6 ms·
> since he does circuit board repair for Apple devices. And thus, the insight comes from someone who only repairs the components, not someone who knows about
by judge2020 5y ago
> since he does circuit board repair for Apple devices.
And thus, the insight comes from someone who only repairs the components, not someone who knows about designing them. I wouldn't trust my mechanic to tell me that my car's engine was designed badly because chances are that opinion is solely based on how easy/cheap it is to repair.
- protomyth 5y agoYou have a low opinion of your mechanic. Operational knowledge is very important and designs that look good at design time sometimes deal poorly with the world. The iPhone 6 and the butterfly keyboard show designs that were not good in actual operation. Mechanics worth their salt know great engine design beyond easy/cheap to repair. Please don't take this attitude as a developer towards your operations / support staff.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoI agree with your comment/sentiment, but to be a little more nuanced: I can tell you that butterfly keyboards suck but I am not qualified to say how they should have been designed.
- bogwog 5y ago> but I am not qualified to say how they should have been designed. Right to repair isn't about telling companies how they should design their products.
- inb4_cancelled 5y agoIt often sounds like that to me.
- bogwog 5y agoProbably because of comments like the one I responded to, which are spreading misinformation. A good resource is: https://fighttorepair.org https://fighttorepair.org
- judge2020 5y agoMy point is that some people try to and want right to repair to force companies to make their computers more modular in order to make them repairable, when that might stifle innovation.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoThat wasn't my point. I was responding to the notion that a mechanic is qualified to tell the engineer his job. ;-)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jrsj 5y agoMechanics are generally pretty knowledgeable about reliability of various vehicles and their components generally; many are genuinely interested in these things and not just repairability as it relates to their job. I would imagine something similar is true here
- bombcar 5y agoMechanics can get a slightly biased view on things - for example, they’re more likely to like less reliable vehicle that’s dead simple to work on compared to a more reliable vehicle that’s harder to repair (or they rarely see).
- jjoonathan 5y agoRight, this is absolutely the case with Rossman. He makes no attempt to control for the base rate.
- RHSeeger 5y agoI would argue that, the harder/more expensive it is to repair a consumer car, the worse it is designed. It's not the only factor, but it is an important one to a LOT of people.
- manigandham 5y agoWhat are those chances? Are you judging their experience based on your non-experience? How would you know what bad design is and the reasons for it?
- gambiting 5y agoI get your point, but even your car mechanic would be able to tell if a component they worked with previously has changed only to make it more difficult to replace. You might argue "how do you know that was the only reason" - well, Rossman has a video on a USB-C charging controller embedded into the macbooks, previously if that burnt out(and they do burn out) he could just buy the chip itself online for a dollar. But after one iteration of macbooks, apple replaced it with identical chip with a changed pin layout and model number incremented by one - and they have secured exclusive production of this chip, so you can't buy this for a dollar any more. There is no hidden design reason here - it was clearly changed to stop people like him from repairing macbooks, because their specific chip revision is not available on the open market.
- dijit 5y agoFor the little it’s worth: cars are mostly computer now. I come from a family of mechanics, my grandfather lamented new cars and their electronics because it’s harder to repair, he doesn’t try to understand the reason why, just that it’s harder now because the manufacturers “did it to him” to prevent third party repairs. You can argue that the electronics are to prevent cheaper repairs, but there is another truth there: the ECU is an almost required component for decent fuel efficiency.
- BombNullIsland 5y agoPerhaps. But it was a deliberate design decision to place certain sensors and actuators that may need repair in inaccessible locations. Pumps, spark plugs and chains need to be removable without major disassembly of the engine. Shift solenoids are a nasty problem that I've run into. They don't need to be hidden inside the transmission. And the transmission doesn't require the entire engine to be dropped to remove it. This was done to be consumer hostile and to maximize dealer shop hours. Batteries in most german cars are also deliberately placed under major engine components, whereas my Mazda 3 requires two minutes and one socket to replace. Shop hours. This all needs to be stopped. Major components need to be able to be replaced, for all appliances and machines. Laws need to be changed to force this.
- indymike 5y ago> chances are that opinion is solely based on how easy/cheap it is to repair. When your mechanic says don't buy a car with a specific motor... You might just want to listen.
- protomyth 5y agoOr other things. Brought in my dad's car to a local mechanic because the driver's side door handle was broken. He told me its too damn common on that manufacturers cars from a range of years. Came back later in the day and he showed me the plastic part that had broken. He replaced it with an aluminum part he made. When you find a good mechanic, listen to them.
- Causality1 5y agoIf your mechanic tells you not to buy a model of car because he keeps seeing them come in with engine failure at low mileage you'd be a fool not to listen to him.
- sircastor 5y agoI think you’re not giving him his due credit. He may only be fixing there devices, but that gives him a unique perspective on how the design behaves in the field. Having watched quite a lot of his videos, he is, at the very least a competent electrical engineer, if not a formally trained one. On top of explaining a problem, he narrates why the problem is happening, which is indicative of solid understanding.
- Zak 5y agoA mechanic is well-positioned to notice that a particular car engine has an unusually high rate of a certain type of failure, and very often to identify the root cause of said failure. If Subaru head gaskets fail because they're bathed in fluids when the engine isn't running, and Ford Tritons spit out spark plugs because they only used 3.5 threads in an aluminum head, mechanics who work on them will notice. Rossmann is in an equivalent position. Of course there may be good explanations for design decisions that negatively impact reliability, but it's reasonable for owners to be grumpy about it. It also wouldn't completely shock me if there's a former Ford engineer out there somewhere collecting a paycheck from Helicoil, a manufacturer of threaded inserts used to repair stripped spark plug holes, with no current job duties.
- mokus 5y agoA mechanic is in a good position to notice that when a car fails, it tends to fail in certain ways. Far too often, though, they then generalize to claims that the car is likely to fail in that way, but that is not necessarily the case. It may be that they fail 1% as often as competitors and due to a relatively fewer number of causes. Without being in a position to see the absolute failure rate, a mechanic may incorrectly conclude that those parts they see failing are especially badly designed even if they are more reliable than the industry average.
- bsder 5y ago> I wouldn't trust my mechanic to tell me that my car's engine was designed badly Um, I would. Easiness of repair is a part of a car lifecycle. When buying a new car, my first stop is my mechanic. They know all the failure modes of the new cars. They also know which cars don't have common failure modes. There are engines where you have to drop the whole thing to do basic things like change spark plugs. There are engines where if you lose the timing belt the engine will eat itself. etc. Those are badly designed engines.