 5y agoBut then if you force every option to be priced the same, despite how much it costs the developer, then you're distorting everything again. For example, I can pay $0.99 to buy a game using Square or Apple, but Apple takes a 30% cut and will give me a full refund if I don't like the game. I chose Apple every time, but not because it's "better", it's just better for me and I'm not the one paying for it.
- mthoms 5y agoBeing able to get a refund is quantifiably better. What do you mean? Are you suggesting other vendors would be unable to compete with that for some reason? As an aside: I don't think the same pricing among different vendors is necessarily a requirement. If one entity offers more security or other benefits, then their pricing should reflect that.
- mcny 5y agoHow is this different from credit cards that have "rewards"? If you think of the independent software vendors as the corner store where you buy groceries and Apple as Visa or some payment processor... Actually now that I think about it the difference is the walled garden. I think pretty much the only compromise I can accept is something like Apple and Google must be required to add something like F-Droid that is run at arms length from Apple and Google and accepts third party software repositories. This way users can download and use any software they like from any repository anywhere. The benefit for Apple and Google is we won't shut them down and really they have inertia behind them so many if not most people will stick to the default stores, and Google can forbid OEMs from adding applications or repositories. A user must do so deliberately and manually. The benefit for users is applications installed from F-Droid will be able to auto update. The benefit for independent software vendors is they can publish their stuff outside of app store and play store and not have to adhere to any policy by the app store or play store and not have to pay any money to the default stores. Anything less and we are basically at status quo.
- abecedarius 5y ago'has to'? App store policies were not handed down on stone tablets on Mount Sinai. Charges that better track the incremental costs are not a logical contradiction.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y ago>otherwise developers will implement workarounds to avoid charging in the App Store altogether. The Windows store has plenty of applications despite having fees (5%). As an aside- to me that seems like an important differentiating factor. Apps must pay a fee to be on these platforms. Who do they pay the fee to? Whoever they pay a fee to shouldn't be allowed to also have apps on there since this is unfair and anti competitive. Fees do not negatively affect Apple but they negatively affect competition.
- yyyk 5y ago>Same here -- every app would turn free, and charge to unlock features within using their own payment mechanism. This is trivial to deal with. Apple already has rules on apps, they could go from banning fremium apps, to disallowing apps without a substantial free version to enforcing a reporting API on payments. What they can't do is use their position in one market to force marketshare in another market (payment processors). That's classic anticompetitive behaviour. (Aside, freemium apps have a low reputation, and that's why other stores without that rule aren't overrun with such apps)
- tgsovlerkhgsel 5y ago> Same here -- every app would turn free, and charge to unlock features within using their own payment mechanism. Not necessarily. Apple would likely be unable to extract the rents it currently does, but if a dev has the choice of paying a 5% fee using an rarely-used payment system, or paying a 15% fee using a payment system that most users already have set up and that has very little friction, the latter is likely more profitable.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 5y ago> No developer in their right mind would let Apple take a cut of anything. No developer in their right mind would let Apple take a 30% cut of anything. Most developers would pay Apple a 3% cut in order to use Apple's built in-payment mechanism, and not force their users to leave the app and type their credit card information into a browser. 30% is exploitive, and not at all proportional to the value provided. People pay it because they have to, not because it's fair.
- MR4D 5y agoVisa charges you 3% but doesn’t have an online store that I can find your app on, and don’t run security checks against your app to check for malicious apps, etc. So I think we can agree that a realistic number for Apple is definitely above 3% for the service they provide. We can argue about 30%, and that’s a good discussion, but 3% is no way comparable.
- thekyle 5y agoI think most credit card processors charge something like 30 cents + 2.9%. On large purchases that's about 3%, but on smaller transactions (like those usually used in mobile apps) that 30 cents dominates and could end up being about 30%. So from that perspective Apple's 30% cut could be a good deal in some cases.
- GeneralTspoon 5y agoIt's not a "good deal" in any case.... The minimum purchase price on iOS is $0.99, so at worst you'd be paying basically the same rate (~30%). But most payment processors offer separate pricing for micro-transactions (e.g. Paypal is 5% + $0.05 IIRC). Which works out at around 10% for a $0.99 transaction. And actually - Adyen offer much better pricing than the "Stripe rate" of $0.30 + 2.9% in the first place.
- anonymouse008 5y agoA few years ago when making a micro transaction app, PayPal only allowed one type of fee structure — either the 5% or the 2.9%. Meaning you couldn’t segregate low tickets from high tickets and get the most optimal fee - your whole merchant account was one fee or the other. ‘Twas quite a PITA
- MereInterest 5y agoThat argument might hold water if Apple allowed for other methods of software installation. Since they don't, that argument is pretty hollow.
- golemotron 5y ago> Unfortunately, Apple has to maintain this rule because otherwise developers will implement workarounds to avoid charging in the App Store altogether If the decision goes against Apple, I'd be surprised if they didn't just 'charge rent' to be on the App Store, just like a retail mall charges stores. Apple would have to take on the additional work of negotiating with each App, which would likely be "take it or leave it" pricing for all except the big ones, but I can't imagine it being illegal. That doesn't cut to the core claim of lack of competition, though, and that's why the choice of remedy here will be interesting.
- sosborn 5y ago> just like a retail mall charges stores Of course, as we all know, rent in a retail mall often includes a percentage cut of monthly revenue, so we would be right back where we started.
- mdoms 5y agoNo they don't "have to". Every other platform gets by just fine without this rule. Windows Store, Play Store, Samsung Store, Steam, Origin, Epic Game Store, even Apple's own MacOS store.
- mdoms 5y ago> As a general rule, app stores simply don't allow third-party payment in apps that don't go through the store, for this exact reason. It's not just Apple with this policy. This is not a "general rule". I can't think of any examples other than Apple's app store.
- michaelmrose 5y agoIt is literally just Apple because you can install apps outside the company store on other platforms. The inability to install outside the store is what makes disallowing outside payment an issue. The combination means that you can't sell to a customer without going through apple because they have used their control of the hardware to take the decision of whom to do business with from you in order to stand there with their hand out.
- paulmd 5y agoallowing sideloading instantly shreds user privacy because any sufficiently-large customer (f.ex facebook) will immediately demand their app be sideloaded to bypass app review, and given full permissions so they can scrape everything. Facebook for example has already gotten their hand slapped for doing exactly this using their developer credentials, and if it suddenly becomes viable to do this for the full user-base then it will happen immediately and without any recourse by users. https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2019/01/facebook-and-google-offered-gift-cards-for-root-level-access-to-ios-users-data/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2019/01/facebook-and-google-... that is the true red-line from a user perspective. go on and have your spat about whether 30% is fair or not, but the app-review process is the keystone on which the permissions system rests, allowing sideloading is tantamount to allowing all major apps full-permissions overnight and essentially making the permissions system meaningless. the only viable solution I can see that allows third-party app stores would be to require that Apple still review all apps on third-party app stores to enforce the requirements surrounding permissioning (i.e. having a valid reason to request the permissions you're requesting) and they would still need to charge for that. "third party app stores without any review, but Apple still gets a cut" would be the worst of all possible outcomes.
- michaelmrose 5y agoIts the users phone let them decide. Apple can strongly encourage users to stick to first party stores and require developers to agree to terms and conditions to access the sdk. Warn users who side load in as scary terms as you please. Nobody who doesn't opt in for privacy shredding will have their privacy shredded.
- rorykoehler 5y agoWhat happens if I buy it on Google Play on my android device and then use it on my iPhone? This is a preposterous idea.
- huhtenberg 5y ago> to avoid charging in the App Store altogether. Not if the AppStore is to offer competitive processing fees.
- perryizgr8 5y ago> otherwise developers will implement workarounds to avoid charging in the App Store altogether That's fine. Apple have this amazing review system that is really thorough and that is funded by every single developer paying into it. That's the main reason Apple considers their store to be so safe and useful for customers.
- raffraffraff 5y agoHow does it work for trading apps like Coinbase, Robinhood, Degiro, Binance etc?