10 ms·
For soccer players, the less brain they use, the better for penalty kicks
- Thorentis 5y agoI think this is one of those "when you start thinking about it, you mess up" scenarios that I encounter with plenty of things. Like when playing a piece of piano music from memory - as soon as I start trying to think about which notes come next, I make mistakes and sometimes even have mental blanks and need to take a break before "remembering" again.
- hamandcheese 5y agoIs it possible that the causality is reversed? Maybe you start thinking because your subconscious brain doesn’t know what to do next.
- taneq 5y agoIf that were so then putting someone else off their game by drawing their attention to a particular aspect of their game and making them self conscious would be less effective.
- mbreese 5y agoNot the parent, but no. Once you’re playing music from memory, your brain already knows the notes/fingering/etc. It’s that when you start thinking, you get out of the “flow”. Too much thinking will pull you right out and then you need to work to get back in it.
- dnh44 5y agoA few years ago a replayed an old video game that I hadn't played since childhood. There are a few parts of the game that were quite difficult and involved a fairly complicated sequence of events, one of them being the final boss battle. When I got to the boss I remembered the battle being quite complicated and intense but I couldn't remember where to move, when to jump, or when to attack. But after a few tries as if by magic my fingers took over and executed the sequence of buttons flawlessly. It was amazing because I didn't consciously know what came next but my fingers did. I also felt a sense of euphoria as the memory came back to me; it was a really interesting thing to experience.
- globular-toast 5y agoYep, I get this with guitar and signing too. If I think about it too much my voice tightens up and I'll start missing notes. The same thing with dancing. I realised long ago that I'm not naturally good at these things because I find it impossible to switch off my brain. When I dance I'm thinking "which direction should I move in" when should I spin my partner" etc. Ask anyone who dances how they know the answers to these questions and they can't tell you. They just don't think about it.
- Glide 5y agoThis is so true. It’s especially true when a dance floor is crowded or it’s harder to listen to the music. It’s harder to "cut loose" if one or two restrictions are going on. For dancing, a couple things helped me out. Repetition and practice. Practicing whole movements together, e.g. footwork with the lead, there is a strong relationship between footwork and your ability to gently exert force and direction. Sure I learned a tuck turn to counts, but I never think about the count of it when leading it, it is engrained into the overall movement I want to execute. There’s an interesting phenomenon that happens at dance events with a heavy teaching component. The first night of dancing is pretty good and when lessons go underway the level of the room slightly drops because people are trying new things. Incorporating new things would do that and it happens, albeit awkwardly.
- IvanLudvig 5y agoI think sometimes stuttering can be explained the same way
- h0nd 5y agoIt does not only apply for penalty kicks. I encountered this situation on the pitch regularly, especially when I had time instead of pressure. Same in table tennis. I tend to make unforced errors the more time I got.
- iamben 5y agoIf you haven't read it, "The Inner Game of Tennis" by W. Timothy Gallway (https://www.amazon.co.uk/Inner-Game-Tennis-ultimate-performance/dp/1447288505 https://www.amazon.co.uk/Inner-Game-Tennis-ultimate-performa...) is worth a go. Whilst it's technically a tennis coaching book, the tennis is really just an example to explain bigger things. Anyway, there's a great story in that book where he says something like "if you want to put someone off their game, compliment them on how strong their backhand [or whatever] is today. From then on they'll think about it before every stroke and destroy their own performance."
- stephenhuey 5y agoThat definitely happens to me. Additional thoughts go through a pro player’s head during penalty kicks. 11 years ago I was fascinated by a short Freakonomics podcast. The data shows that the best chance of scoring is to kick it straight down the center to the keeper. However, most people won’t do this even though their odds are better since the pain of kicking it to a keeper who does not dive to the side and instead catches your ball is far greater than not scoring! https://freakonomics.com/2010/06/14/what-to-do-with-your-penalty-kick/ https://freakonomics.com/2010/06/14/what-to-do-with-your-pen...
- im3w1l 5y agoScientific studies also show that "rock" is the best throw in rock-paper-scissor*. Always shooting center is as ridiculous as always throwing "rock". * Rock and scissor are both thrown at 35%, with paper at 29.6%. The article suggests throwing paper to exploit that, but that makes no sense, since you will win 35% lose 35% and draw 29.6%. Rock on the other hand wins at 35%, draw 35% and lose 29.6% https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/the-blame-game/201504/the-surprising-psychology-rock-paper-scissors https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/the-blame-game/20150...
- schaefer 5y agoIn a one time throw against a complete stranger, okay. But your friends will notice that you always throw rock, and you start to lose 100% of the time.
- solids 5y agoThis kind of experiments always make me think why we experience consciousness, and where is the evolutionary advantage of having it at all.
- xyzelement 5y agoThere are some things you can do better on instinct and some things you need to be conscious. Shooting penalty kicks falls into the former. Organizing the soccer match into the later :) Even on the instinctual level, you need consciousness to hone your instincts. For example things like physical therapy or even athletic training are conscious interventions to reshape your instinct. The best penalty kickers in the world likely made a conscious choice at some point to practice these kicks until their good form became habitual.
- finiteseries 5y agoBlindsight by Peter Watts for a fun book in this direction.
- Bayart 5y agoTo put it in computer terms : it's the same reason why we have task-specific hardware and general purpose hardware and software. The more a task reoccurs, the more you benefit from a device dedicated to the task. And the more heterogeneous your workload is, the more you benefit from broadly defined non-specialized capabilities. In that respect, the beauty of the human brain is that it can go from one to the other depending on your habits.
- weinzierl 5y agoI guess every musician knows this as well: You are in the perfect flow, groovin' along, you know what I mean, and then the moment you start thinking... you mess up. Sometimes I like to believe the mastery of consciously shifting attention to some part while not disturbing the other tracks that run subconsciously in your head is one distinguishing feature of the real virtuoso.
- tgv 5y agoIn music, "conscious" thinking deteriorates performance, because you'll be too late. It adds at least 100ms, but often more (note: there are explanations that model the delay as extra processing, or as interference, or as inhibition), so you'll drop out of the rhythm in no time. It also messes up fast fingering, so you'll be out of tune as well. Motor functions are really time sensitive. Try to write a word while thinking what your fingers have to do to move the pen... I'm not sure this study shows this, though. Lesser activity may be caused by other effects, e.g. because they're better trained, they can set up the motor program (which is often ballistic) in less time. There's also an account where accuracy is linked to larger ensembles of neurons firing simultaneously, so inaccuracy might look the same as prolonged activity.
- notahacker 5y agoThe flip side of this is that some of the best elite penalty takers essentially outthink the opposing goalkeeper. The safest penalty is placed slightly to the opposite side to the one the keeper dives to, which has plenty of margin for error (and if the keeper doesn't move early they're not saving anything that isn't down the middle) Smashing a ball into the top corner [without needing to think about it] is also unsaveable and popular with elite penalty takers, but the margin for error in how you actually kick the ball is smaller: a slight miscue and your penalty is off target (or a "nice height" for a keeper that reads where you're shooting).
- JoeAltmaier 5y agoIn fact, don't "down the middle" kicks succeed more often?
- canuckintime 5y ago> and if the keeper doesn't move early they're not saving anything that isn't down the middle Most penalties are poorly taken. I hate seeing a keeper dive early to a random side only to be beaten by a weak shot down the middle. I assume that keepers don't have faith in their nerves/reactions and thus have to force their bodies to dive before the shot is taken. Otherwise the best strategy for the keeper is to wait for the shot
- leemailll 5y agoYeah, wait for the shot and always late for a save. They do this for a living, they move before ball rolling for a reason: human not fast enough for a shot from pro.
- canuckintime 5y agoNot fast enough for a shot from a pro, a good shot to the top right corner sure. But a penalty shot straight down the middle? A keeper isn't fast enough to catch that?
- 5y ago
- DevX101 5y agoExpert athletes are able to offload much of the mental processing of their game to the subconscious. We all do this to some degree (most of us aren't solving differential equations in real time to catch a ball), but great athletes are able to do this for many more sport specific tasks than casual players. Here's a mindblowing video of Ronaldo making a goal in complete darkness after only seeing the first few milliseconds of the ball path: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t03LHpeWnpA&t=330s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t03LHpeWnpA&t=330s
- mettamage 5y agoDefinitely a good example of Kahneman
- iamben 5y agoThat's a wonderful video. What a talent. Reminded me of a product I read about a while ago - https://www.bernell.com/product/STROBE/Vision_Therapy_BestSellers https://www.bernell.com/product/STROBE/Vision_Therapy_BestSe... - the glasses flicker between clear and not so you learn to interpret the motion of the ball rather than relying on vision alone. Very cool!
- Spooky23 5y agoThe line between experts and non-experts is how they manage. I’m a little league coach, currently with 9-10 year olds. Once the kids get comfortable with basic mechanics, the real challenge of the game is not thinking about mechanics, while thinking about the tactical picture. It’s difficult - in our case right now, working with a talented pitcher who starts to panic and throws wild when she gets rattled in the game (by a walk, hit, etc). The joyous part as a coach is that with repetition and support, the kids figure it out! That cycle continues.
- clusterhacks 5y agoI loved coaching baseball for that age group. For our local rec league levels that is the first entry to kid-pitch. It was really off-putting how outcome focused some of our other coaches were. I am a player development nerd (Driveline youth certified now - highly recommended - and love their philosophy shaped to rec players) and hated playing teams with coaches that tried to manipulate our player draft process to vacuum up all the better athletes. Those were the teams that would max out their two pitchers' pitch counts every game and cycle all the non-starters on their team through right field. I moved onto softball coaching at our local middle school and enjoy player development and coaching at that level too. We lost this year to pandemic closures but I am looking forward to going full-on gamified tech next year (Blast sensors, pocket radar, lots of quick fun drills to keep things moving).
- mrfusion 5y agoOn the other hand, would you want to involve as much brain as possible during practice?
- klyrs 5y agoPerfect practice makes perfect. It is important to think and analyze, to correct bad habits. But once you've got the basics down, you then need to learn to let go and trust muscle memory. If you jump straight into "don't overthink it" while you're still making newbie mistakes, then practice is actually harmful and will impede further skill development
- fnord77 5y agothis seems like "Zen and the art of Archery" stuff
- vagrantJin 5y agoI'm going to press X to doubt since this looks like a load. Too many variables missing up to and including a player just not being good at spot kicks despite their obvious technical ability.
- vxNsr 5y agoA great book on this subject is Chatter[0] by Ethan Kross, he talks about how our inner voice can often be our own worst enemy and also suggests ways to combat it. https://smile.amazon.com/Chatter-Voice-Head-Matters-Harness-ebook/dp/B087PL8YVQ/ref=nodl_ https://smile.amazon.com/Chatter-Voice-Head-Matters-Harness-...
- binbag 5y agoTrying so hard not to make a quip about footballers finding “thinking less” very easy…
- eplanit 5y agoHumor aside, it does raise a legitimate question regarding stereotypes -- there may be very good (biological, psychological) reasons that correlate athleticism with not-so-impressive cognitive skills.
- sys_64738 5y agoUnfortunately PK takers are human too so they can get psych'd out by the goalkeeper who steps towards them to delay the time to take the PK. Probably a more important stat is how many PKs are scored the longer the ball sits on the penalty circle? As the feeling is that the longer it is the more likely the PK taker will bottle it and hit it over the bar.
- Ologn 5y agoThere was a paper in Nature where scientists did magnetic imaging of the brain of grandmaster chess players, as well as of advanced amateur players. They found that when evaluating a move, for grandmasters the frontal and parietal cortices had gamma bursts, whereas for amateurs the medial temporal lobe had gamma bursts. This tends to indicate that when grandmasters evaluate a move they are accessing their memory, whereas an amateur evaluating a move is reasoning about it. I would guess that the same holds true in soccer. https://www.nature.com/articles/35088119 https://www.nature.com/articles/35088119
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- yawaworht1978 5y agoIt is the same principle for tennis players when they do a down the line forehand passing shot from running, it is all muscle memory, it is one of the shots that has higher chances of missing if the player gets too much time to think about it.
- mrbonner 5y agoAnybody remember the “last samurai”? : “too many minds” when they parry.
- allenu 5y agoNot quite the same, but this is like me walking down the stairs and becoming conscious of my walking. I end up overthinking my steps and have to go more slowly otherwise I risk missing a step and falling.
- commiepatrol 5y agoSo this man is a genius? https://youtu.be/o8cZmeZnmc4 https://youtu.be/o8cZmeZnmc4
- squarefoot 5y agoHardly surprising since penalties are very easy to score if the player hits the ball properly and the keeper doesn't move before the kick (which would trigger a penalty repeat). There's one rule to score a penalty 100% of times: keep the ball ground level and aim near one of the goal posts base. If the kicker doesn't screw up, then it's a goal, no matter how good and well trained is the keeper: there's just not enough time to go there, that's why the secret is keeping the ball low: you can fight gravity with a strong high or lateral jump, but you can't help gravity by adding more force to the gravity pulling you down. Once this has become automatic, the player only has to keep cold and ignore the keeper, which naturally will do anything to distract him, therefore it's only a matter of making the thing automatic and don't think about it. Mental coaching, which recently has become a thing in football too, can help with this.
- andreime 5y agoThe keeper can move. The penalty would be repeated if he doesn't have one foot on the line. There's plenty of GKs that start their jump movement before the ball is kicked. example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JNQ6XdrEhqc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JNQ6XdrEhqc edit, better example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I4EtbA2Nlyw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I4EtbA2Nlyw
- acituan 5y agoMisleading title, the study didn't demonstrate anything about the amount of brain activity, but the locale of brain activity. From the study; > Players who were successful under pressure showed most of their activity in the motor cortex of the brain. This is the part of the brain active during movement. > Players who were unsuccessful showed elevated activity in the pre-frontal cortex and left temporal cortex areas of the brain. If anything, this demonstrates the difference between "computational cognition" vs "embodied cognition", latter being more adaptive in this particular task. That said, I find the explanation of the researchers dubious; we don't know if doing prefrontal computation is hampering motor performance or it is simply trying to compensate a deficiency in the procedural knowledge of the player. Considering the fact that half of the participants were selected from inexperienced players, and the average participant age was around 22, the latter is the more likely explanation.
- SnowProblem 5y agoA slight tangent, but it's amazing what the human mind can do in the background. We've all had this experience driving - an amazingly complex task - where you get to your destination you forget how you got there. Well, the best freestyle rapper in the world right now is similar and on YouTube: Harry Mack. Before going on with your day, I promise it's worth your time to check him out: https://youtu.be/U6dbmuCfdyk?t=753 https://youtu.be/U6dbmuCfdyk?t=753. He's amazing. In other videos, he breaks down how he does what he does, and so much of his rap is automatic. This is the only way. He's thinking 2 or 3 bars ahead at all times while speaking what's been decided. He's trying to remember key words and string together stories and structure, while at the same time letting his background processes create the rhythm and specifics. What talent.
- jollybean 5y agoThis is known I think. If you 'think' about how you 'walk across the room' - you don't do it naturally. You don't 'win' during the 'game' - you 'win' during practice, when you are teaching your body all of the skills, and how to score like a walk across the room. There's nothing you can do at 'game time' but to literally let your subconscious use what it's learned. Golf is I think the game with the most subtle and minute aspects to that, and you can see the players are so keen on ritual, consistency, routine. 'Everything in it's right place' before the match and you're thinking is calm.
- snvzz 5y agoRandom obvious statement: For the same task and results, the less brain used the better. It means your brain is more efficient. More headroom. I take the story's just an example of what this means in practice.
- drumhead 5y agoThe best penalty taker I ever saw was Alan Shearer(English Footballer). He's just pick his spot and smash it as hard as he could. He was very successful.
- sershe 5y agoDisclaimer, I haven't played soccer in 15 years, but I've played some and watched a lot :) It is actually pretty hard to miss the box on the penalty kick if you are aiming at the box, as opposed to e.g. aiming for the bottom left corner. Then, (given ~equal skill levels) it is pretty much impossible to react to a strong penalty kick and still have time to dive, given the speed and distance - that's why many goalkeepers guess; the stronger the kick, the harder to react. And, as far as I could tell many players have obvious generic "tells" based on how their body, foot etc. align, and especially where they look before and during the run, so that improved guessing. So the best strategy is a strong kick, and deciding the general direction randomly at the last moment. Note how many penalty kicks on the highest levels of play go straight down the middle of the goal, with the goalkeeper diving away from what might seem like an "easy" one to deflect. But if you do something clever and aim, then you are more likely to make the kick weaker, miss, or allow the goalkeeper to guess your plan.
- failwhaleshark 5y agoToo many mind! Too many mind? Hai, mind the ball, mind the players, watch goalie -- too many mind. NO MIND! https://wallpapertag.com/wallpaper/middle/1/d/c/783939-the-last-samurai-wallpaper-1920x1440-for-tablet.jpg https://wallpapertag.com/wallpaper/middle/1/d/c/783939-the-l...
- failwhaleshark 5y agoI look at it like any skill worth mastering is worth training until doing without conscious effort. Like walking, talking, riding a bicycle, dancing, BJJ, MMA, witty-banter, or chatting-up one's preferred amorous demographic: conscious thinking is nervous, insecure, self-doubting, clumsy, ungraceful... and just plain bad.
- NoPicklez 5y agoI do this with my phone passcode, something happens have I have to think intently about it and I can't remember what the code is.